The effect analysis of shape design of different charging piles based on Human physiological characteristics using the MF-DFA

Yusheng Zhang, Yaoyuan Kang, Xin Guo, Pan Li, Hanqing HeScientific 2024 · DOI

Abstract

With the rapid development of new energy vehicles, the users have an increasing demand for charging piles. It is generally believed that the charging pile is a kind of practical product, and it only needs to realize the charging function. However, as a product, the shape design of the charging pile will directly affect the user experience, thus affecting product sales. Therefore, in the face of increasingly fierce market competition, when designing the shape of charging piles, it is necessary to adopt the traditional evaluation method and human physiological cognitive characteristics to evaluate the shape of charging piles more objectively. From the user's point of view, using the electroencephalogram (EEG) of the user, with the help of the multifractal detrended fluctuation analysis (MF-DFA) method, this paper comprehensively analyzes the differences in emotional cognitive characteristics between two kinds of charging piles, namely, the charging pile with a curved appearance design and the charging pile with square appearance design. The results show that there are significant differences in human physiological cognitive characteristics between two kinds of charging piles with different shapes. And different shapes of charging piles have different physiological cognitive differences for users. When designing charging pile product shapes, human beings can objectively evaluate the product shape design according to the physiological cognition differences of users, so as to optimize the charging pile product shape design.

Introduction

The rapid expansion of the New Energy Vehicle (NEV) market has transformed charging piles from simple functional utilities into critical touchpoints of user experience. While functionality is paramount, the aesthetic design of these units significantly influences consumer perception and brand loyalty. Traditional evaluation methods, such as Likert-scale surveys, often suffer from subjective biases and recall errors. This study proposes an objective framework for design evaluation by analyzing human physiological responses—specifically electroencephalogram (EEG) signals—to different industrial shapes.

Experimental Design and Methodology

The study involved 20 experienced EV drivers who were presented with 100 high-resolution images of charging piles. These stimuli were categorized into two groups: Curved Surface Shape Design (MDCSS) and Square Shape Design (MDSSS).

Example of a Curved Surface Shape Design (MDCSS) used as a visual stimulus.
Example of a Square Shape Design (MDSSS) used as a visual stimulus.

During the visual presentation, neural activity was recorded using a 14-electrode Emotiv EEG system. To process the non-linear and non-stationary nature of brain signals, the researchers employed Multifractal Detrended Fluctuation Analysis (MF-DFA). This method allowed for the extraction of specific rhythms—$\theta$ (4–8 Hz) and $\beta$ (12–32 Hz)—and the calculation of the Hurst exponent ($h(q)$) and multifractal spectrum width, which serve as indicators of signal complexity and neural "memory."

Key Findings and Results

The results revealed a stark contrast in user preference. Participants expressed a "like" response for 95.8% of curved designs compared to only 9% for square designs. This subjective preference was mirrored in the physiological data. When viewing disliked (square) designs, the $\theta$ rhythm exhibited a significantly larger Hurst exponent and a wider multifractal spectrum, suggesting higher signal volatility and negative cognitive processing.

Conversely, positive emotional responses to curved designs were associated with a larger range of values in the $\beta$ sub-band, indicating more stable and active cortical engagement. The C3 and C4 channels in the central brain region were identified as the most sensitive areas for distinguishing these aesthetic preferences. The study found a statistically significant correlation ($P < 0.05$) between the subjective button-press data and the MF-DFA metrics.

Discussion and Conclusion

The strong correlation between subjective feedback and MF-DFA metrics demonstrates that physiological signals can serve as a reliable, objective "truth serum" for product design. By mapping emotional cognition to specific neural signatures, designers can move beyond guesswork and optimize industrial shapes based on human physiological characteristics. While this study focused on the binary distinction between curved and square shapes, future research will explore hybrid designs and larger demographic samples to create a standardized physiological evaluation toolkit for the industry.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid development of new energy vehicles, the users have an increasing demand for charging piles. It is generally believed that the charging pile is a kind of practical product, and it only needs to realize the charging function. However, as a product, the shape design of the charging pile will directly affect the user experience, thus affecting product sales. Therefore, in the face of increasingly fierce market competition, when designing the shape of charging piles, it is necessary to adopt the traditional evaluation method and human physiological cognitive characteristics to evaluate the shape of charging piles more objectively. From the user's point of view, using the electroencephalogram (EEG) of the user, with the help of the multifractal detrended fluctuation analysis (MF-DFA) method, this paper comprehensively analyzes the differences in emotional cognitive characteristics between two kinds of charging piles, namely, the charging pile with a curved appearance design and the charging pile with square appearance design. The results show that there are significant differences in human physiological cognitive characteristics between two kinds of charging piles with different shapes. And different shapes of charging piles have different physiological cognitive differences for users. When designing charging pile product shapes, human beings can objectively evaluate the product shape design according to the physiological cognition differences of users, so as to optimize the charging pile product shape design.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024effect,
  author = {Yusheng Zhang and Yaoyuan Kang and Xin Guo and Pan Li and Hanqing He},
  title = {{The effect analysis of shape design of different charging piles based on Human physiological characteristics using the MF-DFA}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-59147-8},
}
Figure