Abstract
The occurrence of the crisis of teachers' ethics and style in Colleges and universities has seriously damaged the reputation of the teachers in Colleges and universities. This article summarizes the cases of teachers' violation of teachers' ethics and style in Colleges and universities that have been publicly exposed on the Internet and reported on the website of the Ministry of education in the past ten years, makes a statistical analysis of the misconduct of teachers in Colleges and universities, displays various manifestations of the crisis of teachers' ethics and style from multiple dimensions, and reveals the disaster areas where the crisis of teachers' ethics and style broke out, This paper analyzes the loopholes in the prevention mechanism of the crisis of teachers' morality and style, and finally puts forward the idea of implementing the whole process and early warning evaluation mechanism.
Introduction
Despite strict "red line" policies and high-pressure punishments from China’s Ministry of Education, ethical misconduct among university faculty persists. These breaches—ranging from academic fraud to inappropriate personal conduct—damage the reputation of higher education and undermine the "Double First-Class" initiative aimed at building world-class universities. Current management systems are often reactive, focusing on punishment after a scandal breaks rather than prevention. This study seeks to understand the specific dimensions of these ethical crises: where they happen, what triggers them, and how universities can build a "dynamic" early-warning system to catch red flags early.
Methodology and Dataset
The researchers employed a two-pronged approach. First, they conducted a statistical analysis of 93 typical cases of professional ethics violations reported between 2013 and May 2022. These cases were sourced from official reports on the Ministry of Education website and publicly exposed incidents on the Internet. The cases were coded into 11 indicators of speech and behavior, categorized into "internal" (on-campus) and "external" (off-campus) misconduct.
Second, based on this data, they developed a Grid-based multi-subject whole process evaluation model. This framework integrates feedback from school leaders, peers, students, and psychological experts across three phases: recruitment, pre-induction training, and ongoing on-the-job assessment.
Analysis of Misconduct Trends
The data reveals a "highs and lows" trend in exposure frequency. A notable spike occurred around 2016, which the authors suggest is due to a "social demonstration effect" following the Ministry of Education's public notification of ethics cases, encouraging more victims to come forward. Since 2019, there has been a general decrease in the frequency of ethical crises, credited to the deterrent effect of joint policies issued by seven government ministries.
Key Findings: The "Disaster Areas" of Misconduct
The most frequent ethical breach involves inappropriate teacher-student relationships, accounting for nearly 29% of all cases. Within the school environment specifically, this category jumps to 36.49% of incidents. The authors attribute this to the "natural inequality" of power in academia, which can lead to injustice or harassment if not strictly regulated.
While universities focus on classroom behavior, a significant portion of ethical crises happens off-campus. Specifically, 55% of off-campus misconduct relates to "family ethics," and 20% relates to "online discourse."
Proposed Prevention Mechanism
To address these issues, the authors propose moving away from reactive, annual reviews toward a "whole-process" evaluation model. Key features include:
- Psychological Screening: Inclusion of psychological experts during the teacher selection phase to conduct mental health tests and screen for potential behavioral risks.
- Multi-Subject Feedback: Integrating evaluations from students, peers, and administrators to create a more comprehensive ethical profile.
- Dynamic Assessment: Continuous monitoring rather than static, once-a-year checks.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that their dataset of 93 cases is not exhaustive, as it relies on publicly reported incidents which may suffer from selection bias. Future work involves the practical implementation of the "Grid-based" model. Moving from a theoretical framework to a functional "early warning" system requires overcoming administrative hurdles, such as protecting the anonymity of student evaluators while ensuring assessments are not misused.
Summary updated