Abstract
In this editorial, Frank Park, President of the IEEE Robotics and Automation Society, reflects on the tension between classical analytical robotics and the modern deep-learning-driven paradigm. He argues that while data-driven methods are transformative, classical foundations—such as kinematics and contact modeling—remain essential. These foundations provide the physics-based backbone for the simulators that make modern AI training possible and define the intellectual rigor of the field.
Introduction: The Identity Crisis in Robotics
The field of robotics is currently navigating a profound "identity crisis." As deep learning and end-to-end data-driven methods achieve transformative results, a growing divide has emerged between "classical" robotics—rooted in analytical physics and mathematics—and "modern" robotics, which is increasingly dominated by black-box neural networks. This shift raises a fundamental question for educators: what should constitute the core curriculum for the next generation of roboticists?
A common sentiment among some modern researchers is that classical approaches to problems like grasping or contact modeling are obsolete. The prevailing mantra has become "design a network, collect data, and train." However, this approach risks relegating teaching to an afterthought and losing the intellectual rigor that defines robotics as a scientific discipline.
The Simulation Paradox
Park points out a striking irony in the current research landscape: the very data-driven methods that claim to replace classical models rely heavily on them. Because high-quality physical robot data is scarce and expensive to collect, researchers turn to physics-based simulators to generate synthetic training data. These simulators are built entirely upon the "classical" analytical models—kinematics, dynamics, and contact mechanics—that are sometimes dismissed as outdated.
Furthermore, an interesting trend is emerging where physical hardware is being redesigned to better align with these model-based simulations. Rather than forcing models to perfectly capture every nuance of a messy physical reality, engineers are creating robots that behave more predictably according to the underlying physics, effectively bridging the gap between simulation and reality.
The Enduring Value of Mathematical Foundations
The enduring value of rigorous mathematical foundations is exemplified by the career of the late Roger Ware Brockett (1938–2023). Brockett was instrumental in introducing Lie-theoretic methods and nonholonomy to the robotics community. Tools such as the product-of-exponentials formalism and the use of Lie groups (SE(3)) for kinematics are not merely academic exercises; they provide the scientific "vernacular" that allows robotics to exist as a coherent intellectual discipline.
When revising the Modern Robotics textbook, the authors faced the dilemma of whether to prune classical material like force closure and contact models. Ultimately, they decided to retain these topics, viewing them as the essential "baggage" required to understand how robots interact with the physical world.
Institutional Action: Defining the Core
Recognizing that the rapid pace of research can often leave pedagogical strategy as an afterthought, the IEEE Robotics and Automation Society (RAS) has established the Education Activities Board. This new body is tasked with:
- Defining a Sustainable Core: Identifying the fundamental concepts that every roboticist should know, regardless of their specific sub-field.
- Global Educational Outreach: Developing and launching online content to bridge the gap between classical theory and modern applications, ensuring that the global community has access to high-quality foundational knowledge.
Conclusion
The future of robotics education lies in a synthesis: leveraging the power of modern AI while remaining grounded in the analytical rigor that defines the field. While data-driven methods are powerful tools, they do not replace the need for a deep understanding of physical principles. By preserving these foundations, we ensure that the next generation of roboticists is equipped not just to use tools, but to understand the physics of the machines they build.
Summary updated