Abstract: This research argues that representations of ancient architecture in Chinese period movies are more than mere entertainment; they serve as vital materials for architectural history. By examining the 1940 film Confucius, designed by professional architect Fei Kang, the study explores how cinematic sets became a "creative concretization" of an idealized Chinese architectural identity. Facing a lack of archaeological data for the Spring and Autumn Period, Fei Kang synthesized later historical structural logic with Modernist aesthetics, reflecting the theoretical priorities of 1930s Chinese architectural historians.
Introduction: The Authenticity Trap
In the field of architectural history, period movie sets are frequently dismissed as inauthentic. However, this paper posits that these sets are primary sources that reflect the intersection of cinema, academic research, and national identity. The central challenge for the film’s architect, Fei Kang, was the "authenticity trap": designing for the Spring and Autumn Period (770–403 B.C.) despite a near-total absence of surviving physical structures or detailed records from that era. To bridge this gap, Kang utilized the film as a laboratory to test-drive contemporary architectural theories.
Methodology: Cinema as Applied History
The study employs a comparative historical analysis, treating the production of Confucius as a case study in applied architectural history. The methodology involves mapping specific design choices to the theoretical frameworks promoted by the Society for Research in Chinese Architecture in the 1930s.
As illustrated in the framework above, the "Ideal Image of Chinese Architecture" was formed through a dialogue between academic research (ancient remains and literature), modern architectural influences, and their visual manifestation in cinema. The author analyzed film stills recovered by the Hong Kong Film Archive alongside 1930s survey drawings of the Qufu Confucian Temple and academic journals of the period.
Key Insights: Defining the National Style
The Structural Bias and the Dougong
During the 1930s, Chinese architectural historians, led by figures like Liang Sicheng, identified the dougong (bracket set) as the essential "soul" of Chinese building. Fei Kang reflected this academic obsession by making simplified dougong a prominent feature of the film’s sets. Since no Spring and Autumn period brackets were known, he "borrowed" and simplified styles from the Song and Yuan dynasties—the oldest available data—to signify antiquity.
Simplification as Academic Rejection
The film’s "Apricot Pavilion" (Xingtan) was intentionally stripped of the elaborate ornamentation found in extant Qing Dynasty temples. This was not merely a budgetary constraint but a deliberate reflection of the 1930s academic rejection of "decadent" late-imperial decoration in favor of what was perceived as "pure" structural form.
Modernism as a Spatial Filler
Because historical data on ancient interiors was non-existent, Fei Kang integrated Modernist elements to fill the void. The film features long, horizontal rectangular windows—a hallmark of the International Style—to create a sense of space that felt both modern and timelessly Chinese. This indicates that for 1940s architects, the "Chinese" ideal was inherently tied to contemporary spatial logic.
Conclusion
The sets of Confucius were never intended to be literal replicas of the 5th century B.C. Instead, they represent a high-fidelity projection of 1930s architectural theory. The film served as a bridge between academic research and public imagination, demonstrating that the "ideal image" of Chinese architecture was a hybrid: it used later-period structural logic to represent the past and Modernist spatial logic to define a forward-looking national identity.
Summary updated