The DLR Hierarchy of Approximate Inference

Michal Rosen-Zvi, Michael I. Jordan, Alan L. YuilleUAI 2005 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new framework, the DLR Hierarchy, for understanding and developing approximate inference algorithms in graphical models. It unifies existing methods like Belief Propagation and Mean Field, while also proposing novel algorithms, by framing them as solutions to a system of linear equations. This hierarchy offers a more systematic way to design and analyze these crucial algorithms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In machine learning, especially with complex graphical models, we often need to approximate calculations like finding the most likely configuration of variables or their marginal probabilities. This is known as approximate inference. While methods like Mean Field (MF) and Belief Propagation (BP) are widely used, their theoretical underpinnings and relationships are not always clear. The authors point out limitations of the purely variational approach, such as BP not always being a strict descent step in the Bethe free energy, and the difficulty in connecting variational methods to Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling. This paper aims to provide a more unified and systematic framework for designing and analyzing these approximate inference algorithms, bridging the gap between different approaches and potentially leading to better algorithms.

Methods

The core of the paper is the DLR Hierarchy, based on the Dobrushin, Lanford, Ruelle (DLR) equations. These equations describe dependencies between subsets of nodes and their Markov blankets. Instead of solving these equations exactly (which is intractable), the authors propose approximating them by considering subsets of these equations. This leads to a hierarchy of algorithms:

  • Level 1: Factorized Neighbors (FN) Algorithms: This is the simplest approximation, focusing on individual nodes. It leads to an algorithm that has connections to existing "hard spin" mean field equations.
  • Level 2: Belief Propagation (BP) and its Variants: This level considers pairs of nodes in addition to singletons. The authors show that the standard BP algorithm and its fixed points correspond to solutions of these DLR equations. They also prove that extrema of the Bethe free energy correspond to these solutions.
  • Intermediate Levels (e.g., Level 1.5): The framework allows for intermediate approximations by considering different subsets of nodes, leading to algorithms like the CP algorithm and a novel "Second-order Factorized Neighbors" (FN2) algorithm.
  • Mean Field (MF) Algorithms: The paper reinterprets MF algorithms within this DLR framework, showing how they can be seen as an alternative approximation to the DLR equations, particularly when dealing with logarithms.

A key aspect is the connection to Gibbs sampling. The authors demonstrate that the iterative update rules derived from the DLR framework can be viewed as deterministic approximations to Gibbs sampling, generalizing known results for MF. They also explore a variational perspective using weighted sums of Kullback-Leibler divergences (WSKL) to capture solutions of the DLR equations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments are conducted on synthetic Ising models with varying parameters and grid sizes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Framework: The DLR Hierarchy provides a single theoretical lens through which to view and derive a wide range of approximate inference algorithms, from simple Mean Field to Belief Propagation.
  • Beyond Variational Descent: The paper clarifies that while BP's fixed points correspond to extrema of the Bethe free energy, the BP iteration itself isn't always a descent step. This offers a new perspective on BP's behavior.
  • Algorithmic Design: The DLR framework naturally suggests new algorithms, such as the Factorized Neighbors (FN) and FN2 algorithms, by systematically choosing subsets of the DLR equations.
  • MCMC Connection: A significant insight is the demonstration that DLR-based iterative updates can be seen as deterministic approximations to Gibbs sampling, potentially paving the way for hybrid algorithms.
  • Hierarchy Trade-offs: The experiments reveal a clear trade-off: algorithms higher up in the hierarchy (like BP) tend to be more accurate when they converge but are also less stable and more prone to non-convergence.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Equivalence: The paper proves that fixed points of Belief Propagation correspond to solutions of the DLR equations (Level 2 approximation) and that extrema of the Bethe free energy also correspond to these solutions.
  • Novel Algorithms: The Factorized Neighbors (FN) and FN2 algorithms are introduced and shown to be viable alternatives.
  • Empirical Performance:
    • In an "easy regime" (where BP converges reliably), BP generally yields the most accurate results, followed by FN2, then FN, and finally MF/MF2.
  • In a "hard regime" (where BP frequently fails to converge), FN and FN2 algorithms show more robust performance, with FN failing to converge in only a small fraction of runs and often providing useful oscillating marginals. FN2 also shows improvement over FN.
  • The critical temperature prediction for the 2D Ising model shows that FN and FN2 offer improvements over MF and MF2, with FN being a significant improvement over MF.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Convergence Stability: A key limitation highlighted is the trade-off between accuracy and stability. Algorithms higher in the hierarchy (like BP) are more accurate but less stable, failing to converge in many challenging scenarios.
  • Hybrid Algorithms: The demonstrated connection between DLR-based methods and Gibbs sampling suggests future work on developing hybrid algorithms that combine the strengths of both deterministic and sampling approaches.
  • Broader Applicability: While the paper focuses on Ising models for empirical results, the DLR framework is general and could be applied to a wider range of graphical models.
  • Understanding Non-Convergence: Further investigation into why algorithms like BP fail to converge in harder regimes and how to improve their stability would be valuable. The paper notes that even when FN doesn't converge, its oscillating marginals can still be useful, hinting at potential for approximate solutions even in non-convergent cases.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a hierarchy for approximate inference based on the Dobrushin, Lanford, Ruelle (DLR) equations. This hierarchy includes existing algorithms, such as belief propagation, and also motivates novel algorithms such as factorized neighbors (FN) algorithms and variants of mean field (MF) algorithms. In particular, we show that extrema of the Bethe free energy correspond to approximate solutions of the DLR equations. In addition, we demonstrate a close connection between these approximate algorithms and Gibbs sampling. Finally, we compare and contrast various of the algorithms in the DLR hierarchy on spin-glass problems. The experiments show that algorithms higher up in the hierarchy give more accurate results when they converge but tend to be less stable.
BibTeX
@misc{rosenzvi2005dlr,
  author = {Michal Rosen-Zvi and Michael I. Jordan and Alan L. Yuille},
  title = {{The DLR Hierarchy of Approximate Inference}},
  year = {2005},
  eprint = {1207.1417},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1207.1417},
}
Figure