The driving force for charge ordering in rare earth nickelates

Basudeb Mandal, Sagar Sarkar, Shishir Kumar Pandey, Priya Mahadevan, Cesare Franchini, Andrew J. Millis, D. D. SarmaarXiv 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We show that charge ordering (more precisely, two-sublattice bond disproportionation) in the rare earth nickelate perovskites is intimately related to a negative charge transfer energy. By adding an additional potential on the Ni d states we are able to vary the charge tranfer energy and compute relaxed structures within an ab-initio framework. We show that the difference in Ni-O bond lengths and the value of the ordered state magnetic moment correlate with the charge transfer energy and that the transition to the bond-disproportionated state occurs when the effective charge transfer energy becomes negative.

Introduction

Rare earth nickelates ($RENiO_3$) represent a fascinating class of perovskite oxides known for their complex phase diagrams, most notably a metal-insulator transition (MIT) accompanied by a structural change. This structural change is characterized by "bond disproportionation," where the nickel-oxygen (Ni-O) framework splits into two distinct sublattices—one featuring shorter bonds and the other longer bonds. While this state is frequently referred to as "charge ordering," the precise physical mechanism driving this transition has remained a subject of significant debate in condensed matter physics.

This paper addresses why nickelates exhibit this behavior while neighboring materials on the periodic table do not. The authors propose that the "charge transfer energy" ($\Delta$)—the energy required to move an electron from an oxygen $p$-level to a nickel $d$-level—is the fundamental parameter controlling the onset of bond disproportionation.

Methods

The researchers employed Density Functional Theory (DFT+U) calculations using the Vienna Ab initio simulation package (VASP). Their methodology involved several innovative steps to isolate the effect of the charge transfer energy:

  1. Structural Relaxation: Starting with experimental lattice parameters for Neodymium Nickelate ($NdNiO_3$), the team allowed internal atomic positions to relax to their lowest energy state.
  2. Artificial Potential Tuning: To systematically vary $\Delta$, they introduced an additional $d$-symmetry potential specifically on the Ni ions. This allowed them to manually shift the energy of the Ni $d$-states within the simulation.
  3. Wannier Mapping: Maximally localized Wannier functions were used to map the complex ab-initio band structures onto a simplified tight-binding model, enabling the extraction of a precise value for the effective charge transfer energy.
  4. Magnetic Modeling: The findings were tested across both ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic orders to ensure the robustness of the structural conclusions.

The Negative Charge Transfer Mechanism

A key insight of this work is that bond disproportionation only occurs when the charge transfer energy becomes negative. In this regime, the Ni $d$-band effectively "sinks" into the Oxygen $p$-band. This shift fundamentally changes the electronic configuration of the material.

Schematic representation of the charge transfer energy $\Delta$ and the transition to a negative effective charge transfer energy state with ligand holes.

When $\Delta$ is negative, the electronic state of the short-bond Ni sites is best described by the presence of "ligand holes" ($d^8\underline{L}^2$). Instead of a simple change in nickel valence, holes reside on the oxygen ligands. These oxygen holes form a spin-singlet with the nickel electrons, which explains the observed zero magnetic moment at these sites in the antiferromagnetic phase. This transition marks a shift from an ionic balance to a highly covalent state where the oxygen network destabilizes, driving the "breathing" distortion of the $NiO_6$ octahedra.

Quantitative Results

The study demonstrates that the amplitude of the structural distortion—the difference in Ni-O bond lengths—correlates directly with the magnitude of the negative charge transfer energy.

Evolution of (a) Ni-O bond lengths and (b) Ni magnetic moments as a function of the charge transfer energy $\Delta$.

For $NdNiO_3$, the transition to a uniform, non-disproportionated state occurs when the charge transfer energy is increased above approximately 1 eV. In the disproportionated state (at $\Delta = 0$), the short bonds are measured at $\sim1.90$ Å and the long bonds at $\sim2.0$ Å. As $\Delta$ increases toward positive values, these bond lengths converge.

Similarly, the magnetic moments show a clear dependency on $\Delta$. The long-bond sites maintain a magnetic moment of 1.50 $\mu_B$, consistent with a $Ni^{2+}$ state. In contrast, the moment on the short-bond sites is zero in the antiferromagnetic phase but increases in ferromagnetic test cases as $\Delta$ becomes more positive, eventually matching the long-bond site as the system returns to a uniform state.

Conclusion

By artificially tuning the electronic potential in quantum mechanical simulations, the authors have shown that the driving force for charge ordering in rare earth nickelates is a negative charge transfer energy. The material's crystal structure only distorts into a disproportionated state when it becomes energetically favorable to move holes onto oxygen atoms rather than keeping them on nickel. This work provides a clear electronic criterion for the metal-insulator transition in these materials and suggests that future research should explore these trends across the entire rare earth series to establish a universal rule for nickelate physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

We show that charge ordering (more precisely, two-sublattice bond disproportionation) in the rare earth nickelate perovskites is intimately related to a negative charge transfer energy. By adding an additional potential on the Ni d states we are able to vary the charge tranfer energy and compute relaxed structures within an ab-initio framework. We show that the difference in Ni-O bond lengths and the value of the ordered state magnetic moment correlate with the charge transfer energy and that the transition to the bond-disproportionated state occurs when the effective charge transfer energy becomes negative.
BibTeX
@misc{mandal2017driving,
  author = {Basudeb Mandal and Sagar Sarkar and Shishir Kumar Pandey and Priya Mahadevan and Cesare Franchini and Andrew J. Millis and D. D. Sarma},
  title = {{The driving force for charge ordering in rare earth nickelates}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1701.06819},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1701.06819},
}
Figure