Abstract
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s11071-021-06705-8.
Introduction
SARS-CoV-2 is a dynamic pathogen. As it spreads, it mutates into variants with varying degrees of transmissibility and severity. Traditional epidemiological models, such as the standard SIR model, often treat viruses as static entities, failing to account for how public health policies might influence the evolutionary trajectory of the virus. This paper addresses this gap by introducing the coSIR (competitive SIR) model to study the competition between viral strains under different policy interventions.
Methodology: The coSIR Model
The researchers developed the coSIR model by extending the SIDARTHE framework. Unlike the standard SIR model, coSIR categorizes infected individuals into five distinct subgroups for each competing strain based on symptom severity and detection status:
- $i_j$: Asymptomatic, undetected.
- $d_j$: Asymptomatic, detected (via testing).
- $a_j$: Ailing (symptomatic), undetected.
- $r_j$: Recognized (symptomatic), detected.
- $t_j$: Threatened (life-threatening symptoms, detected).
The model utilizes a system of Ordinary Differential Equations (ODEs) to simulate the competition between two strains. It also accounts for partial cross-immunity through a "risk reduction rate" ($\omega$), which represents the reduced likelihood of reinfection after exposure to a different strain.
Key Insights and Results
The study identifies a "Stealth Advantage" for variants with lower severity. Because these strains produce fewer symptoms, infected individuals are less likely to be detected and isolated, allowing the virus to circulate longer and reach more hosts. This leads to a "Mortality Paradox": a variant that is significantly less lethal but more transmissible can cause a much larger outbreak and more total deaths than a highly lethal but slow-moving strain.
Key findings include:
- Evolutionary Direction: The model predicts SARS-CoV-2 will likely evolve toward a "flu-like" state—highly transmissible but with lower individual pathogenicity.
- Policy Robustness: "Block" policies (e.g., masks, social distancing) are the most effective across all variant types.
- Policy Synergy: Combining "Isolation" (quarantining the sick) and "Screening" (mass testing) can match the effectiveness of lockdowns without the same economic impact.
- Mobile Cabin Hospitals: These facilities are highlighted as effective "dual-threat" interventions that simultaneously increase isolation and cure rates.
Limitations and Future Work
The model assumes a well-mixed population and significant cross-immunity between strains. Future research could extend the model to include vaccination dynamics, age-stratified populations, and more complex feedback loops between policy changes and hospital capacity.
Summary updated