The development of career planning scale for junior high school students based on cognitive information processing theory

Peng Wang, Tiantian Li, Zhigang Wu, Xiao Wang, Jihao Jing, Jianjun Xin, Xiuchun Sang, Binrong DaiFrontiers in Psychology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Based on the career theory of Cognitive Information Processing (CIP), this study developed a 28-item scale to measure career planning levels in junior high school students. The scale identifies four primary factors: interests, abilities, values, and personality. Confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) was employed to test the factor structure, revealing that while a first-order model was informative, a second-order model provided a more rational fit for the total score. The scale demonstrated high internal consistency (Cronbach's alpha = 0.965) and strong convergent validity. These findings suggest the scale is a reliable tool for assessing and guiding early-stage career development, particularly within Information Technology (IT) education contexts.

Introduction

In many educational systems, career planning is often delayed until university, leaving students ill-prepared for critical academic and vocational choices. This study addresses the lack of standardized, theory-based instruments for junior high school students. By focusing on Information Technology (IT) courses—which offer a practical environment for exploring technical and soft skills—the researchers aimed to create a metric for evaluating career maturity at a critical developmental window.

Theoretical Framework

The scale is built upon the "Pyramid of Information Processing" from CIP theory. This model posits that career decision-making is a hierarchical process. At the base lies self-knowledge (encompassing interests, abilities, values, and personality) and occupational knowledge. These support the decision-making skills level, which is ultimately overseen by metacognition.

Figure 1: The Career Counseling Information Processing Model (Pyramid) illustrating the hierarchy of self-knowledge, decision-making, and metacognition.

Methodology

The researchers followed a multi-step validation process:

  1. Item Generation: 28 items were developed through literature review and expert consultation.
  2. Data Collection: A sample of 252 junior high students (mean age 13.48) from Jinan, China, provided the data.
  3. Statistical Analysis: The study utilized discrimination analysis, item-total correlation, and CFA. While the first-order CFA (treating factors as independent) was tested, the researchers moved to a second-order CFA to reflect the unified nature of career planning in adolescents.

Results and Validation

The analysis confirmed a robust four-factor structure. The high overall Cronbach’s alpha (0.965) indicates exceptional reliability across the scale, with each individual dimension scoring above 0.8.

Figure 2: The four-factor model of first-order confirmatory factor analysis showing the relationships between interests, abilities, values, personality, and their respective questionnaire items.

Key psychometric properties included:

  • Interests: Validated items related to engagement in IT coursework.
  • Abilities: Items focused on the application of IT skills to complete work.
  • Values: Items assessing the perceived relevance of IT to future goals.
  • Personality: Items identifying character strengths through technical tasks.

The shift to a second-order model was a significant finding, suggesting that for young students, self-awareness in one domain (e.g., interests) is deeply intertwined with others (e.g., perceived ability), forming a single latent "General Career Planning" factor.

Discussion and Implications

The study highlights that IT education is uniquely positioned as a "vocational proxy," mirroring modern STEM requirements. Early intervention using this scale can help students align their academic trajectories with their evolving professional identities.

While the study is limited by its geographic focus (eastern China) and the potential influence of the COVID-19 pandemic on student outlooks, it provides a foundational tool for longitudinal tracking of career maturity. Future research should explore the scale's predictive validity regarding long-term STEM career choices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on the career theory of Cognitive Information Processing (CIP), we selected scale items from literature reviews and expert guidance. The scale consisted of 28 items with 4 factors (interests, abilities, values, personality). To test the scale's factor structure, we used confirmatory factor analysis (CFA), and the model was modified according to CFA results. The second-order confirmatory factor analysis was applied to the model of the scale to prove the rationality of the total score. The internal consistency were evaluated using Cronbach's alpha coefficients. In addition, the composite reliability (CR) and average variance extraction (AVE) of the scale were also calculated to test the convergent validity. After related analyses, the scale was proved to have good psychometric properties, which can be used to measure junior high school students' career planning level in information technology course from the aspects of interest, ability, values, and personality. The effect of the first-order confirmatory factor analysis model constructed in this study is not ideal. Therefore, on this basis, a second-order confirmatory factor analysis model is constructed in combination with existing literatures, and the rationality of the model is verified through data, which highlights the novelty of this study.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023development,
  author = {Peng Wang and Tiantian Li and Zhigang Wu and Xiao Wang and Jihao Jing and Jianjun Xin and Xiuchun Sang and Binrong Dai},
  title = {{The development of career planning scale for junior high school students based on cognitive information processing theory}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1106624},
}
Figure