The Effect of Enterprise Crowdsourcing Systems on Employees’ Innovative Behavior and Job Performance

Vetrivadivel Vel, Insu Park, Jun LiuProceedings of the ... Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences/Proceedings of the Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Employees are primary sources of innovative ideas through their unique insights into products, processes, and customers. Enterprise crowdsourcing systems (ECSs) are designed to capture and refine these ideas, yet participation remains strikingly low—often under 8% at major firms like Pfizer and HCL Technologies. This research investigates the factors that drive active ECS participation and its subsequent impact on job performance. Using a multi-actor dyadic survey of 183 employee-manager pairs, the study identifies "Creative Knowledge Application" as a central driver of both employee satisfaction and objective performance outcomes.

Introduction

While digital Enterprise Crowdsourcing Systems (ECSs) have replaced traditional suggestion boxes, they often struggle with engagement. Participation rates at companies like Polaris Industries (3%) and HCL Technologies (2%) highlight a significant gap between the potential of these platforms and their actual use. This study explores how organizations can bridge this gap by fostering a culture of knowledge sharing and providing specific system support for creative tasks.

Methodology

The researchers employed a robust multi-actor dyadic survey method to minimize common method bias. Data was collected from 183 pairs of employees and their direct supervisors across 15 US-based IT companies.

  • Data Collection: Employees reported on their knowledge-sharing behaviors and system satisfaction, while supervisors provided objective ratings for innovative behavior and job performance.
  • Analysis: The study used Partial Least Squares (PLS) structural equation modeling to test the causal relationships between latent variables such as "Creative Knowledge Application" (CKA) and "ECS Satisfaction."

The sample was diverse, with 54% male participants and a significant portion (41.5%) over age 40. Over 30% of participants had more than six years of job experience, ensuring the data reflects the perspectives of established professionals.

Key Findings and Results

The core of the model is Creative Knowledge Application (CKA)—the behavior of finding novel uses for existing resources to support job tasks. The analysis revealed that CKA is strongly influenced by two main factors: the existing culture of knowledge sharing and the perceived support the ECS provides for creative work.

Structural model showing path coefficients and R-squared values for the impact of ECS on job performance.

As shown in Figure 1, the structural model supported several key hypotheses:

  • Drivers of CKA: Knowledge Sharing ($\beta = 0.664$) and ECS Support ($\beta = 0.309$) are significant predictors of creative application.
  • Impact on Performance: CKA significantly predicts both ECS Satisfaction ($\beta = 0.523$) and Innovative Behavior ($\beta = 0.190$).
  • Performance Outcomes: Both satisfaction ($\beta = 0.688$) and innovative behavior ($\beta = 0.198$) positively impact overall job performance.

The model explains a substantial 73.2% of the variance in Job Performance, suggesting that ECS-driven satisfaction and innovation are critical components of employee success.

The Role of Satisfaction as a Mediator

A notable insight from the study is that ECS Satisfaction acts as a more powerful mediator for job performance than innovative behavior itself. While the system encourages innovation, its primary value often lies in making employees feel more effective and supported in their daily roles.

Mediation analysis showing the paths from Creative Knowledge Application (CKA) to Job Performance (Perf) through Satisfaction (ECS SAT) and Innovative Behavior (INB).

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research demonstrates that ECSs are most effective when they are integrated into a broader culture of knowledge sharing. However, the study is limited by its focus on the IT sector and its cross-sectional nature. Future research should explore these dynamics in traditional industries like manufacturing and healthcare, and consider longitudinal studies to track how ECS usage impacts performance over time. Additionally, investigating the "implementation gap"—where submitted ideas are never realized—could provide deeper insights into long-term employee morale and participation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Employees are main sources of innovative ideas via their insights of companies’ products, processes, customers, and competitors. Enterprise crowdsourcing systems (ECSs) are used to collect, refine, and realize ideas. However, only a small percent of employees submit ideas - about 7.7% at Pfizer, 2% at HCL Technologies, and 3% at Polaris Industries. Why employee’s participation is low? More specifically, what are the factors that can lead employees to use ECS actively to submit and share their innovative ideas for improving their job performance? In this research, we used a multi-actor dyadic survey to survey 183 employees and their managers and conducted data analysis to understand the impact of ECS factors on employees’ job performance. The findings of this study can help organizations refine their ECSs and innovation initiatives.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{vel2018effect,
  author = {Vetrivadivel Vel and Insu Park and Jun Liu},
  title = {{The Effect of Enterprise Crowdsourcing Systems on Employees’ Innovative Behavior and Job Performance}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the ... Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences/Proceedings of the Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.24251/hicss.2018.024},
}
Figure