The effect of elastic support location on natural frequency of pipe conveying fluid

Ping Zhou, Yanqing Li, Zijun Zhang2018 · DOI

Abstract

The governing equation of pipe conveying fluid was deduced based on the Timoshenko beam model. The wave method was applied to solve the governing equation, obtaining wave reflection matrices for three typical boundary conditions and establishing a wave scattering model for the intermediate elastic support. Based on this model, the wave characteristic equation for pipes conveying fluid with intermediate elastic support was obtained through the wave train closure principle. Natural frequencies and critical fluid velocities were calculated for pipes with intermediate elastic supports at various locations.

Introduction

Pipes conveying fluid are essential components in industrial engineering, found in everything from power plants to chemical processing facilities. However, the interaction between the flowing fluid and the pipe structure can trigger vibrations that lead to fatigue or catastrophic failure.

While the dynamics of simple pipes are well-understood, real-world systems often feature intermediate elastic supports to provide stability. The challenge lies in determining the optimal location for these supports. Traditional methods like Finite Element Analysis (FEA) can be computationally heavy for complex configurations. This paper seeks a more efficient analytical approach to determine how support location affects the system's natural frequency and its critical fluid velocity (the speed at which the pipe becomes unstable and buckles).

Methodology

The authors employ two primary theoretical frameworks: the Timoshenko Beam Model and the Wave Propagation Method.

Timoshenko Beam Model

Unlike the simpler Euler-Bernoulli model, the Timoshenko model accounts for shear deformation and rotary inertia. This makes it significantly more accurate for "thick" pipes or higher-frequency vibrations where these effects become non-negligible.

Wave Propagation Method

Instead of solving the entire system as a single static entity, this method treats vibrations as waves traveling along the pipe. When a wave hits a boundary or a discontinuity, such as an intermediate support, it is reflected or transmitted. The authors derived specific matrices to describe these interactions.

Wave scattering model for an intermediate elastic support showing incident and reflected wave components.

A key technical detail is that the fluid's motion introduces a Coriolis force. This means waves traveling "upstream" move at different velocities than those traveling "downstream," requiring distinct propagation matrices ($[T_r] \neq [T_l]$). By applying the Wave Train Closure Principle—following a wave through a complete circuit of the pipe and ensuring it returns to its starting state—the authors derived the characteristic equation used to find the natural frequencies.

Key Insights and Results

The study investigated how the location of the support, denoted by distance $d$, influences the pipe's stability and vibration characteristics.

Schematic of a pipe with an intermediate elastic support located at a distance d from the left end.

The Midpoint Advantage

For the first mode of vibration (the simplest "swing"), the natural frequency is highest when the support is exactly at the midpoint ($d = L/2$). This is because the midpoint is where the pipe would naturally experience the greatest displacement; placing a support there provides the maximum restoring force. In a test case, moving the support from $d=1m$ to $d=4m$ (the midpoint) increased the 1st natural frequency from 2.032 rad/s to 4.334 rad/s.

Higher-Order Complexity

Interestingly, the "midpoint is best" rule primarily applies to the 1st order natural frequency. For 2nd and 3rd order frequencies, the optimal support location shifts, as the peaks of those vibration modes occur at different points along the pipe.

Critical Velocity ($V_{cr}$)

The fluid velocity at which the pipe buckles is also highly sensitive to support location. The authors found a symmetric relationship where stability is highest when the support is centered and drops off sharply as the support moves toward either end. This confirms that centering the support maximizes the pipe's resistance to fluid-induced buckling.

Conclusion

The results showed strong agreement with existing literature, such as research by Paidoussis, proving that the wave propagation method is a valid and efficient alternative to more complex numerical simulations. While this study focused on a single support and neglected damping, it provides a robust framework for researching multi-span pipes. Future work could explore nonlinear fluid-structure interactions where the pipe's deformation significantly alters the fluid flow itself.

Summary updated

Abstract

The governing equation of pipe conveying fluid was deduced based on Timoshenko beam model. Wave method was applied to solve the governing equation. In the process, wave reflection matrices were obtained for three typical boundary conditions and the wave scattering model was established for the intermediate elastic support. Based on the above model, the wave characteristic equation for pipe conveying fluid with intermediate elastic support was obtained through wave train closure principle. In the example, the natural frequencies and critical fluid velocities were calculated for pipe conveying fluid with the intermediate elastic support at different locations.
BibTeX
@misc{zhou2018effect,
  author = {Ping Zhou and Yanqing Li and Zijun Zhang},
  title = {{The effect of elastic support location on natural frequency of pipe conveying fluid}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.2991/ismems-17.2018.23},
}
Figure