The COVID-19 Outbreak and Affected Countries Stock Markets Response

Haiyue Liu, Aqsa Manzoor, Cangyu Wang, Lei Zhang, Zaira ManzoorInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the immediate impact of the COVID-19 outbreak on 21 major global stock market indices. It reveals a significant negative shock to stock markets worldwide, with Asian countries experiencing more pronounced downturns. The research highlights that investor sentiment, driven by fear and uncertainty, plays a crucial role in transmitting the pandemic's economic shock to financial markets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid and unprecedented spread of the COVID-19 pandemic presented a significant challenge to global economies and financial markets. Understanding the immediate impact of such a novel infectious disease on stock market performance is crucial for investors, policymakers, and public health officials. While previous studies have examined the effects of infectious diseases like SARS and Ebola on financial markets, the unique characteristics of COVID-19 (its rapid global spread, the uncertainty surrounding its transmission and severity, and the implementation of widespread containment measures) necessitated a specific analysis. This paper aims to quantify this short-term impact and identify the underlying mechanisms driving market reactions.

Methods

The researchers employed an event study methodology to analyze the impact of the COVID-19 outbreak on stock market indices. This approach involves:

  • Defining an event: The "event day" was set as January 20, 2020, when a key Chinese health official confirmed human-to-human transmission, marking a turning point in public awareness.
  • Estimating normal returns: A market model (using Ordinary Least Squares regression) was used to estimate the expected returns of each stock index during a pre-event period (90 trading days before the event).
  • Calculating abnormal returns (AR): The difference between the actual stock index return and the estimated normal return on a given day.
  • Calculating cumulative abnormal returns (CAR): The sum of abnormal returns over a specified event window (e.g., 0-6 days after the event).
  • Analyzing different event windows: The study examined several event windows (0-6, 7-13, 14-20, 21-27, and 28-34 days after the event) to capture the evolving market response.
  • Panel data regression: To further analyze the relationship between confirmed COVID-19 cases and stock market abnormal returns, controlling for global and country-specific factors, and to test for regional effects (Asia vs. non-Asia).
  • Mediating effect analysis: The study investigated the role of investor sentiment, proxied by the VIX (Volatility Index), as a transmission channel for the pandemic's impact on stock markets.

Datasets

The study utilized daily closing prices for 21 leading stock market indices from major affected countries. These indices represent markets in Asia (Japan, Korea, Singapore, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Shanghai, Shenzhen, Malaysia, Indonesia, Thailand, India), Europe (Germany, Italy, UK, France, Russia), and North America (USA, Canada). The Dow Jones Global Index was used as a benchmark index to calculate abnormal returns. Data was collected from February 21, 2019, to March 18, 2020, sourced from the China Stock Market & Accounting Research (CSMAR) database and the website Investing.com. Logged global COVID-19 confirmed cases were extracted from the WIND database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Asia's disproportionate impact: Asian stock markets experienced more significant negative abnormal returns compared to markets outside Asia, suggesting a heightened sensitivity in the region, likely due to the initial epicenter and proximity.
  • Investor sentiment as a key mediator: The study strongly suggests that investor fear and pessimistic sentiment, amplified by media coverage and uncertainty surrounding the pandemic, act as a crucial channel through which COVID-19 impacts stock market performance. The VIX index was identified as a complete mediator in this transmission.
  • Two distinct market shocks: The analysis identified two significant plunges in average abnormal returns (AAR) and cumulative average abnormal returns (CAAR) around day 1 and day 24, which correspond to the initial outbreak in China and the subsequent widespread outbreaks outside Asia, respectively.
  • Resilience of Chinese markets: While initially hit hard, the stock markets in mainland China (represented by SSEC and SZCS) showed signs of recovery and even positive cumulative abnormal returns in later event windows, suggesting a quicker rebound as containment measures took effect.

Key Results

  • Immediate negative shock: Stock markets in major affected countries experienced a quick and significant fall immediately following the COVID-19 outbreak.
  • Significant negative CARs: In the initial event window (0-6 days), indices for Hong Kong, Malaysia, Japan, and Thailand showed significant negative cumulative abnormal returns (CARs).
  • Regional differences: While Asian countries generally saw negative CARs, Canada showed a significantly positive CAR in the initial window.
  • VIX as a mediator: The VIX (investor fear index) was found to be a significant mediator, confirming that increased volatility and investor panic transmit the pandemic's shock to stock markets.
  • OLS regression findings: Panel data regressions confirmed a significant negative relationship between confirmed COVID-19 cases and daily abnormal stock market returns. The "Asia" dummy variable also showed a significant negative coefficient, reinforcing the finding of a greater impact in Asian markets.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Short-term focus: The study primarily examines the immediate and short-term effects of the COVID-19 outbreak due to the limited event window. The evolving nature of the virus and its long-term economic consequences were not fully captured.
  • Demographic variables: The analysis did not include demographic variables (age, gender, education, investor type) due to data limitations, which could offer further insights into investor behavior.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Longer-term analysis: Investigating the sustained impact of the pandemic on stock markets over a longer period.
  • Investor sentiment and uncertainty: Further exploring investor confidence and uncertainty as frameworks for analysis.
  • Cross-country comparisons: Deeper dives into investor confidence and interdependencies between foreign markets.
  • Policy implications: Examining the effectiveness of various policy interventions in mitigating the economic impact of pandemics.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper evaluates the short-term impact of the coronavirus outbreak on 21 leading stock market indices in major affected countries including Japan, Korea, Singapore, the USA, Germany, Italy, and the UK etc. The consequences of infectious disease are considerable and have been directly affecting stock markets worldwide. Using an event study method, our results indicate that the stock markets in major affected countries and areas fell quickly after the virus outbreak. Countries in Asia experienced more negative abnormal returns as compared to other countries. Further panel fixed effect regressions also support the adverse effect of COVID-19 confirmed cases on stock indices abnormal returns through an effective channel by adding up investors' pessimistic sentiment on future returns and fears of uncertainties.
BibTeX
@article{liu2020covid,
  author = {Haiyue Liu and Aqsa Manzoor and Cangyu Wang and Lei Zhang and Zaira Manzoor},
  title = {{The COVID-19 Outbreak and Affected Countries Stock Markets Response}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph17082800},
}
Figure