The Determinants of User Acceptance of Mobile Medical Platforms: An Investigation Integrating the TPB, TAM, and Patient-Centered Factors

Hailiang Wang, Jiaxin Zhang, Yan Luximon, Mingfu Qin, Ping Geng, Da TaoInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates what makes people accept and use mobile medical platforms (MMPs) by combining established technology adoption theories (TAM, TPB) with patient-centric factors like convenience, credibility, and privacy. The findings highlight that perceived credibility and convenience are key drivers of positive attitudes towards MMPs, ultimately influencing their adoption for healthcare management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing prevalence of chronic diseases worldwide puts a strain on traditional healthcare systems, making medical services costly and inaccessible for many. Mobile medical platforms (MMPs) offer a promising solution by increasing accessibility and efficiency. However, despite their potential, the adoption and sustained use of MMPs remain a challenge. While existing research has explored factors like perceived usefulness and ease of use, there's a significant gap in understanding the specific patient-centered factors that influence acceptance. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining how perceived convenience, credibility, and privacy risk, alongside established TAM and TPB constructs, impact user acceptance of MMPs.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using a survey-based methodology. They integrated two prominent theoretical frameworks:

  • Technology Acceptance Model (TAM): This model focuses on how perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use influence user attitudes and intentions to adopt technology.
  • Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB): This theory posits that behavioral intention is shaped by attitudes, subjective norms (social influence), and perceived behavioral control.

To these established models, they added three crucial patient-centered factors:

  • Perceived Convenience: How easy and timely it is for patients to access services.
  • Perceived Credibility: The trustworthiness and reliability of the information and services provided.
  • Perceived Privacy Risk: Concerns about the security and potential misuse of personal health data.

Data was collected through an online questionnaire administered to 389 Chinese smartphone users with experience using MMPs. The collected data was then analyzed using Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) to test the proposed hypotheses and the relationships between the various constructs.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study collected primary data through a self-administered online questionnaire.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Credibility is King (and Queen): Perceived credibility emerged as a particularly strong predictor, influencing not only attitude directly but also indirectly through perceived usefulness and convenience. This suggests that for patients, trusting the information and the platform itself is paramount, even more so than just the convenience it offers.
  • Convenience Matters, But Trust is Foundational: While perceived convenience positively impacts attitudes, its effect is less pronounced than credibility. This implies that while patients appreciate the ease of access, they will prioritize platforms they trust to provide accurate and reliable health information.
  • Privacy Concerns are Real, But Not Always Dominant: Perceived privacy risk negatively affected perceived usefulness and behavioral intention, but its direct impact on attitude was minimal. This suggests that while privacy is a concern, it might not be the primary barrier to adoption if the perceived benefits (usefulness, convenience) are high enough. However, efforts to mitigate privacy risks are still crucial.
  • Social Influence Takes a Backseat: Interestingly, social influence (family/friends' opinions) had no significant effect on attitudes or behavioral intentions towards MMPs in this Chinese context. This could be due to MMPs being in their early stages of adoption in China, leading to less widespread discussion and recommendation.
  • Usability is the Bedrock: Perceived ease of use was a significant predictor of perceived usefulness and convenience, reinforcing the idea that a user-friendly interface is fundamental for MMPs to be perceived as beneficial.

Key Results

The study found that:

  • Perceived credibility and perceived convenience significantly influenced patients' attitudes towards MMPs.
  • Perceived usefulness, attitude, perceived privacy risk, and perceived behavioral control were significant determinants of behavioral intention to use MMPs.
  • Behavioral intention and perceived behavioral control strongly predicted perceived effective use of MMPs.
  • Perceived credibility and perceived ease of use positively affected perceived convenience.
  • Perceived ease of use, perceived credibility, and perceived privacy risk influenced perceived usefulness.
  • The integrated model explained a substantial portion of the variance: 62.6% for perceived effective use, 65.7% for behavioral intention, 71.1% for attitude, 63.2% for perceived convenience, and 64.6% for perceived usefulness.
  • 14 out of 17 hypotheses were supported, indicating a robust model.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cultural Specificity: The study was conducted solely in China. Cultural differences can influence social norms and perceptions, so findings may not generalize to other regions. Future research should include cross-cultural comparisons.
  • Early Adoption Phase: MMPs are in their nascent stages in China. The findings might be specific to this early adoption phase. Further studies are needed to examine acceptance in the post-adoption phase.
  • No Real Usage Scenario: Participants answered based on past experiences, not actual usage during the study. This could introduce recall bias, particularly for factors like perceived credibility. Future research should ideally incorporate real-world usage scenarios.

The authors suggest future work could explore how to improve MMP usability for diverse patient abilities and resources, and investigate mediators between perceived privacy risk and behavioral intention, given the sensitive nature of health data. They also recommend extending the study to examine different MMPs during the post-implementation stage.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mobile medical platforms (MMPs) can make medical services more accessible and effective. However, the patient-centered factors that influence patients' acceptance of MMPs are not well understood. Our study examined the factors affecting patients' acceptance of MMPs by integrating the theory of planned behavior (TPB), the technology acceptance model (TAM), and three patient-centered factors (i.e., perceived convenience, perceived credibility, and perceived privacy risk). Three hundred and eighty-nine Chinese respondents were recruited in this study and completed a self-administered online questionnaire that included items adapted from validated measurement scales. The partial least squares structural equation modeling results revealed that perceived privacy risk, perceived credibility, and perceived ease of use directly determined the perceived usefulness of an MMP. Perceived convenience, perceived credibility, and perceived usefulness significantly affected the patients' attitudes toward MMPs. Perceived usefulness, attitude, perceived privacy risk, and perceived behavioral control were important determinants of the patients' behavioral intentions to use MMPs. Behavioral intention and perceived behavioral control significantly influenced perceived effective use. Perceived credibility and perceived ease of use significantly affected perceived convenience. However, social influence had no significant effect on attitude and behavioral intention. The study provides important theoretical and practical implications, which could help practitioners enhance the patients' use of MMPs for their healthcare activities.
BibTeX
@article{wang2022determinants,
  author = {Hailiang Wang and Jiaxin Zhang and Yan Luximon and Mingfu Qin and Ping Geng and Da Tao},
  title = {{The Determinants of User Acceptance of Mobile Medical Platforms: An Investigation Integrating the TPB, TAM, and Patient-Centered Factors}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph191710758},
}
Figure