Abstract
Recent developments in neural interfaces enable the real-time and non-invasive tracking of motor neuron spiking activity. Such novel interfaces provide a promising basis for human motor augmentation by extracting potential high-dimensional control signals directly from the human nervous system. However, it is unclear how flexibly humans can control the activity of individual motor neurones to effectively increase the number of degrees-of-freedom available to coordinate multiple effectors simultaneously. Here, we provided human subjects (N=7) with real-time feedback on the discharge patterns of pairs of motor units (MUs) innervating a single muscle (tibialis anterior) and encouraged them to independently control the MUs by tracking targets in a 2D space. Subjects learned control strategies to achieve the target-tracking task for various combinations of MUs. These strategies rarely corresponded to a volitional control of independent input signals to individual MUs. Conversely, MU activation was consistent with a common input to the MU pair, while individual activation of the MUs in the pair was predominantly achieved by alterations in de-recruitment order that could be explained with history-dependent changes in motor neuron excitability. These results suggest that flexible MU control based on independent synaptic inputs to single MUs is not a simple to learn control strategy.
Introduction
The "Holy Grail" of non-invasive neural interfaces is to increase the number of degrees-of-freedom (DoF) available for controlling external devices, such as prosthetic limbs or exoskeletons. Since a single muscle contains hundreds to thousands of motor units (MUs), being able to control them independently would theoretically provide a massive, high-dimensional control signal directly from the nervous system.
However, Henneman’s "Size Principle" suggests that motor units are usually recruited in a fixed, stereotypical order based on a common synaptic input signal sent to the entire muscle pool. This study investigates whether humans can learn to bypass this "common input" constraint to achieve truly independent, volitional control of individual motor units within the same muscle.
Methods
The researchers recruited seven healthy subjects for a 14-day training study. They used High-Density Surface Electromyography (HDsEMG)—a grid of 64 electrodes placed over the tibialis anterior (the muscle that lifts the foot)—to track the activity of individual motor units in real-time.
The core of the experiment was a 2D biofeedback task:
- Real-time Decomposition: An algorithm translated raw muscle signals into the firing patterns of two specific motor units (MU1 and MU2).
- 2D Cursor Control: The firing rate of MU1 moved a cursor on the X-axis, and MU2 moved it on the Y-axis.
- Target Tracking: Subjects navigated the cursor to specific targets. To hit "Target III," they had to activate the higher-threshold MU2 while keeping the lower-threshold MU1 silent—essentially trying to "break" the natural recruitment order.
Results
Target hit rates improved significantly over 14 days, rising from ~41% to ~67%. However, truly independent activation was extremely rare. For the most difficult target (activating only the high-threshold unit), "direct" movements occurred in less than 7% of successful trials. Despite days of training, the fundamental recruitment order of the motor units remained largely unchanged.
Subjects achieved success through a "hacking" strategy rather than independent volitional signals. 95% of subjects used a three-stage approach: ramping up force to activate both units, then slowly releasing the force. This exploited Persistent Inward Currents (PICs)—intrinsic properties of motor neurons that allow them to continue firing even after the initial synaptic input has decreased (hysteresis). They weren't sending a "Y-axis only" signal; they were sending a "Both-on then one-off" signal.
Discussion
The results strongly suggest that the Central Nervous System (CNS) is hard-wired to provide common, rather than individual, input to motor unit pools during isometric tasks. Control was not absolute; it was state-dependent. Subjects could not simply "turn on" the high-threshold unit from a resting state; they had to go through a specific sequence of muscle contractions to "set the stage" for that unit to fire in isolation.
While the study was limited to isometric tasks in the tibialis anterior, it highlights a major biological bottleneck. Other muscles, particularly those involved in fine motor control like the hands, might exhibit more flexibility, but the common input constraint appears robust in large postural muscles.
Conclusion
For engineers building the next generation of Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCIs), the message is clear: don't assume the nervous system can easily provide independent "channels" per motor unit. We may need to design interfaces that work with the common input constraint and exploit physiological properties like PICs rather than attempting to fight them.
Summary updated