The Diversity of NLRs in Brassica rapa Pan-genome

Shu-Hao Liu, Yimeng Zhu, Boyang Ke, Jun Wang, Xianjia Peng, Shaoke Zhang, Ruoxuan Zhao, Haizheng Wang, Jing Lou, Jiaruo Li, Yunhong Zheng, Tao Huang, Siyao Wang, Zebin Lang, Leye Wang, Xizhe Sun, Chunyang WangbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study comprehensively catalogs the diversity of Nucleotide-Binding Leucine-Rich Repeat (NLR) genes, crucial for plant immunity, across 17 Brassica rapa accessions, revealing a rich and varied "pan-NLRome." The findings highlight significant differences in the distribution, evolution, and functional potential of different NLR types, offering valuable insights for breeding disease-resistant crops.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Brassica rapa (common in vegetables like cabbage and turnips) is highly susceptible to various diseases, leading to significant yield losses. While NLR genes are known to confer disease resistance by detecting pathogen effectors and triggering immune responses, the full spectrum of their diversity within Brassica rapa (intraspecific diversity) and its implications for breeding remained largely unexplored. Understanding this diversity is key to developing more robust and sustainable crop protection strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of computational approaches:

  • Domain Similarity Search: This standard technique was used to identify potential NLR genes by searching for known conserved domains (like NBS and LRR) within the Brassica rapa genomes.
  • Machine Learning Pipeline: This likely refers to a more sophisticated approach for classifying and annotating the identified NLR genes, potentially improving accuracy over traditional methods.
  • Phylogenetic Analyses: These methods were used to reconstruct the evolutionary relationships between the identified NLR genes, helping to understand their origins and diversification.
  • 3D Protein Structure Prediction: Tools like AlphaFold2 were used to model the three-dimensional structures of specific NLR proteins, allowing for the visualization of functional domains and potential interaction sites.
  • Binding Capacity Prediction: A deep learning network was used to predict the binding probabilities of specific sites on the NLR proteins, suggesting their potential roles in interacting with pathogen effectors.

Datasets

The study utilized genomic data from 17 Brassica rapa accessions. Additionally, for comparative analyses, CDS (coding sequence) files from seven other Brassicaceae species were downloaded.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Vast NLR Repertoire: Brassica rapa possesses an extensive collection of NLR genes, with a species-wide "pan-NLRome" of 2188 identified genes. This highlights the plant's significant investment in immune defense.
  • Unequal Distribution and Diversification: The four main types of NLRs (NL, RNL, TNL, CNL) are not evenly distributed across accessions or even within the genome. This unevenness suggests different evolutionary pressures and functional roles.
  • TNL Expansion and Positive Selection: TNL-type NLRs, characterized by a Toll/interleukin-1 receptor (TIR) domain, show significant accession-specific expansion. These expanded TNLs also exhibit a higher number of positively selected amino acid residues, particularly on their surface, hinting at their active role in adapting to diverse and evolving pathogens.
  • RNLs as Conserved Guardians: RNL-type NLRs appear to be more conserved in terms of copy number and chromosomal location, suggesting a fundamental and ancient role in Brassica rapa immunity.
  • Integrated Domains (IDs) as Functional Modifiers: A substantial portion of NLRs harbor integrated domains (IDs) that can dramatically increase their functional diversity, particularly in pathogen effector recognition. Some of these IDs are unique to specific NLR types or categories, further diversifying immune responses.
  • Structural Insights into Recognition: 3D structure predictions reveal that positively selected sites on NLR proteins are often located on the protein surface, consistent with their role in interacting with pathogen effectors. The "ring" structure observed in some TNL proteins, with positive selection sites on its inner surface, is particularly suggestive of a direct role in effector recognition.

Key Results

  • 2188 NLRs identified across 17 Brassica rapa accessions.
  • Unequal distribution: RNLs showed the most stable copy numbers, while TNLs and CNLs exhibited significant variation between accessions.
  • TNLs are highly diverse: TNLs showed the largest number variation, with some accessions having over ten times more TNLs than others.
  • 93 distinct Pfam domains were identified as integrated domains (IDs) within NLR proteins.
  • 365 NLRs contain at least one ID, representing 16.7% of all identified NLRs.
  • Positive selection analyses revealed that accession-specific expanded TNLs have significantly more positively selected sites than RNLs, averaging 38 sites per OG compared to RNLs.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that gene model prediction might miss some NLR genes, especially those expressed only under specific pathogen challenges. They suggest that de novo mining of NLR genes from whole-genome sequences using machine learning could be a promising solution for future studies.

Future work should focus on:

  • Biofunction assignment: Investigating the specific roles of the identified NLR genes, particularly the accession-specific expanded TNLs, in disease resistance.
  • Molecular mechanisms: Elucidating the detailed molecular mechanisms underlying NLR function, especially in pathogen effector recognition.
  • Genetic manipulation: Utilizing the identified NLR genes and their diverse domains for genetic engineering to develop improved disease-resistant crop varieties.
  • Experimental validation: Testing the predicted binding capacities and functional roles of specific NLR proteins through experimental approaches.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The species Brassica rapa is mainly cultivated as a vegetable crop with high economic value. But infectious diseases, such as soft rot disease and clubroot disease can cause severe yield losses. Introducing resistance genes through breeding is an efficient and sustainable way to reduce the susceptibility and improve the yield of crops. Nucleotide-Binding Leucine-Rich Repeat (NLR) genes are the main types of resistance genes. They can recognize pathogen effectors and initiate downstream immune response. However, the intraspecific diversity of NLR genes in Brassica rapa has remained unknown. Based on domain similarity search and machine learning pipeline, we identified 2188 NLRs in 17 accessions of Brassica rapa genomes, which constitute the species-wide pan-NLRome in Brassica rapa . The diversity of the four types of NLR genes are significantly different in the aspects of chromosome location, number stability, integrated domains (IDs), evolutionary trajectory, and positive selection sites. Phylogenetic analyses show TNL-type NLRs whose N terminus contain Toll/interleukin-1 receptor (TIR) domain experienced accession-specific expansion. Moreover, the expanded TNL-type NLRs carry more positively selected amino acid residues which are mainly located on the protein surface based on their 3D structures. These evidences might imply their important biological function in perceiving pathogen effectors. Taken together, our study provides better insights into the diversity and variation of NLR genes in Brassica rapa pangemone, which can facilitate the biofunction assigning, cloning, and subsequent application in breeding programs.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2023diversity,
  author = {Shu-Hao Liu and Yimeng Zhu and Boyang Ke and Jun Wang and Xianjia Peng and Shaoke Zhang and Ruoxuan Zhao and Haizheng Wang and Jing Lou and Jiaruo Li and Yunhong Zheng and Tao Huang and Siyao Wang and Zebin Lang and Leye Wang and Xizhe Sun and Chunyang Wang},
  title = {{The Diversity of NLRs in <i>Brassica rapa</i> Pan-genome}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.08.29.555307},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure