The Correlation Between Brain Performance Capacity and COVID-19: A Cross-sectional Survey and Canonical Correlation Analysis

Yan Liu, Xian Chen, Js Xian, Rongquan Wang, Kuansheng Ma, Kai Xu, Xue Yang, F. Wang, Nan Mu, Shuo Wang, Yunfeng Lai, Tie Li, Cy Yang, Yl Quan, Hua Feng, Lh Wang, Tn ChenmedRxiv 2022 · DOI

Introduction

In safety-critical environments such as aviation, human error is a primary factor in 60% to 90% of accidents. These errors are frequently rooted in cognitive exhaustion and high mental workload. While factors like sleep deprivation and fatigue are known to impair performance, they are often analyzed in isolation. This research introduces the concept of Brain Performance Capacity (BPC)—a holistic metric that integrates sleep quality, fatigue, and mental workload—to evaluate cognitive readiness.

The study specifically examines BPC within the context of the "normalized" COVID-19 era. This period, following the initial crisis, was characterized by persistent stressors such as frequent nucleic acid testing (NAT), mandatory personal protective equipment (PPE), and a lingering fear of infection. By surveying 259 civil air crew members, the authors quantify how these pandemic-related factors correlate with overall cognitive capacity.

Defining Brain Performance Capacity (BPC)

The researchers propose BPC as a unified construct to measure an individual's mental state and readiness for complex tasks. In this model, BPC is defined by three primary indicators:

  1. Sleep Quality: Measured via the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI).
  2. Fatigue: Assessed using the Multidimensional Fatigue Inventory (MFI-20).
  3. Mental Workload (MWL): Evaluated through the NASA Task Load Index (NASA-TLX).

The study validates BPC as a cohesive metric, finding that sleep quality serves as the strongest anchor (loading at 0.790), followed by mental workload (0.667) and fatigue (0.606).

Methodology: Canonical Correlation Analysis

To understand the complex relationship between cognitive state and environmental stressors, the study utilized Canonical Correlation Analysis (CCA). Unlike standard regression models that relate multiple independent variables to a single dependent variable, CCA examines the relationship between two distinct sets of variables.

The two sets analyzed were:

  • The BPC Variable Set: Comprising PSQI, MFI-20, and NASA-TLX scores.
  • The COVID-19 Impact Set: Comprising seven dimensions (C1–C7) of pandemic-related stress, including fear of infection, discomfort from testing, and the increased workload of wearing PPE.

This approach allowed the researchers to treat BPC as a "latent" cluster of indicators, providing a more comprehensive view of mental readiness than any single metric could offer.

Key Findings: The Impact of the "Normalized" Pandemic

The analysis revealed a significant correlation between the BPC set and the COVID-19 impact set, with a canonical correlation coefficient of 0.517 ($P=0.000$). Several critical insights emerged from the data:

The Fatigue Paradox

A striking 100% of participants reported some level of fatigue, with 47.9% categorized as "severe." This incidence rate is significantly higher than historical benchmarks for aviation personnel, suggesting that the "normalized" pandemic era imposed a cognitive tax far heavier than previously estimated.

Sleep and Insomnia

Nearly half of the crew members (49.8%) reported incidents of insomnia. The average PSQI score was 7.826, indicating generally poor sleep quality across the cohort. Within the COVID-19 variable set, "impact on sleep quality" and "fear of infection" showed the highest absolute loadings (up to 0.951), marking them as the primary drivers of reduced BPC.

Logistics as a Stressor

The study found that cognitive decline was not solely driven by the fear of the virus itself (C1). The logistical burdens of the pandemic—specifically the physical unwellness caused by regular testing (C3) and the increased workload associated with PPE (C4)—were major contributors to the degradation of BPC.

Discussion and Demographic Vulnerabilities

The data also highlighted specific demographic trends. Older age and higher Body Mass Index (BMI) were positively correlated with poorer sleep, higher fatigue, and increased mental workload. This suggests that certain subgroups within high-stress industries may require more targeted support and interventions to maintain cognitive readiness during prolonged crises.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research demonstrates that BPC is a valuable construct for assessing the mental readiness of personnel in high-stakes environments. The significant correlation between pandemic stressors and BPC decline underscores the need for comprehensive anti-epidemic measures that account for cognitive health.

However, the authors note several limitations. As a cross-sectional study, it identifies correlations rather than direct causation. Furthermore, the reliance on self-reported data suggests a need for future research to incorporate objective measures such as EEG, fMRI, or reaction time tests. Expanding this model to other high-risk professions, such as healthcare, and conducting longitudinal studies will be essential for understanding how BPC fluctuates over time and across different global challenges.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Objective To generate a concept of brain performance capacity (BPC) with sleep, fatigue and mental workload as evaluation indicators and to analyze the correlation between BPC and the impact of COVID-19. Methods A cluster sampling method was adopted to randomly select 259 civil air crew members. The measurements of sleep quality, fatigue and mental workload (MWL) were assessed using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), Multidimensional Fatigue Inventory (MFI-20) and NASA Task Load Index. The impact of COVID-19 included 7 dimensions scored on a Likert scale. Canonical correlation analysis (CCA) was conducted to examine the relationship between BPC and COVID-19. Results A total of 259 air crew members participated in the survey. Participants’ average PSQI score was 7.826 (SD = 3.796), with 49.8% reporting incidents of insomnia, mostly of a minor degree. Participants’ MFI was an average 56.112 (SD = 10.040), with 100% reporting some incidence of fatigue, mainly severe. The weighted mental workload (MWL) score was an average of 43.084 (SD = 17.543), with reports of mostly a mid-level degree. There was a significant relationship between BPC and COVID-19, with a canonical correlation coefficient of 0.507 ( P =0.000), an eigenvalue of 0.364 and a contribution rate of 69.1%. All components of the BPC variable set: PSQI, MFI and MWL contributed greatly to BPC, with absolute canonical loadings of 0.790, 0.606 and 0.667, respectively; the same was true for the COVID-19 variable set, with absolute canonical loadings ranging from 0.608 to 0.951. Conclusion Multiple indicators to measure BPC and the interrelationship of BPC and COVID-19 should be used in future research to gain a comprehensive understanding of anti-epidemic measures to ensure victory in the battle against the spread of the disease.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2022correlation,
  author = {Yan Liu and Xian Chen and JS Xian and Rongquan Wang and Kuansheng Ma and Kai Xu and Xue Yang and F. Wang and Nan Mu and Shuo Wang and Yunfeng Lai and Tie Li and CY Yang and YL Quan and Hua Feng and LH Wang and TN Chen},
  title = {{The Correlation Between Brain Performance Capacity and COVID-19: A Cross-sectional Survey and Canonical Correlation Analysis}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.01.29.22270064},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure