The cyclic expansion and contraction characteristics of a loess slope and implications for slope stability

Hengxing Lan, Xiaoxia Zhao, Renato Macciotta, Jianbing Peng, Langping Li, Wu Yu-ming, Yanbo Zhu, Xin Liu, Ning Zhang, Shijie Liu, Chenghu Zhou, John J. ClagueScientific 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Loess deposits cover approximately 6.6% of China, forming extensive and often unstable steep slopes. This study investigates the mechanical behavior of a 70-meter-high loess slope near Yan'an, China, through high-precision monitoring. Using Ground-Based Synthetic Aperture Radar (GB-SAR) and in-situ displacement meters, researchers identified a cyclic pattern of contraction and expansion—a phenomenon termed "breathing." These movements are driven by daily and annual thermal and moisture fluctuations. While some deformations are recoverable, non-recoverable cyclic strains suggest cumulative damage to the loess structure, potentially leading to slope failure. Under projected climate change scenarios, these thermal stresses are expected to intensify, further compromising slope stability.

Introduction

Loess is a wind-blown, silty sedimentary deposit prevalent in northern and northwestern China. Natural erosion and human activity have created numerous steep slopes in these regions, many of which are prone to landslides. While traditional triggers like rainfall and seismic activity are well-studied, the role of subtle, repetitive thermal stresses—thermal fatigue—has remained largely unexplored. This research aims to quantify how weather cycles physically deform loess slopes and evaluate the long-term implications for stability.

Study Site and Instrumentation

The research focused on a 70-meter-high loess slope located near Yan'an city in Shanxi Province. The site features several scarps and was monitored over a one-year period from September 2018 to August 2019.

Figure 1: Geographic location and overview of the monitored loess slope near Yan'an, China, showing measurement sites and scarps.

To capture the sub-millimeter "breathing" of the slope, the team employed a Ground-Based Synthetic Aperture Radar (GB-SAR) system, providing deformation maps every 15 minutes. This was supplemented by in-situ hygrothermographs buried at depths of 0.1m to 0.6m to track soil temperature and moisture, as well as traditional displacement meters for validation.

Figure 2: Instrumentation used for monitoring, including (a) GB-SAR sensor, (b) surface hygrothermograph, (c) buried soil sensors, and (d) solar power supply.

Methods and Data

The study utilized a massive dataset of 24,518 GB-SAR images alongside high-frequency meteorological data. Researchers applied the classical heat diffusion equation and finite element methods to model heat transfer through the soil. By linking temperature changes to physical deformation via a linear thermal expansion model, they sought to validate the mechanism behind the observed cyclic movements.

Key Findings

Cyclic "Breathing" Patterns

The slope exhibits distinct sinusoidal deformation. Daily cycles typically show maximum contraction between 3:00 and 8:00 AM and maximum expansion between 2:00 and 5:30 PM, with amplitudes often reaching 1 mm. On an annual scale, the greatest contraction occurs during the coldest period in late January, while maximum expansion peaks in late July or early August.

Energy Conservation and Moisture

The slope acts as a thermal battery, absorbing energy to expand and releasing it to contract. Soil moisture plays a critical role by increasing the soil's heat capacity; wetter areas demonstrated smaller temperature fluctuations and reduced cyclic deformation compared to drier sections.

Elastic vs. Plastic Deformation

Monitoring revealed two types of behavior. At Site 1, deformations were largely recoverable, suggesting the soil remained within its elastic limit. However, Site 2 exhibited non-recoverable deformation, accumulating 8–14 mm of permanent outward movement over the year. This permanent shift indicates the breakage of internal bonds between soil grains, a precursor to potential slope failure.

Climate Change Implications

Using IPCC RCP 8.5 scenarios, the model predicts that a 3.5 °C rise in global temperatures by 2100 will result in an additional 0.35 mm of average expansion. This represents a 70% increase in expansion amplitude relative to current daily cycles, significantly accelerating the process of thermal fatigue and structural degradation.

Conclusion

The discovery of cyclic thermal "breathing" in loess slopes provides a new lens through which to view slope stability. The cumulative damage caused by non-recoverable thermal deformation suggests that slopes may fail over time even in the absence of extreme weather events. Integrating these thermal fatigue models into engineering practices will be essential for predicting the long-term stability of loess regions, especially as climate change intensifies thermal stresses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Loess covers approximately 6.6% of China and forms thick extensive deposits in the northern and northwestern parts of the country. Natural erosional processes and human modification of thick loess deposits have produced abundant, potentially unstable steep slopes in this region. Slope deformation monitoring aimed at evaluating the mechanical behavior of a loess slope has shown a cyclic pattern of contraction and expansion. Such cyclic strain change on the slope materials can damage the loess and contribute to slope instability. The site showing this behavior is a 70-m high loess slope near Yan'an city in Shanxi Province, northwest China. A Ground-Based Synthetic Aperture Radar (GB-SAR) sensor and a displacement meter were used to monitor this cyclic deformation of the slope over a one-year period from September 2018 to August 2019. It is postulated that this cyclic behavior corresponds to thermal and moisture fluctuations, following energy conservation laws. To investigate the validity of this mechanism, physical models of soil temperature and moisture measured by hygrothermographs were used to simulate the observed cyclic deformations. We found good correlations between the models based on the proposed mechanism and the exhibited daily and annual cyclic contraction and expansion. The slope absorbed energy from the time of maximum contraction to the time of maximum expansion, and released energy from the time of maximum expansion to the time of maximum contraction. Recoverable cyclic deformations suggest stresses in the loess are within the elastic range, and non-recoverable cyclic deformations suggest damage of the loess material (breakage of bonds between soil grains), which could lead to instability. Based on these observations and the models, we developed a quantitative relationship between weather cycles and thermal deformation of the slope. Given the current climate change projections of temperature increases of up to 3.5 °C by 2100, the model estimates the loess slope to expand about 0.35 mm in average, which would be in addition to the current cyclic "breathing" behavior experienced by the slope.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lan2021cyclic,
  author = {Hengxing Lan and Xiaoxia Zhao and Renato Macciotta and Jianbing Peng and Langping Li and WU Yu-ming and Yanbo Zhu and Xin Liu and Ning Zhang and Shijie Liu and Chenghu Zhou and John J. Clague},
  title = {{The cyclic expansion and contraction characteristics of a loess slope and implications for slope stability}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-81821-4},
}
Figure