The Dynamic Shift of Neuron Excitability Observed with Enveloped High Frequency Stimulation

Jiahui Wang, Hao Wang, Xin Yuan Thow, Nitish V. ThakorarXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Neuronal excitability is known to be affected by transcranial electrical stimulation. However, due to the existence of both excitatory and inhibitory neurons in the cortex, the mechanism of neuronal excitability shift is still not clear. Here, we study electrical stimulation disturbance on neuronal excitability in the neuromuscular system on an acute rat model. We design a special stimulation waveform of enveloped high frequency stimulation (EHFS). With modeling and in vivo measurements, EHFS is confirmed to synchronize the neuronal recruitment at the positive and negative electrode. This unique synchronization property of EHFS amplifies the electrical stimulation disturbance on neuronal excitability, to enable the macroscopic observations of large increase and decrease of force output. By eliminating the complicated inhibitory interneuron effects in the cortex, our observations on the neuromuscular system supports the argument that electrical stimulation dynamically shifts neuronal excitability, by inducing depolarization during anodal stimulation and hyperpolarization during cathodal stimulation.

Introduction

Functional Electrical Stimulation (FES) has long been a vital tool for restoring motor function in individuals with paralysis. However, a persistent challenge in the field is the rapid onset of muscle fatigue, which occurs much faster under FES than during voluntary movement. While traditional explanations for this fatigue focus on the non-natural recruitment order of muscle fibers—where large, fast-fatiguing fibers are activated first—this research explores a deeper, purely physical cause: transmembrane ion distortion.

The authors hypothesize that external electrical currents linger long enough to disrupt the distribution of Sodium ($Na^+$) and Potassium ($K^+$) ions across the neuronal membrane. This disruption shifts the neuron's firing threshold, a phenomenon known as an excitability shift. To observe this effect without the interference of complex cortical interneurons, the researchers developed a novel waveform called Enveloped High Frequency Stimulation (EHFS) and tested it within a controlled neuromuscular system.

Methodology

The EHFS Waveform

Standard square-wave pulses often obscure excitability shifts because the positive and negative electrodes exert opposing effects that cancel each other out. To overcome this, the team introduced EHFS, which consists of a high-frequency "inner" sine wave (20 kHz) modulated by a lower-frequency "outer" envelope (0.5 kHz). This design creates a signal with a gradual onset and termination, allowing for a more nuanced interaction with the neuronal membrane.

Modeling and In Vivo Testing

The researchers utilized a distributed-parameter circuit model (RLC circuit) to simulate the extracellular medium, myelin, and cell membranes. This model allowed them to calculate the probability of neuron firing under various waveforms.

Empirical validation was conducted using an acute rat model (Sprague-Dawley, ~450g). The researchers stimulated the Tibialis Anterior (TA) muscle and measured the resulting kick force using a high-precision gauge. This setup allowed for the direct observation of how electrical stimulation alters muscle output over time.

Key Insights: The "A-B-C" Force Profile

The most striking finding from the EHFS experiments was a unique three-phase force pattern, referred to as the A-B-C profile:

  1. Area A: An initial baseline force output.
  2. Area B: A significant drop in force, sometimes reaching zero.
  3. Area C: A surprising recovery and subsequent increase in force that exceeded the initial baseline.

The existence of "Area C" is particularly significant. It provides macroscopic evidence that electrical stimulation does not merely cause fatigue; it can actually increase neuronal excitability. This suggests a dynamic "tug-of-war" where positive stimulation facilitates $Na^+$ influx (lowering the threshold and increasing excitability), while negative stimulation facilitates $K^+$ efflux (raising the threshold and decreasing excitability).

Synchronization and Recruitment

A critical advantage of EHFS identified by the RLC model is its ability to synchronize neuronal recruitment. In traditional square-wave stimulation, the recruitment curves at the positive and negative electrodes are often asynchronous, leading to the aforementioned cancellation effect. EHFS produces overlapping probability curves at both electrodes. This synchronization amplifies the ion distortion effect, making the resulting shifts in excitability visible in the total muscle force output.

Furthermore, the study found that these force shifts are most prominent at low current amplitudes. As the current increases, the system becomes more "resistive" to small threshold shifts, leading to a more stable (though potentially more fatiguing) force output.

Implications for Neuromodulation

The findings offer a new physical explanation for "collision blocking," a technique used to ensure nerve signals travel in only one direction. By demonstrating how current amplitude, pulse width, and electrode distance interact to shift excitability, the researchers provide a framework for more precise nerve signal control.

Additionally, the discovery of frequency-dependent polarity—where the efficiency of positive-first versus negative-first stimulation reverses at specific frequency windows (e.g., between 2 kHz and 4 kHz)—highlights the limitations of standard stimulation models that ignore these high-frequency dynamics.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study confirms that electrical stimulation dynamically shifts neuronal excitability by inducing depolarization during anodal stimulation and hyperpolarization during cathodal stimulation. While the researchers noted that the specific frequency windows for these effects can be narrow and subject-specific, the implications for the future of FES are profound.

By moving toward "bio-mimetic" neuromodulation designs that account for ion balance distortion, engineers may be able to develop waveforms that mimic natural action potentials. Such advancements could eventually eliminate the rapid fatigue currently associated with FES, leading to more effective and sustainable treatments for motor impairment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neuronal excitability is known to be affected by transcranial electrical stimulation. However, due to the existence of both excitatory and inhibitory neurons in the cortex, the mechanism of neuronal excitability shift is still not clear. Here, we study electrical stimulation disturbance on neuronal excitability in the neuromuscular system on an acute rat model. We design a special stimulation waveform of enveloped high frequency stimulation (EHFS). With modeling and in vivo measurements, EHFS is confirmed to synchronize the neuronal recruitment at the positive and negative electrode. This unique synchronization property of EHFS amplifies the electrical stimulation disturbance on neuronal excitability, to enable the macroscopic observations of large increase and decrease of force output. By eliminating the complicated inhibitory interneuron effects in the cortex, our observations on the neuromuscular system supports the argument that electrical stimulation dynamically shifts neuronal excitability, by inducing depolarization during anodal stimulation and hyperpolarization during cathodal stimulation.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2018dynamic,
  author = {Jiahui Wang and Hao Wang and Xin Yuan Thow and Nitish V. Thakor},
  title = {{The Dynamic Shift of Neuron Excitability Observed with Enveloped High Frequency Stimulation}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1812.01179},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1812.01179},
}
Figure