The effect of a one-year vigorous physical activity intervention on fitness, cognitive performance and mental health in young adolescents: the Fit to Study cluster randomised controlled trial

Thomas Wassenaar, Catherine Wheatley, Nick Beale, Thomas E. Nichols, Piergiorgio Salvan, Andrew Meaney, Kathryn Atherton, Karla Díaz-Ordaz, Helen Dawes, Heidi Johansen‐BergInternational Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

A year-long, school-based vigorous physical activity (VPA) intervention, delivered through regular physical education classes, did not significantly improve cardiorespiratory fitness, cognitive function, or mental health in young adolescents. Despite the intervention's potential scalability and the critical developmental period of adolescence, low intervention fidelity and high participant dropout limited the study's ability to draw definitive conclusions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adolescence is a crucial period for brain development, characterized by increasing vulnerability to mental health issues. Physical activity (PA) is known to positively impact brain function, cognition, and mental well-being. High-intensity interval training (HIIT) and vigorous physical activity (VPA) are time-efficient and scalable approaches to increase PA. However, the effectiveness of such interventions, particularly when delivered pragmatically within school settings, on cognitive, academic, and mental health outcomes in adolescents remained unclear. This study aimed to address this gap by investigating the impact of a year-long VPA intervention on fitness, cognitive performance, and mental health in young adolescents.

Methods

The study employed a cluster-randomized controlled trial design, involving 104 secondary schools in South/Mid-England. Schools were randomly assigned to either an intervention group, where physical education (PE) teachers delivered an additional 10 minutes of VPA per PE lesson for one academic year, or a control group receiving "PE as usual." The intervention was designed to be pragmatic and scalable, integrated into existing school curricula.

Key outcome measures included:

  • Cardiorespiratory fitness (CRF): Assessed using the 20-meter shuttle run (20MSR) test.
  • Cognitive performance: Evaluated using online, computer-based tests measuring processing speed, visual relational memory, and core executive functions (working memory, inhibition, and cognitive flexibility). A latent variable model was used to capture executive function.
  • Mental health: Assessed using the Strength and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) for psychosocial problems and measures of global and physical self-esteem.

Statistical analyses included intention-to-treat (ITT) analyses using linear models and structural equation models, with adjustments for baseline values, stratification variables, and clustering within schools. A complier-average causal effect (CACE) analysis was also conducted to account for potential non-compliance.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 18,261 Year 8 pupils (aged 12-13) across 104 secondary schools in South/Mid-England. Baseline assessments were conducted at the end of Year 7, and post-intervention assessments were completed at the end of Year 8. No new datasets were introduced; the study relied on data collected from participating pupils and schools.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Scalability vs. Efficacy Trade-off: The intervention was designed for scalability and feasibility within real-world school settings. However, this pragmatic approach may have led to a lower dose of VPA and potentially less intense exercise than required to elicit significant physiological or cognitive changes.
  • The Challenge of Intervention Fidelity: A major takeaway is the significant difficulty in maintaining high intervention fidelity in large-scale, school-based trials. Low compliance among teachers and schools highlights the practical hurdles in implementing even seemingly simple interventions consistently.
  • Adolescence as a Critical Window: While adolescence is a period of significant neurobiological development and vulnerability, this study suggests that a year-long, moderately implemented VPA intervention may not be sufficient to drive measurable improvements in fitness, cognition, or mental health.
  • The Importance of Dose: The study raises questions about the optimal "dose" of HIIT/VPA for adolescents. The intervention's duration and intensity might have been too low to overcome the inertia of existing habits and developmental trajectories.

Key Results

  • No Significant Improvements: The one-year VPA intervention did not lead to statistically significant improvements in cardiorespiratory fitness, cognitive performance (including executive functions, relational memory, and processing speed), or mental health outcomes (psychosocial problems and self-esteem) compared to the control group.
  • Subgroup Analyses Null: No significant moderation of intervention effects was found based on sex, socioeconomic status, or baseline fitness levels.
  • CRF Not Linked to Other Outcomes: Changes in cardiorespiratory fitness over the year were not significantly related to changes in cognitive or mental health outcomes.
  • Low Compliance and High Dropout: The trial was marked by high dropout rates (24 schools lost to follow-up) and low intervention compliance, with only 77% of intervention schools reporting delivering the intervention in at least 50% of PE lessons. Objective measures indicated that VPA levels achieved were lower than targeted.
  • CACE Results Aligned with ITT: Complier-average causal effect (CACE) analyses, which focused on compliant schools, yielded results consistent with the primary intention-to-treat (ITT) analyses, suggesting that even among those who adhered better, the intervention did not show significant effects.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Low Intervention Fidelity: This was a major limitation, significantly impacting the study's power to detect effects. Future research needs robust measures to capture multidimensional fidelity.
  • High Dropout Rates: Significant participant and school dropout limited the sample size and potentially introduced bias.
  • Lack of Active Control Group: The study used a "PE as usual" control, which may not have been sufficiently distinct from the intervention to isolate the effects of VPA.
  • Uncertainty of "Dose": The exact dose of VPA received by participants is unclear due to fidelity issues, making it difficult to determine if the intervention was simply too low in intensity or duration.
  • No Information on Weight or Pubertal Status: Due to the scale and opt-out consent, data on weight and pubertal status, which might influence PA benefits, were not collected.

Future work should focus on:

  • Well-controlled, large-scale trials: Testing the effectiveness of HIIT-style interventions with improved implementation strategies.
  • Investigating optimal "dose": Determining the minimum effective dose of VPA/HIIT for adolescents.
  • Exploring moderators: Further investigating how factors like sex, pubertal status, and weight might influence responses to PA interventions.
  • Utilizing technology for fidelity: Employing smartphone-based applications for more accurate fidelity measurement.

Summary updated

Abstract

ISRCTN registry, 15,730,512 . Trial protocol and analysis plan for primary outcome prospectively registered on 30th March 2017. ClinicalTrials.gov , NCT03286725 . Secondary measures (focus of current manuscript) retrospectively registered on 18 September 2017.
BibTeX
@article{wassenaar2021effect,
  author = {Thomas Wassenaar and Catherine Wheatley and Nick Beale and Thomas E. Nichols and Piergiorgio Salvan and Andrew Meaney and Kathryn Atherton and Karla Díaz-Ordaz and Helen Dawes and Heidi Johansen‐Berg},
  title = {{The effect of a one-year vigorous physical activity intervention on fitness, cognitive performance and mental health in young adolescents: the Fit to Study cluster randomised controlled trial}},
  journal = {International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s12966-021-01113-y},
}
Figure