The Development of Asian Characters’ Stereotypes of Ethnic Identity and Cultural Representation in American Films

Kexin Dong, Lixuan Sun, Xinjie ZhangAdvances 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This paper examines the persistent construction of Asian stereotypes in Hollywood films, categorizing them into specific tropes regarding appearance, academic skill, and personality. By applying social identity and cognitive theories, the research argues that these media representations reinforce out-group prejudice and can lead to the erosion of self-identity among Asian populations. Through a qualitative analysis of modern film and television, the study concludes that while overt practices like "yellowface" have diminished, the underlying stereotypical content remains a significant barrier to genuine cultural representation.

Introduction: The Persistence of Media Caricatures

Despite the increasing globalization of the film market—particularly the massive growth of Hollywood's presence in China—Asian characters in Western media often remain trapped in narrow, historical caricatures. This research addresses the "minimal group paradigm," a psychological phenomenon where media serves as a primary source for forming biased cultural schemas.

These stereotypes are not merely harmless tropes; they function as cognitive shortcuts that solidify into systemic discrimination. By bridging media analysis with psychological theory, this paper explains why these stereotypes persist and how they impact both the general audience's perception and the marginalized group's self-evaluation.

Methodology

The study employs a qualitative research method centered on a comprehensive literature review and case study analysis. Two primary theoretical frameworks guide the investigation:

  • Social Identity Theory: This framework explains how audiences categorize people into "in-groups" and "out-groups." Media often attributes limited or negative traits to the out-group to bolster the status and identity of the in-group.
  • Cognitive Theory: Drawing on Jean Piaget’s work, the authors analyze how individuals build knowledge of the world through experience. Media-driven stereotypes become "fixed, over-generalized beliefs" that are internalized during cognitive development.

The researchers applied these theories to a thematic analysis of selected modern productions, including Doctor Strange, Fresh Off the Boat, Young Sheldon, The Edge of Seventeen, Inside No. 9, and Man on Fire.

Thematic Analysis of Asian Stereotypes

Appearance and the "Otherness" of Costume

In many contemporary films, physical appearance is used as a crutch to signal identity rather than nuanced characterization. In Doctor Strange, for instance, the character Wong is identified as "Asian" through traditional clothing and props like a birdcage, even in modern settings. This reliance on ethnic costumes reinforces the "otherness" of the character, suggesting that their identity is tied to historical artifacts rather than modern reality.

The Academic Performance Gap

Scripts frequently use Asian characters as a foil for white characters by exaggerating academic success—the pervasive "math genius" or "nerd" trope. This creates a label that is difficult to shake, reducing complex human beings to one-dimensional figures.

Representation of the 'nerd' trope in modern television, often contrasting Asian characters with their white peers.

For example, in Fresh Off the Boat, the protagonist’s straight-A report card is explicitly contrasted with a white peer’s C-grade to highlight racialized academic expectations. This "nerd" label often carries social penalties, depicting Asian characters as socially awkward or physically inferior.

The "Kung Fu" Pivot and Personality Tropes

The research notes that while figures like Bruce Lee successfully challenged the "weak" Asian stereotype in the 1960s, they inadvertently created a new, equally limiting "martial artist" stereotype. This highlights a recurring pattern: breaking one trope often leads to the solidification of another. Furthermore, Asian men are frequently depicted as shy or inarticulate, while Asian women are often relegated to submissive roles or historical caricatures, such as geishas or concubines.

Psychological and Cultural Impact

Perhaps the most critical insight is that these stereotypes do not just affect how others see Asians; they affect how Asian individuals evaluate themselves. Constant exposure to limited media roles can lead to a "doubt and denial of self-identity." This internalization can result in the "disappearance of multi-culture" as individuals attempt to either over-conform to or aggressively distance themselves from these tropes to avoid being pigeonholed.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While Hollywood has largely moved away from the era of "yellowface" (white actors playing Asian roles), the content of the roles remains largely stereotypical. The study suggests that the industry must move toward a variety of figures rather than fixed types.

Future work should focus on the creation of films that intentionally break the traditional American image of Asians. Media should report cultural characteristics truthfully rather than exaggerating them for box-office hype. Ultimately, art must be used as a medium to promote genuine racial equality and cultural diversity, moving beyond the "fixed belief" to a more nuanced understanding of ethnic identity.

Summary updated

Abstract

The paper discussed the stereotypes of Asian people developed in American films. Besides, it also talked about the impact of stereotypes and how people should deal with the impact of existing stereotypes. In order to solve this question, the paper used the qualitative method. To evaluate the creation and cognition of Asian stereotypes in society, a literature review was conducted, which included reading substantial reputable literature and reference materials, as well as combining data and information acquired from multiple platforms to conclude. This paper analyzed the stereotypes of Asians in American movies from three of the most classic stereotypes in selected five films. These films were promoted before they were released due to the media's influence, and they spread quickly compared to decades earlier. This paper concluded that although it was undeniable that stereotypes represent the spread of a country's culture to some extent, the stereotypes of Asians in American films needed to be stopped. At the same time, the conclusion of this paper was a general phenomenon and idea.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong2022development,
  author = {Kexin Dong and Lixuan Sun and Xinjie Zhang},
  title = {{The Development of Asian Characters’ Stereotypes of Ethnic Identity and Cultural Representation in American Films}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2991/assehr.k.220504.047},
}
Figure