The Deposit Business at Large vs. Small Banks

Adrien d’Avernas, Andrea L. Eisfeldt, Can Huang, Richard Stanton, Nancy Wallace2023 · DOI

Abstract

The deposit business differs at large versus small banks. We provide a parsimonious model and extensive empirical evidence supporting the idea that much of the variation in deposit-pricing behavior between large and small banks reflects differences in "preferences and technologies." Large banks offer superior liquidity services but lower deposit rates, and locate where customers value their services. In addition to receiving a lower level of deposit rates on average, customers of large banks exhibit lower demand elasticities with respect to deposit rate spreads. As a result, despite the fact that the locations of large-bank branches have demographics typically associated with greater financial sophistication, large-bank customers earn lower average deposit rates. Our explanation for deposit pricing behavior challenges the idea that deposit pricing is mainly driven by pricing power derived from the large observed degree of concentration in the banking industry.

Introduction: The Mega-Bank Rate Gap

In the United States, the banking landscape is dominated by a small number of "mega-banks." Just 14 institutions hold over half of all domestic deposits. A persistent observation in this market is that these giants consistently offer lower interest rates to savers than their smaller counterparts. Traditional economic theory often attributes this to market concentration—the idea that big banks use their dominant position to "squeeze" customers. However, this paper challenges that narrative, proposing that the deposit business is defined by product differentiation rather than raw monopoly power.

Service vs. Yield: A Different Business Model

The authors argue that large banks operate a fundamentally different business model. Instead of competing on price (interest rates), they compete on "liquidity services." These include superior mobile applications, vast ATM networks, and a high density of physical branches. This strategy targets a specific demographic: high-income urban customers who value convenience and transaction ease over marginal gains in yield.

Methodology and Data

To test this hypothesis, the researchers developed a theoretical model where banks choose between two strategies: being "large" (investing in high-tech services and operating across many markets with a uniform interest rate) or "small" (operating locally and competing primarily on price).

They employed a "BLP-style" (Berry, Levinsohn, and Pakes) demand system to estimate rate elasticity—how sensitive customers are to changes in interest rates. This structural estimation accounts for unobserved bank characteristics and the endogenous nature of rate-setting. The study utilized three primary datasets covering 2001 to 2020:

  1. RateWatch (S&P Global): Weekly branch-level data on advertised rates for products like Money Market accounts and 12-month CDs.
  2. Regulatory Data (FDIC): Bank-level financial statements and branch-level deposit balances.
  3. Data Axle: Demographic data for approximately 67 million U.S. households.

Key Findings: The Sophistication Paradox

One of the study's most striking findings is the "Sophistication Paradox." Large banks tend to cluster in wealthy, high-density urban areas. While these customers are often considered "financially sophisticated," they are actually less sensitive to interest rates on their deposits. This is because they primarily use deposits for transactions and liquidity, keeping the bulk of their investment wealth in higher-yield assets like equities. For these depositors, a seamless mobile app or a nearby ATM is more valuable than an extra 20 basis points of interest.

The empirical results confirm this:

  • The Rate Gap: On average, large banks pay approximately 26 basis points (0.26%) less on Money Market accounts and 48 basis points less on 12-month CDs than small banks.
  • Elasticity Differences: The estimated rate semi-elasticity for small banks is 1.539, compared to just 0.958 for large banks. This indicates that small bank customers are significantly more likely to move their funds in response to rate changes.

The Role of Uniform Pricing and Location

Large banks typically set uniform interest rates across all their branches nationwide. This "one-size-fits-all" approach acts as a constraint, preventing them from tailoring rates to local competitive conditions. Consequently, large banks are selective about their locations, entering only those markets where the average customer matches their service-heavy, low-yield model.

Counterfactual simulations highlight the importance of location:

  • Randomizing a large bank's branch locations resulted in a 14.37% drop in profits.
  • In contrast, allowing large banks to use flexible (non-uniform) pricing only increased profits by 6.98%.

This suggests that strategic location is more vital to a large bank's bottom line than pricing flexibility.

Conclusion: Beyond Market Concentration

The study suggests that the standard measure of market concentration, the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI), is a poor predictor of deposit rates. In fact, customer elasticity explains ten times more of the variation in deposit rates than HHI does.

While large banks currently maintain a competitive edge through technology and branch networks, this advantage may be shifting. As small banks catch up in digital offerings, the "technological gap" may erode, potentially forcing large banks to reconsider their low-yield pricing models. For now, however, the deposit market remains a tale of two distinct strategies: one focused on price, and the other on the value of convenience.

Summary updated

Abstract

The deposit business differs at large versus small banks.We provide a parsimonious model and extensive empirical evidence supporting the idea that much of the variation in deposit-pricing behavior between large and small banks reflects differences in "preferences and technologies."Large banks offer superior liquidity services but lower deposit rates, and locate where customers value their services.In addition to receiving a lower level of deposit rates on average, customers of large banks exhibit lower demand elasticities with respect to deposit rate spreads.As a result, despite the fact that the locations of large-bank branches have demographics typically associated with greater financial sophistication, large-bank customers earn lower average deposit rates.Our explanation for deposit pricing behavior challenges the idea that deposit pricing is mainly driven by pricing power derived from the large observed degree of concentration in the banking industry.
BibTeX
@misc{davernas2023deposit,
  author = {Adrien d’Avernas and Andrea L. Eisfeldt and Can Huang and Richard Stanton and Nancy Wallace},
  title = {{The Deposit Business at Large vs. Small Banks}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3386/w31865},
}
Figure