Abstract This study investigates the non-linear relationship between diversification strategies and business performance within China's sports industry from 2018 to 2023. Utilizing panel data from 20 listed sports enterprises and employing a SYS-GMM model to address endogeneity, the research identifies a critical "enterprise scale threshold." Findings reveal a transition from a "diversification discount" in smaller firms to a "diversification premium" in larger ones. Furthermore, the study highlights industry heterogeneity, showing that sporting goods manufacturers require a significantly larger operational scale to benefit from diversification compared to sports service providers.
Introduction
In recent years, China’s sports industry has been hailed as a "sunrise industry," spurred by national policies aimed at promoting fitness and sports consumption. In response, many enterprises have pursued aggressive diversification, expanding from core manufacturing into event management, sports tourism, and media. However, the strategic value of such expansion remains a subject of intense debate. Does diversification provide a "premium" through economies of scope and risk reduction, or does it impose a "discount" due to increased agency costs and resource strain? This paper argues that the answer depends fundamentally on the firm's size—specifically, whether it has crossed a necessary scale threshold to manage increased complexity.
Methodology
To provide a robust analysis, the study employs several advanced econometric techniques:
- Total Factor Productivity (TFP): Rather than relying on simple accounting profits, the researchers used the Olley-Pakes (OP) method to calculate TFP, offering a more accurate measure of long-term operational efficiency.
- System Generalized Method of Moments (SYS-GMM): This approach addresses the endogeneity problem—the possibility that performance drives diversification decisions rather than the other way around—ensuring that the observed effects are causal.
- Hansen’s Dynamic Threshold Model: This core analytical tool identifies the specific "tipping points" in business size where the impact of diversification on performance shifts from negative to positive.
Datasets and Sample
The research is based on panel data from 20 representative sports enterprises listed on various Chinese exchanges (Shanghai, Shenzhen, and the New Third Board) between 2018 and 2023. Data was gathered from annual financial reports, the CSMAR database, and official statistical yearbooks.
The sample includes a diverse mix of firms, ranging from traditional manufacturers like GuiRenNiao and Sanfo to service-oriented entities like Evergrande Taobao and the China Sports Industry Group, covering 11 distinct categories of the sports industry.
Key Findings: The Scale Flip
The empirical results confirm a significant non-linear relationship between diversification and performance. The study identifies a "scale flip" where the impact of spreading business lines changes based on the natural log of sales (lnsales).
- The Diversification Discount: For firms below the threshold of 9.0327, diversification has a negative impact (coefficient of -0.6133). In these smaller firms, limited resources are spread too thin, weakening the core business and increasing management overhead.
- The Diversification Premium: Once firms surpass this size threshold, the relationship becomes positive (coefficient of 0.4429). Larger firms can leverage internal capital markets, share brand equity across sectors, and achieve genuine economies of scope.
Sector Heterogeneity
The "size" required to succeed at diversification is not uniform across the industry. The study reveals distinct thresholds for different sectors:
- Sporting Goods Manufacturers: These firms face higher fixed costs and more complex supply chain management. Consequently, they require a higher threshold (9.2671) before diversification yields positive returns.
- Sports Service Providers: These enterprises are typically more asset-light and agile. They can successfully diversify at a much lower scale (7.3792). Interestingly, service firms exhibit a "double threshold" effect, where performance gains accelerate even further after passing a second scale milestone of 9.0327.
Financial Factors and Performance
The study also uncovered divergent impacts of financial leverage. For sporting goods firms, higher liabilities were often associated with better performance, suggesting that debt is effectively used to fund necessary scale expansions. In contrast, for sports service firms, high debt levels tended to inhibit performance, likely due to the increased financial risk in a sector that relies more on human capital and operational agility than on physical assets.
Conclusion and Strategic Implications
The findings suggest that for sports enterprises, "bigger is better" when it comes to diversification. Managers of small-to-medium sports firms should focus on strengthening their core competencies rather than premature expansion. Conversely, large-scale enterprises should actively seek related diversification to maximize resource efficiency. While the study is limited by a relatively small sample size, it provides a vital roadmap for strategic planning in one of China's most dynamic industries.
Summary updated