The Effect Analysis of Water Diversion on Water Quality Improvement: A Case Study in Urban Lake, China

Jingjing Li, Yunxiang Liang, Chaowang Zou, Yingshu Chen, Zhe WangWater 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the effectiveness of water diversion in improving the water quality of Lake Hou, a polluted urban lake in Wuhan, China. Using a sophisticated 2D hydrodynamic and water quality model, the research demonstrates that increasing water diversion flow significantly reduces pollutants like TP, TN, and COD, though the rate of improvement diminishes at higher flows. The findings suggest that a diversion rate of 15 m³/s offers the best balance between water quality enhancement and economic feasibility for managing urban lakes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban lakes worldwide, including those in Wuhan, China, are facing severe degradation due to rapid industrialization, urbanization, and increased pollutant discharge. This leads to a decline in water quality, impacting ecosystem health, water security, and the overall urban environment. While pollution interception and control measures are crucial, they alone are often insufficient to restore water bodies with limited natural circulation. This paper addresses the challenge of improving water quality in such lakes by analyzing the impact of water diversion, a strategy that can enhance hydrodynamic conditions and dilute pollutants. Specifically, it aims to quantify the benefits of different water diversion scenarios on key water quality parameters in Lake Hou, a representative urban lake experiencing significant pollution.

Methods

The core of this study relies on a two-dimensional (2D) coupled hydrodynamic and water quality model built using the MIKE 21 software suite. This approach allows for the simulation of water movement (hydrodynamics) and the transport and transformation of pollutants (water quality) across the lake's surface.

  • Hydrodynamic Model: This component simulates water flow patterns driven by factors like wind stress, throughput flow from rivers, and the Coriolis force. The model uses a shallow water equation framework.
  • Water Quality Model: This component simulates the concentration changes of key pollutants (TP, TN, and COD) based on advection (transport by water flow), diffusion, and source/sink terms (pollutant inputs and removal processes, including biochemical reactions).

The model was calibrated and verified using observed data for water levels and water quality parameters. The study then employed this validated model to simulate four distinct scenarios:

  1. Current Situation: Analyzing water quality under existing pollution loads.
  2. Pollution Control (Planning Year): Assessing water quality after implementing planned pollution reduction measures.
  3. Pollution Control + Water Diversion: Evaluating water quality with pollution control and varying levels of water diversion (10, 15, and 20 m³/s).
  4. Ecological Water Replenishment: Specifically focusing on the impact of different diversion flows on water quality.

Datasets

The study utilized several datasets for model setup, calibration, and validation:

  • Hydrological Data:
    • Lake Hou's underwater topography and bathymetry data.
  • Annual rainfall data for 1986 (selected as a representative dry year).
  • Monthly runoff data for Lake Hou from the Wujiashan station.
  • Annual evaporation data.
  • Monthly average wind direction and speed data.
  • Water Quality Data:
    • Measured water quality parameters (TP, TN, COD) for Lake Hou during the current low-water season and the dry season (November 2021).
  • Pollutant concentrations in the supplementary water source (Fuhuan River and Han River).
  • Pollutant load data for the current year (2015) and the planning year (2030).
  • Environmental Standards:
    • Environmental Quality Standard for Surface Water (GB3838-2002) for China was used as a benchmark for assessing water quality.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relied on existing monitoring and historical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Water Diversion is Crucial: The study strongly suggests that relying solely on pollution interception and control measures is insufficient to meet environmental quality standards for lakes with limited natural circulation. Water diversion is essential for improving hydrodynamic conditions and diluting pollutants.
  • Diminishing Returns: While increasing water diversion flow generally improves water quality, the rate of improvement decreases as the flow rate increases. This implies an optimal point beyond which further increases in diversion yield less benefit and may become economically inefficient.
  • The "Sweet Spot" for Diversion: The research identifies 15 m³/s as a potentially optimal water diversion rate for Lake Hou, offering a significant improvement in water quality while balancing economic considerations.
  • Model's Predictive Power: The validated 2D hydrodynamic and water quality model proved effective in simulating water level changes and predicting the impact of different pollution control and water diversion scenarios, providing valuable insights for lake management.
  • Connectivity is Key: The study implicitly highlights the importance of river-lake connectivity for maintaining lake health, as water diversion effectively creates or enhances this link.

Key Results

  • Model Performance: The hydrodynamic model showed good performance, with a mean relative error (MRE) of 0.27% and a correlation coefficient (R²) of 0.99 for water levels. Water quality simulations also achieved acceptable performance, with MREs for TN, TP, and COD below 23%.
  • Pollution Levels: Under the current situation (Scenario 1), Lake Hou's water quality was poor, with COD, TN, and TP concentrations frequently exceeding Class IV and even Class V standards.
  • Impact of Pollution Control: Implementing pollution control measures (Scenario 2) significantly reduced pollutant loads, but TP levels still exceeded Class IV standards year-round.
  • Water Diversion Benefits:
    • At 10 m³/s diversion, TP, TN, and COD improvements were 28.94%, 24.14%, and 14.30%, respectively.
  • At 15 m³/s diversion, improvements rose to 33.14% (TP), 27.77% (TN), and 15.57% (COD).
  • At 20 m³/s diversion, improvements reached 35.74% (TP), 30.10% (TN), and 16.29% (COD).
  • Rate of Improvement: The increase in improvement rate from 10 to 15 m³/s was 4.2% for TP, 3.56% for TN, and 1.27% for COD. From 15 to 20 m³/s, these rates further decreased to 2.6% (TP), 2.4% (TN), and 0.72% (COD), demonstrating the diminishing returns.
  • Optimal Diversion: The study suggests 15 m³/s as the most effective rate for achieving water quality goals, considering both improvement and economic factors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Diminishing Returns: A key limitation identified is the diminishing rate of water quality improvement with increasing diversion flow beyond 15 m³/s. This suggests that simply increasing diversion indefinitely is not an efficient solution.
  • Economic Justification: The authors emphasize the need for a thorough economic analysis of diversion costs versus environmental benefits when considering implementation.
  • Model Simplifications: While a 2D model is powerful, it simplifies vertical mixing and complex biochemical processes. Future work could explore 3D models for more detailed simulations.
  • Data Availability: The authors note that due to confidentiality, the original data is not conveniently available, which could limit independent verification or further analysis by other researchers.
  • Future Work: The study provides a foundation for guiding future conservation and development activities in urban lakes, suggesting that similar modeling approaches can be used to assess the impact of water diversion and other management strategies. The findings support the integration of river-lake connectivity into urban lake management plans.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid progress of society and economy on a regional level, river pollution trends have risen, causing an overwhelmingly poor water quality in urban lakes. In this study, a two-dimensional coupled hydrodynamic and water quality model was employed to assess the enhancement of water quality subsequent to the implementation of water diversion measures in Lake Hou, a representative urban lake located in Wuhan. The model was established based on detailed data collection via survey analysis, model simulation, and joint analysis. The total amount of pollutants in Lake Hou before and after pollution interception and control was compared and analyzed. The observed lake water level, discharge, and water quality parameters, including total phosphorus (TP), total nitrogen (TN), and chemical oxygen demand (COD), were utilized to evaluate the performance of the model. The results showed that the water quality of Lake Hou improved as the recharge flow increased. When the recharge flow was 10 m3/s, TP, TN, and COD improvements were 28.94%, 24.14%, and 14.30%, respectively. When the recharge flow was 15 m3/s, TP, TN, and COD improvements were 33.14%, 27.77%, and 15.57%, respectively. When the recharge flow was 20 m3/s, TP, TN, and COD improvements were 35.74%, 30.10%, and 16.29%, respectively. However, a downward trend can be observed with increasing rates of TP, TN, and COD improvements (%), from 10 m3/s to 15 m3/s, at 4.2%, 3.56%, and 1.27%, respectively. The increasing rates of TP, TN, and COD improvements (%) from 15 m3/s to 20 m3/s were 2.6%, 2.4%, and 0.27%, respectively. This study offers a valuable technical solution for the management of urban lakes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023effect,
  author = {Jingjing Li and Yunxiang Liang and Chaowang Zou and Yingshu Chen and Zhe Wang},
  title = {{The Effect Analysis of Water Diversion on Water Quality Improvement: A Case Study in Urban Lake, China}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/w15162880},
}
Figure