The Earlier You Know, the Smoother You Act

Abir Chowdhury, Heiko Maurer, Alap Kshirsagar, Kai Ploeger, Jan Peters, Hermann Müller, Lisa K. MaurerbioRxiv 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Intercepting a moving object with our hands requires that the moving object and the hand come into contact at some point along the object’s trajectory. Hand movement must, therefore, be planned in advance so that the hand reaches a chosen spatial location along this trajectory at the correct moment in time. To enable such anticipatory behavior, the object’s trajectory must be predicted based on sensory information collected before movement planning is concluded. Early completion of planning would allow for a smooth and economical movement; however, it also requires sufficiently accurate information about the object’s movement to be available earlier. We investigate interception in the context of a complex, naturalistic motor task, toss juggling, to understand the extent to which proprioceptive and tactile information influence anticipatory movements of the catching hand. In our study, we compared solo juggling, where the efferent, tactile and proprioceptive information from the throwing hand is available during catch planning, with dyadic juggling, a functionally “deafferented” condition where no such information is available because the ball has been thrown by another person. Our results indicate that when internal and tactile information from the toss is absent, anticipatory behavior is greatly reduced. Experienced jugglers seem to rely more strongly on internal information than vision, allowing earlier planning and lower target uncertainty. In the dyadic condition, when internal information is absent, trajectory planning is delayed, leading to greater target uncertainty.

Introduction

Intercepting a moving object isn't just about reacting; it’s about predicting. To catch a ball, your brain must forecast where the ball will be and coordinate your hand to meet it at the right time and place. While vision is a primary source of information, it comes with a processing lag. This research investigates whether "internal" information—the sense of your own hand's movement (proprioception) and the feel of the ball leaving your fingertips (tactile feedback)—provides a head start in planning.

By comparing solo juggling to dyadic (partner) juggling, researchers found that having internal "insider information" about a throw allows the brain to plan interception significantly earlier. This earlier planning results in a "minimum jerk" trajectory, leading to the smoother, more economical movements characteristic of expert motor performance.

Methods and Experimental Setup

The study involved 18 experienced jugglers (12 male, 6 female, aged 20–60) performing two distinct tasks:

  1. Solo Juggling: A standard 3-ball cascade.
  2. Dyadic Juggling: Two jugglers standing side-by-side, sharing a 3-ball cascade. This setup effectively "deafferents" the catcher from the thrower's internal cues, forcing a reliance on external visual information.
Experimental setup for dyadic juggling, where two participants share a three-ball cascade.

Data was collected at 240 Hz using a 36-camera Vicon motion capture system, tracking 3D trajectories of the balls and the jugglers' upper bodies using the Plug-in-Gait marker set. Each participant performed 10 trials per condition, with each trial lasting approximately 20 seconds.

Technical Analysis

To quantify the timing and quality of motor planning, the researchers utilized two key metrics:

  • MDHP (Minimum Distance of the Hand to the Parabola): This metric calculates the shortest distance between the hand and the ball's predicted parabolic path at every time step.
  • Minimum Jerk Trajectory: This mathematical model represents the "smoothest possible" movement. The onset of a minimum jerk profile serves as a proxy for when the brain has finished planning the movement and committed to a predictive, feedforward control strategy.
Visualization of the MDHP metric: (a) 3D plot of ball trajectory and hand position with distance vectors; (b) the resulting MDHP trajectory over time.

Temporal data was normalized relative to the ball's apex and the moment the catching hand was freed by its own outgoing throw to account for varying flight times across conditions.

Key Results and Insights

The study revealed that internal information is a critical driver of smooth motor performance:

  • Earlier Planning Onset: In solo juggling, the smooth approximation phase started significantly earlier than in dyadic juggling. Solo jugglers often completed planning before the ball reached its apex.
  • The Cost of Deafferentation: In dyadic juggling, the absence of throw-related proprioception forced jugglers to rely more heavily on visual feedback. This delayed the onset of the smooth movement phase, making the catch more reactive and less "economical."
  • The 110ms Window: Planning in solo juggling often concludes within a 110ms window around the ball's apex—matching the typical latency for a visuomotor response. This suggests that while vision fine-tunes the movement, the primary planning is driven by internal models.
  • Shorter Smooth Phase in Dyadic: Despite longer ball flight times in the dyadic condition, the duration of the smooth, goal-directed movement was shorter. Jugglers delayed commitment until they had visual certainty, resulting in a compressed, less smooth movement.

Conclusion

Fluidity in movement is a signature of feedforward (predictive) control. The "earlier you know" the ball's path through internal cues, the more time you have to distribute the movement over a longer duration, minimizing jerk. While this study focused on experts, future work could explore how novices integrate these cues and how sensory weighting shifts when visual information is occluded or degraded.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Intercepting a moving object with our hands requires that the moving object and the hand come into contact at some point along the object’s trajectory. Hand movement must, therefore, be planned in advance so that the hand reaches a chosen spatial location along this trajectory at the correct moment in time. To enable such anticipatory behavior, the object’s trajectory must be predicted based on sensory information collected before movement planning is concluded. Early completion of planning would allow for a smooth and economical movement; however, it also requires sufficiently accurate information about the object’s movement to be available earlier. We investigate interception in the context of a complex, naturalistic motor task, toss juggling, to understand the extent to which proprioceptive and tactile information influence anticipatory movements of the catching hand. In our study, we compared solo juggling, where the efferent, tactile and proprioceptive information from the throwing hand is available during catch planning, with dyadic juggling, a functionally “deafferented” condition where no such information is available because the ball has been thrown by another person. Our results indicate that when internal and tactile information from the toss is absent, anticipatory behavior is greatly reduced. Experienced jugglers seem to rely more strongly on internal information than vision, allowing earlier planning and lower target uncertainty. In the dyadic condition, when internal information is absent, trajectory planning is delayed, leading to greater target uncertainty.
BibTeX
@misc{chowdhury2025earlier,
  author = {Abir Chowdhury and Heiko Maurer and Alap Kshirsagar and Kai Ploeger and Jan Peters and Hermann Müller and Lisa K. Maurer},
  title = {{The Earlier You Know, the Smoother You Act}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1101/2025.11.08.687371},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure