Abstract: This paper attempts to determine to what degree voicemail messages can be considered a discourse genre – that is, to what degree and in what ways they appear to be uniform across speakers. Thirty-seven voice messages were recorded from the cellular phones of three University of Michigan students. The messages were analyzed in terms of their overall structure, the discursive functions that were executed therein, and the specific words, phrases and prosodic strategies that were used to execute certain functions. The messages were found to have highly uniform openings and closings, and the message bodies were found to reduce to a small set of discursive functions. In addition, certain words, phrases and devices appeared frequently and in predictable locations within the messages. It is concluded that voicemail message-leaving is a highly structured act governed by conventions that arise both from face-to-face conversation and from the specific constraints of the medium.
Introduction: The "Ironic" Task of Voicemail
When answering machines first gained popularity, they introduced a unique form of social anxiety. Users faced an "ironic" tension: the necessity of speaking to a person they knew was not actually present. Decades later, while leaving a message feels like second nature, the practice remains a complex adaptation of face-to-face conversational norms to a one-sided, machine-mediated environment. This study investigates whether voicemail has evolved into a distinct discourse genre—a uniform, predictable way of communicating across different speakers.
Methods and Data Collection
The study utilized a mix of qualitative and quantitative discourse analysis. The primary dataset consisted of 37 "natural" (unsolicited) voicemail messages recorded from the mobile phones of three University of Michigan students (ages 18–20). These messages originated from 23 different speakers, ranging from best friends to institutional representatives.
Messages were transcribed to capture not just words, but pauses, phonetic lengthening, and "repairs" (self-corrections). Each message was then segmented into "discursive functions"—the specific purpose of each utterance, such as an apology, an invitation, or a request for a callback.
Key Results: The Anatomy of a Message
The analysis revealed a striking level of macro-uniformity across the corpus. Almost every message adhered to a strict three-part structure: Opening, Body, and Closing.
The Opening Formula
The study found that openings are highly formulaic. Out of 37 messages, 27 followed an identical sequence: Greeting Word – Direct Address – Self-Identification. Interestingly, while modern Caller ID often makes self-identification redundant, speakers continue to use it, likely as a "cognitive buffer" to help the listener identify the voice and context before the main message begins.
The "Hey" Hierarchy and Lexical Standards
As shown in the data, "Hey" was the dominant greeting for peers (22 instances), while "Hello" and "Hi" were typically reserved for formal or institutional contexts. The bodies of the messages, despite the infinite possibilities of human speech, were limited to a small set of functions: Justification (why I'm calling), Call Request (call me back), and Status Updates. Lexical standardization was also high; the phrase "gimme a call" appeared 21 times, and 33 out of 37 messages ended with a variation of "bye."
Discussion: Discourse Markers and Social Lubricants
Because voicemail is asynchronous, speakers use "discourse markers" like so, um, and uh as audio punctuation. These markers signal transitions between different sections of the message, such as moving from the reason for the call to the specific request.
Furthermore, humor acts as a social lubricant. Approximately 30% of messages included jokes or altered voices, often as a reaction to the inherent awkwardness of the medium or a humorous outgoing prompt. This suggests that even in a one-sided recording, speakers are deeply attuned to the social relationship with the callee.
Conclusion and Future Directions
Voicemail is not a series of random rants but a highly structured communicative genre. While this study provides a snapshot of college-aged peer discourse, the findings suggest that voicemail conventions are governed by rules adapted from both face-to-face interaction and the specific constraints of the medium.
Future research should expand to broader demographics and explore how outgoing prompts influence message structure. Additionally, these findings have practical applications for English as a Second Language (ESL) learners, who may benefit from explicit instruction on the "unwritten rules" of this common communicative task.
Summary updated