The dynamic relationship between cerebellar Purkinje cell simple spikes and the spikelet number of complex spikes

Amelia Burroughs, Andrew K. Wise, Jianqiang Xiao, Conor Houghton, Tianyu Tang, Colleen Y. Suh, Eric J. Lang, Richard Apps, Nadia L. CerminaraThe Journal of Physiology 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a dynamic interplay between two types of neuronal firing in cerebellar Purkinje cells: simple spikes and complex spikes. They found that the number of "spikelets" within a complex spike is not arbitrary but is directly influenced by preceding simple spike activity, and in turn, modulates subsequent simple spike firing. This suggests a novel mechanism for how the cerebellum might regulate its own output and contribute to motor learning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The cerebellum is crucial for motor control, coordination, and learning. Its primary output neurons, Purkinje cells, fire in two distinct ways: rapid, regular "simple spikes" and slower, more complex "complex spikes." While it's known that these two firing patterns interact, much of the research has treated complex spikes as single events. However, complex spikes are actually composed of an initial large spike followed by a variable number of smaller deflections called "spikelets." The functional significance of this spikelet variability and its precise relationship with simple spike activity remained largely unknown. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating how the number of spikelets in a complex spike is influenced by preceding simple spike activity and, conversely, how it affects subsequent simple spike firing.

Methods

The researchers recorded the electrical activity of Purkinje cells in both anaesthetized rats and awake cats. They employed standard electrophysiological techniques, including extracellular single-unit recordings using glass microelectrodes. To analyze the complex spike waveforms, they developed or utilized algorithms for spike sorting and spikelet detection. Specifically, they used template-matching algorithms and principal component analysis (PCA) to discriminate between simple and complex spikes and to identify individual spikelets within complex spikes. For data analysis, they calculated various metrics related to simple spike firing rates before and after complex spikes, as well as pause duration and rebound activity. Statistical analyses, including linear regression and Spearman's rank correlation, were used to assess the relationships between spikelet number and these firing parameters.

Datasets

The study utilized electrophysiological recordings from Purkinje cells in:

  • Anaesthetized adult rats: Data from 27 Purkinje cells from the Bristol dataset and 34 from the New York dataset were pooled, totaling 61 cells.
  • Awake cats: A smaller sample of 4 Purkinje cells was recorded.

No new benchmarks or datasets were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing electrophysiological recordings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spikelet number isn't random: The number of spikelets in a complex spike is not a fixed property but is dynamically influenced by the preceding simple spike activity. This suggests a feedback mechanism within the Purkinje cell itself or its immediate network.
  • A graded response: Complex spikes with more spikelets are associated with a more pronounced reduction in subsequent simple spike firing. This indicates a graded modulatory effect, rather than an all-or-none phenomenon.
  • Maintaining operational range: The authors propose that this dynamic interaction might serve a homeostatic function, helping to keep Purkinje cells within their optimal firing range and preventing runaway excitation or inhibition.
  • Implications for learning: The findings align with theories suggesting complex spikes play a role in motor learning, potentially by signaling errors or teaching signals. The graded nature of the simple spike modulation could provide a more nuanced signal for plasticity.

Key Results

  • Preceding simple spike rate predicts spikelet number: A higher simple spike firing rate before a complex spike was strongly correlated with a greater number of spikelets in that complex spike. This effect was observed in both spontaneous and evoked complex spikes. For instance, simple spikes preceding complex spikes with six spikelets were, on average, 135% of the mean simple spike firing rate, compared to 86% for complex spikes with one spikelet.
  • Spikelet number influences post-complex spike activity: Complex spikes with more spikelets were followed by a more significant reduction in simple spike firing rate in the period after the initial complex spike pause and rebound. This depression was graded with spikelet number.
  • Pause duration is independent of spikelet number: While complex spikes reliably cause a pause in simple spike activity, the duration of this pause was not correlated with the number of spikelets.
  • Rebound activity is modulated: The frequency of simple spikes during the rebound period following a complex spike was positively correlated with spikelet number in spontaneous activity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Anaesthesia effects: While awake cat data was included, the majority of the study was performed on anaesthetized rats. The authors acknowledge that anaesthesia can alter neuronal activity and suggest that further studies in awake, behaving animals are crucial to fully understand these dynamics.
  • Species differences: While findings were consistent between rats and cats, the sample size for awake cats was small.
  • Discrepancies with prior studies: The authors note that their findings on the relationship between preceding simple spike rate and spikelet number differ from some previous studies, suggesting potential differences in recording site location or experimental conditions.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that further research should explore the specific ionic mechanisms (e.g., involving Ih, Kv3.3, and resurgent sodium currents) that underlie this spikelet modulation. They also propose investigating how these dynamics contribute to specific cerebellar functions like motor learning and adaptation, potentially by examining how spikelet number influences plasticity. The role of zebrin-positive and zebrin-negative bands in the cerebellum in these interactions is also highlighted as an area for future investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purkinje cells are central to cerebellar function because they form the sole output of the cerebellar cortex. They exhibit two distinct types of action potential: simple spikes and complex spikes. It is widely accepted that interaction between these two types of impulse is central to cerebellar cortical information processing. Previous investigations of the interactions between simple spikes and complex spikes have mainly considered complex spikes as unitary events. However, complex spikes are composed of an initial large spike followed by a number of secondary components, termed spikelets. The number of spikelets within individual complex spikes is highly variable and the extent to which differences in complex spike spikelet number affects simple spike activity (and vice versa) remains poorly understood. In anaesthetized adult rats, we have found that Purkinje cells recorded from the posterior lobe vermis and hemisphere have high simple spike firing frequencies that precede complex spikes with greater numbers of spikelets. This finding was also evident in a small sample of Purkinje cells recorded from the posterior lobe hemisphere in awake cats. In addition, complex spikes with a greater number of spikelets were associated with a subsequent reduction in simple spike firing rate. We therefore suggest that one important function of spikelets is the modulation of Purkinje cell simple spike firing frequency, which has implications for controlling cerebellar cortical output and motor learning.
BibTeX
@article{burroughs2016dynamic,
  author = {Amelia Burroughs and Andrew K. Wise and Jianqiang Xiao and Conor Houghton and Tianyu Tang and Colleen Y. Suh and Eric J. Lang and Richard Apps and Nadia L. Cerminara},
  title = {{The dynamic relationship between cerebellar Purkinje cell simple spikes and the spikelet number of complex spikes}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physiology},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1113/jp272259},
}
Figure