The correlation between reading and mathematics ability at age twelve has a substantial genetic component

Oliver S. P. Davis, Gavin Band, Matti Pirinen, Claire M. A. Haworth, Emma L. Meaburn, Yulia Kovas, Nicole Harlaar, Sophia Docherty, Ken B. Hanscombe, Maciej Trzaskowski, Charles Curtis, Amy Strange, Colin Freeman, Céline Bellenguez, Zhan Su, Richard D. Pearson, Damjan Vukcevic, Cordelia Langford, Panos Deloukas, Sarah Hunt, Emma Gray, Serge Dronov, Simon Potter, Avazeh Tashakkori-Ghanbaria, Sarah Edkins, Suzannah J. Bumpstead, Jenefer M. Blackwell, Elvira Bramon, Matthew A. Brown, Juan P. Casas, Aiden Corvin, Audrey Duncanson, Janusz Jankowski, Hugh S. Markus, Christopher G. Mathew, Colin N. A. Palmer, Anna Rautanen, Stephen Sawcer, Richard C. Trembath, Ananth C. Viswanathan, Nicholas Wood, Inês Barroso, Leena Peltonen, Philip S. Dale, Stephen A. Petrill, Leonard C. Schalkwyk, Ian Craig, Cathryn M. Lewis, Thomas S. Price, Peter Donnelly, Robert Plomin, Chris C. A. SpencerNature Communications 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the genetic underpinnings of reading and math abilities in 12-year-olds. It reveals a significant genetic component to both skills and suggests that approximately half of the correlation between them is due to shared genetic factors, supporting the "Generalist Genes" hypothesis. This work emphasizes the interplay of genetics and environment in shaping cognitive development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the genetic and environmental factors that influence cognitive abilities like reading and mathematics is crucial for optimizing learning and addressing learning difficulties. While previous research has established that these traits are heritable, the specific genetic architecture and how genetic factors contribute to the correlation between reading and math abilities have remained unclear. This paper aims to dissect this genetic architecture, particularly focusing on the shared genetic influences that might explain why individuals who are good at reading often tend to be good at math, and vice versa.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  • Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS): They analyzed genetic data from a large sample of twins to identify specific genetic variants (SNPs) associated with reading and mathematics ability. This involved a discovery phase followed by a replication phase to confirm any significant findings.
  • Bivariate Twin and Population-Level Variance Component Models:
    • Twin Models: These models leverage the unique genetic relatedness of monozygotic (identical) and dizygotic (fraternal) twins to estimate the proportions of variance in traits attributable to additive genetics, shared environment, and non-shared environment. The bivariate extension allows for the estimation of genetic and environmental correlations between two traits.
  • Population-Level Models: These models use genome-wide SNP data from individuals who are not closely related to estimate the proportion of phenotypic variance explained by common genetic variants. This approach provides a lower-bound estimate of heritability and genetic correlation.

By combining these methods, the study aimed to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the genetic architecture and its contribution to the correlation between reading and math abilities.

Datasets

  • Twins Early Development Study (TEDS): This is the primary dataset, comprising approximately 3,000 twin pairs measured for reading and mathematics ability at age twelve. Genotyping data was collected using the Illumina Immunochip.
  • Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC): This dataset was used for replication of GWAS findings, specifically for word-reading efficiency.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Substantial Genetic Influence: The study strongly supports the idea that both reading and mathematics abilities at age twelve have a significant genetic component.
  • Shared Genetic Basis for Correlation: A key finding is that a substantial portion (estimated around half) of the observed correlation between reading and mathematics ability is due to shared genetic factors. This aligns with the "Generalist Genes" hypothesis, which posits that many genes influence a wide range of cognitive abilities.
  • Polygenic Nature: The GWAS did not identify any single genetic variants with a large effect that could be reliably replicated. This reinforces the understanding that these complex traits are highly polygenic, meaning they are influenced by many genes, each with a small effect.
  • Complementary Methodologies: The convergence of results from both twin-based and population-level genetic analyses strengthens the confidence in the findings regarding genetic correlation.

Key Results

  • Heritability Estimates: Twin models estimated the narrow-sense heritability of reading at approximately 66% and mathematics at around 51%.
  • Genetic Correlation: The bivariate twin model estimated a genetic correlation between reading and mathematics ability of approximately 0.64 (with a 95% CI of 0.56-0.72). The population-level model yielded a similar genetic correlation of 0.74 (with a 95% CI of 0.32-1.00).
  • Contribution to Phenotypic Correlation: The study estimates that around half of the observed phenotypic correlation (r=0.60) between reading and mathematics is due to shared genetic effects.
  • GWAS Findings: No single SNP replicated consistently across discovery and replication phases, supporting the polygenic nature of these traits. A region on chromosome 19 showed a strong association for reading ability but failed to replicate.

Limitations and Future Work

  • "Missing Heritability": The GWAS approach, relying on common SNPs, likely underestimates the total genetic contribution to these traits, as rare variants or structural variations might also play a role.
  • Environmental Influences: While the study highlights shared genetic influences, it also underscores the importance of the learning environment in contributing to individual differences in cognitive abilities. Future work could further disentangle the complex interplay between genetic predispositions and environmental factors.
  • Sample Size for GWAS: Although large, the sample size for the GWAS might still be insufficient to detect the small effects of individual SNPs for highly polygenic traits. Larger sample sizes and meta-analyses are suggested for future studies to pinpoint specific genetic variants.
  • Generalist Genes Hypothesis: The findings provide strong support for the Generalist Genes hypothesis, but further research is needed to identify these specific genes and understand their mechanisms of action.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dissecting how genetic and environmental influences impact on learning is helpful for maximizing numeracy and literacy. Here we show, using twin and genome-wide analysis, that there is a substantial genetic component to children's ability in reading and mathematics, and estimate that around one half of the observed correlation in these traits is due to shared genetic effects (so-called Generalist Genes). Thus, our results highlight the potential role of the learning environment in contributing to differences in a child's cognitive abilities at age twelve.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{davis2014correlation,
  author = {Oliver S. P. Davis and Gavin Band and Matti Pirinen and Claire M. A. Haworth and Emma L. Meaburn and Yulia Kovas and Nicole Harlaar and Sophia Docherty and Ken B. Hanscombe and Maciej Trzaskowski and Charles Curtis and Amy Strange and Colin Freeman and Céline Bellenguez and Zhan Su and Richard D. Pearson and Damjan Vukcevic and Cordelia Langford and Panos Deloukas and Sarah Hunt and Emma Gray and Serge Dronov and Simon Potter and Avazeh Tashakkori-Ghanbaria and Sarah Edkins and Suzannah J. Bumpstead and Jenefer M. Blackwell and Elvira Bramon and Matthew A. Brown and Juan P. Casas and Aiden Corvin and Audrey Duncanson and Janusz Jankowski and Hugh S. Markus and Christopher G. Mathew and Colin N. A. Palmer and Anna Rautanen and Stephen Sawcer and Richard C. Trembath and Ananth C. Viswanathan and Nicholas Wood and Inês Barroso and Leena Peltonen and Philip S. Dale and Stephen A. Petrill and Leonard C. Schalkwyk and Ian Craig and Cathryn M. Lewis and Thomas S. Price and Peter Donnelly and Robert Plomin and Chris C. A. Spencer},
  title = {{The correlation between reading and mathematics ability at age twelve has a substantial genetic component}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1038/ncomms5204},
}
Figure