The Difference in Open Innovation between Open Access and Closed Access, According to the Change of Collective Intelligence and Knowledge Amount

JinHyo Joseph Yun, Zheng Liu, EuiSeob Jeong, Sang‐Woo Kim, Kyunghun KimSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how collective intelligence (CI) and the amount of knowledge (references) influence open innovation in academic journals, comparing open access (OA) and closed-access (CA) models. It finds that while CA journals initially benefited more from CI and references, the digital transformation era has significantly boosted OA journals, with their citation rates now rivaling those of CA journals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rise of online open access journals (OAJs) has coincided with the "digital transformation" of the academic publishing industry. However, the precise impact of this shift on how research innovation occurs, particularly concerning the interplay of collective intelligence (CI) and the knowledge base (references), remains unclear. This paper aims to quantify and compare the influence of CI and references on open innovation (measured by citations) in both OA and CA journals across two distinct periods: pre-smartphone mobile internet (2003-2006) and the digital transformation era (2013-2016). It seeks to understand if OA journals foster open innovation differently than their CA counterparts, especially as digital technologies become more pervasive.

Methods

The researchers employed ordinary least squares (OLS) regression analysis to examine data from the Scopus database. They analyzed articles across various disciplines (arts and humanities, business, economics, engineering, and mathematics) during two time periods: 2003-2006 and 2013-2016. The study focused on three key variables:

  • Collective Intelligence (CI): Measured by the number of co-authors per paper.
  • Knowledge Amount (References): Measured by the number of references in a paper.
  • Open Innovation: Measured by the number of citations a paper receives.

They also investigated the moderating effect of references on the relationship between CI and open innovation. Comparative analyses were conducted between OA and CA journals, and across different disciplinary groupings.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Scopus database. This dataset comprised academic articles across various disciplines, collected for two distinct time periods:

  • 2003-2006: Representing the pre-smartphone mobile internet era.
  • 2013-2016: Representing the digital transformation era.

The data included information on the number of authors, references, and citations for papers published in both open access and closed access journals.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Digital Transformation as a Catalyst for OA: The study strongly suggests that the digital transformation, particularly the widespread adoption of mobile internet, has been a crucial factor in leveling the playing field between OA and CA journals.
  • Shifting Dynamics of CI and References: While CA journals initially showed a stronger correlation between CI, references, and open innovation, this advantage has diminished. OA journals have increasingly leveraged these factors, especially in the later period.
  • OA Journals Catching Up (and Surpassing): The research indicates that OA journals are not only catching up to CA journals in terms of citation impact but, in some instances, are beginning to surpass them, particularly in the post-digital transformation era.
  • CI and References as Drivers of Open Innovation: The study consistently finds that both collective intelligence (more co-authors) and a robust knowledge base (more references) are significant drivers of open innovation, as evidenced by increased citations.

Key Results

  • 2003-2006 Period: In this earlier period, only closed-access journals showed a statistically significant effect of collective intelligence and references on open innovation. The moderating role of references was also primarily observed in CA journals. OA journals, likely due to their nascent stage, did not exhibit these effects.
  • 2013-2016 Period: This period marked a significant shift. Both OA and CA journals demonstrated the positive effects of collective intelligence and references on citations. Crucially, the moderating role of references on the CI-citation link became evident in OA journals as well.
  • Citation Impact: While OA papers had fewer citations than CA papers in 2003-2006, by 2013-2016, the citation rates of OA journals had significantly increased and were nearly on par with, or even surpassed, those of CA journals across various disciplines. For example, in engineering, OA citations in 2013-2016 were higher than in 2003-2006, and the gap between OA and CA citations narrowed considerably.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • Publication Time Pressure: The study acknowledges that the shorter publication times of OAJs might be a factor influencing researchers' choices, which could be a separate area of investigation.
  • High APCs: The increasing Article Processing Charges (APCs) in OAJs, and their comparison with hybrid OA journals, are noted as potential financial burdens and areas for further research.
  • Limited Scope: The research focused on specific time periods and journal types, and future work could expand these to provide a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Positivist Paradigm: The study's reliance on quantitative data (positivist paradigm) might not fully capture the qualitative nuances of collective intelligence.
  • Future Work:
    • Qualitative Research: The authors suggest more qualitative research (interviews, natural experiments) to explore the diverse aspects of collective intelligence beyond co-author counts.
  • Broader Industries: Applying the research model to other industries beyond academic publishing could offer broader insights.
  • Nonlinear Aspects of CI: Investigating the nonlinear aspects of CI and their implications for knowledge strategy planning is recommended.
  • Comparative Analysis of APCs: A deeper dive into the financial aspects of OAJs, including APCs and their impact, is proposed.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study explored the differences in the effects of collective intelligence and references on open innovation between open and closed access journals. This study analyzed the moderating effect of references on the motivation of collective intelligence on open innovation from 2003 to 2006 and 2013 to 2016, considered to be the digital transformation era. The Scopus database on open and closed access journals was used for ordinary regression analysis. During the 2003–2006 period, only papers in closed access journals demonstrated sufficient effect of collective intelligence and reference on open innovation and the effective moderating role of reference. However, between 2013 and 2016, papers in open and closed access journals demonstrated the incentive effects of collective intelligence and references on citation and the moderating role of references on the correlation between collective intelligence and citation. The increase in digital transformation strengthens the collective intelligence and references of open access journals, and citations of open access journals nearly surpass those of closed access journals.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yun2022difference,
  author = {JinHyo Joseph Yun and Zheng Liu and EuiSeob Jeong and Sang‐Woo Kim and Kyunghun Kim},
  title = {{The Difference in Open Innovation between Open Access and Closed Access, According to the Change of Collective Intelligence and Knowledge Amount}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14052574},
}
Figure