THE CORRELATION BETWEEN HAZE AND ECONOMIC GROWTH: BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS BASED ON WOS DATABASE

Hongkai Xiong, Zihan ZhaoApplied Ecology and Environmental Research 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This study analyzes 4,225 articles from the Web of Science database (1992–2017) to map the research landscape of haze and economic growth. Using CiteSpace, the authors explore temporal distributions, key contributors, and evolving research trends. Findings reveal a rapid surge in literature volume, the formation of major author cooperation groups (e.g., Huang GH and Streets DG), and the dominance of institutions like the Chinese Academy of Sciences and the US EPA. Research hotspots have shifted from general air pollution and health concerns toward specific metrics like $\text{PM}_{2.5}$ and $\text{CO}_2$ emissions.

Introduction

The tension between rapid economic expansion and environmental degradation is a defining challenge of the 21st century. In developing nations, particularly China, "haze"—a complex mix of smog and particulate matter—has become a visible cost of industrial success. While numerous studies investigate specific local impacts, this paper provides a "meta-map" of the global intellectual history of this field over 25 years.

Methodology

The researchers utilized CiteSpace, a bibliometric visualization tool, to analyze 4,225 effective records from the Web of Science Core Collection. The methodology involved:

  • Co-occurrence Analysis: Mapping networks of authors, institutions, and keywords.
  • Centrality Metrics: Identifying "hubs" of influence within the research network.
  • Price Formula: Quantifying high-yield authors to identify the field's leading experts.

The volume of research on haze and economic growth remained relatively low for nearly two decades. However, 2011 marked a significant turning point, initiating a "rapid growth stage."

Annual growth in literature volume (1992–2017) showing the sharp increase after 2011.

This surge is attributed to heightened social awareness and public health concerns, notably influenced by the broadcasting of $\text{PM}_{2.5}$ data in major urban centers like Beijing.

Institutional and Geographic Landscape

The research landscape is characterized by strong international cooperation, primarily between the United States and China. These two nations, along with the UK, Canada, and Germany, produce nearly 70% of the global literature.

Top research institutions by publication frequency, highlighting the dominance of Chinese and American organizations.

As shown in the data, the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) leads in total output, followed by Tsinghua University and UC Berkeley. These institutions serve as central nodes in the global knowledge network.

Evolution of Research Hotspots

The focus of the field has evolved significantly:

  1. Early Phase (1990s): Broad focus on "air pollution," "health," and "mortality."
  2. Development Phase: Introduction of the Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) hypothesis, exploring whether pollution eventually declines as wealth increases.
  3. Modern Phase: A shift toward specific pollutants like $\text{PM}_{2.5}$ and $\text{CO}_2$, alongside "spatial spillover" effects—the recognition that economic activity in one region directly impacts the air quality of its neighbors.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the field has matured, the authors identify a need for deeper theoretical exploration of the transmission mechanisms between economic activity and haze. Future research should prioritize rigorous empirical spatial statistics and interdisciplinary approaches to better understand how specific geographic frameworks influence the correlation between growth and pollution.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper takes 4,225 articles on the relationship between haze and economic growth in the Web of Science database from 1992 to 2017 as the research object, and uses CiteSpace to explore the spatial and temporal distribution, research topics and hot trends of the literature. The results show that: (1) The relevant literature volume keeps growing at a high speed. (2) The cooperative group of high-yield authors represented by Huang GH and Streets DG is basically formed. (3) The research institutions are divided into the top international colleges and universities represented by Tsinghua University and the University of California, Berkeley, as well as the two major groups of international well-known scientific research institutes represented by the Chinese Academy of Sciences and the American Environmental Protection Agency. ( (5) The two major cooperation bodies of "the United States-China" and "Holland-France-Italy-Spain" have been formed. ( (7) The research hotspots show trends from "air pollution" and "health" to "PM2.5" and "CO2 emission".
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiong2020correlation,
  author = {Hongkai Xiong and Zihan Zhao},
  title = {{THE CORRELATION BETWEEN HAZE AND ECONOMIC GROWTH: BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS BASED ON WOS DATABASE}},
  booktitle = {Applied Ecology and Environmental Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.15666/aeer/1801\_059075},
}
Figure