The controversy of intrapartum management in parturients with Chiari-1 malformation: a protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis

Taylor Furst, Derek D. George, Aman Singh, Suyash Sau, Adam Li, Thomas Mattingly, Loralei L. Thornburg, G. Edward Vates2025 · DOI

Introduction

Chiari-1 malformation (C1M) is a structural neurological condition characterized by the downward displacement of the cerebellar tonsils through the foramen magnum into the spinal canal. For pregnant patients, the intrapartum period—encompassing labor and delivery—poses a significant clinical challenge. The primary concern involves the physiological stress of labor, particularly the Valsalva maneuvers during the "pushing" phase, which can cause spikes in intracranial pressure (ICP). Such fluctuations theoretically increase the risk of neurological deterioration or tonsillar herniation.

The Clinical Dilemma

Currently, there is no international consensus on the optimal management of parturients with C1M. Clinical practice is often divided between two main philosophies:

  1. Surgical/Conservative Approach: Some providers advocate for elective Cesarean sections under general anesthesia to maintain strict control over hemodynamics and avoid ICP spikes associated with labor and neuraxial techniques.
  2. Obstetric Approach: Others argue that vaginal delivery assisted by neuraxial anesthesia (such as epidurals) is safe and avoids the risks inherent to general anesthesia and major surgery.

This lack of standardized guidelines often leads to highly variable care, potentially resulting in unnecessary medical interventions or avoidable complications.

Study Objectives and Methodology

This protocol outlines a systematic review and meta-analysis designed to synthesize available literature and provide evidence-based recommendations regarding the safety of anesthetic techniques and delivery modalities.

PICO Framework

  • Population: Parturient females diagnosed with C1M, with or without associated syringomyelia.
  • Intervention/Comparison: General Anesthesia (GA) versus Neuraxial Anesthesia (NA); Cesarean Delivery (CD) versus Vaginal Delivery (VD).
  • Outcome: The primary metric is the presence or absence of new or worsening neurological deficits post-delivery.

Search and Selection Strategy

The research team will conduct a comprehensive search across PubMed, EMBASE, and Scopus using targeted MeSH terms. To ensure objectivity, a dual-reviewer process will be employed via the Rayyan platform. The review will include Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs), cohort studies, and case series, while excluding non-primary literature and non-English publications.

Statistical Analysis

Given the expected heterogeneity in clinical reporting, a random-effects model will be used for the meta-analysis. The analysis will be performed using Python (utilizing pandas, numpy, and scipy) and Comprehensive Meta-Analysis software. The team will calculate Odds Ratios (OR) and 95% Confidence Intervals to determine the relative safety of different modalities.

Key Considerations: The "Syrinx" Variable

A critical component of this review is the impact of syringomyelia—a fluid-filled cyst within the spinal cord often seen in C1M patients. The study aims to determine if the presence of a syrinx significantly alters the risk profile for neuraxial anesthesia, a topic of intense debate in obstetric anesthesia. While sample sizes for this subgroup are expected to be small, the synthesis of existing case data may provide the first clear signal for this specific population.

Limitations and Future Impact

The authors acknowledge that the reliance on retrospective data and case series may introduce publication bias, which will be monitored using Egger’s regression and funnel plots. Despite these challenges, the resulting meta-analysis aims to clarify whether routine neurosurgical consultation is mandatory for all C1M patients or if management can be safely streamlined by obstetric and anesthetic teams.

By establishing this rigorous protocol, the researchers seek to move C1M intrapartum management from institutional "expert opinion" toward a standardized, evidence-based clinical framework.

Summary updated

Abstract

eview question / Objective Systematic review and meta-analysis of available literature regarding the intrapartum management of parturients with C1M to (a) assess safety of anesthetic techniques and delivery modalities among parturients with C1M, and (b) provide clear recommendations regarding the management of this patient population and need for neurosurgical consultation.Rationale There is an on-going controversy regarding the best anesthetic technique and delivery modality in pregnant patient with Chiari 1 malformation.Some providers have advocated for general anesthesia and cesarian section over neuraxial anesthessia and vaginal delivery.Condition being studied Chiari 1 malformation in pregnant women. METHODS S e a r c h s t r a t e g y T he s e a r c h s t r a t e g y encompassed a combination of keywords and MeSH terms related to "Chiari 1 malformation," "pregnancy," "delivery," "anesthesia," "cesarean section," and "vaginal delivery."Participant or population PICO criteria: Population: Parturient females with C1M with or without
BibTeX
@misc{furst2025controversy,
  author = {Taylor Furst and Derek D. George and Aman Singh and Suyash Sau and Adam Li and Thomas Mattingly and Loralei L. Thornburg and G. Edward Vates},
  title = {{The controversy of intrapartum management in parturients with Chiari-1 malformation: a protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.37766/inplasy2025.10.0025},
}
Figure