Abstract
Bitcoin's performance during the COVID-19 pandemic has drawn a lot of attention, with many researchers wondering whether bitcoin can act as a hedge against the stock market, and how exactly the COVID-19 pandemic has changed bitcoin's connection to the world. This paper aims to investigate the dynamic relation between Bitcoin and global stock markets using a DCC-GARCH approach.
Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic served as a significant "stress test" for financial theories, particularly the narrative of Bitcoin as "digital gold." Proponents argued that as a decentralized asset, Bitcoin would serve as a safe haven during traditional market downturns. This study investigates whether this held true during the pandemic's systemic shock, analyzing the dynamic relationship between Bitcoin and global stock indices before and after the outbreak.
Methodology: The DCC-GARCH Approach
To capture the evolving nature of market relationships, the study employs the Dynamic Conditional Correlation - Generalized Autoregressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity (DCC-GARCH) model. Unlike standard models that assume static correlations, DCC-GARCH allows for daily fluctuations in the relationship between assets. This is essential for identifying "contagion effects," where market panic causes previously unrelated assets to move in tandem.
The dataset includes daily prices from March 12, 2019, to March 12, 2021, covering Bitcoin and six major stock indices: the S&P 500 (USA), FTSE 100 (UK), Nikkei 225 (Japan), SSE Composite (China), Nifty 50 (India), and IBOVESPA (Brazil).
Shifting Correlations and the "Safe Haven" Mirage
The analysis reveals that while Bitcoin initially plummeted alongside stocks in March 2020, its rapid recovery created a brief window (April to July 2020) where it functioned as a hedge. However, as markets stabilized, this independence diminished.
A critical finding is the "tightening bond" between Bitcoin and traditional equities. Post-outbreak, correlations did not return to their low pre-pandemic levels but remained elevated.
As shown in Figure 4, the correlation between Bitcoin and the US stock market rose from nearly zero (-0.005) to a post-outbreak average of 0.211. This suggests that Bitcoin is becoming increasingly integrated into the global financial system, behaving more like a high-beta risk asset than an independent store of value.
Developed vs. Developing Markets
The degree of integration varies by region. The link is most pronounced in mature markets like the US and UK. In contrast, developing markets show more varied dynamics.
While most markets saw a spike in correlation during the initial crisis, China's stock market remained relatively decoupled from Bitcoin compared to Western indices. This regional divergence highlights that Bitcoin's role as a diversifier may depend heavily on the specific market context.
Conclusion
The COVID-19 pandemic fundamentally altered the relationship between Bitcoin and global stocks. While a temporary safe-haven window existed during the early recovery phase, the long-term trend points toward increased correlation, particularly with developed markets. For investors, this means Bitcoin's effectiveness as a long-term diversifier has decreased, as it increasingly responds to the same macro-economic stressors as traditional equities. Future research should consider the impact of institutional adoption, such as spot ETFs, on these dynamic correlations.
Summary updated