The Contribution of Chicken Products’ Export to Economic Growth: Evidence from China, the United States, and Brazil

Xiaowei Wen, Lin Li, Sangluo Sun, Qinying He, Fu-Sheng TsaiSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the impact of chicken product exports on economic growth in China, the US, and Brazil. While no long-term equilibrium was found, export growth significantly boosts the US economy, with Brazil showing more volatile but substantial contributions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the ongoing debate about the export-led growth (ELG) hypothesis, specifically focusing on a single agricultural commodity: chicken products. While the general impact of agricultural exports on economic growth is recognized, there's a need for more granular analysis on specific products and across countries with varying economic structures. The authors aim to fill this gap by comparing China (an emerging economy with a large domestic market), the United States (a developed economy and major exporter), and Brazil (another emerging economy and significant exporter) to understand how chicken product exports contribute to their respective economic growth rates.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted econometric approach:

  • Co-integration Analysis (Engel-Granger two-step method): This was used to determine if there's a long-term, stable relationship between chicken product exports and economic growth (GDP). This involves testing for unit roots in the time series data and then examining the residuals of a regression between the variables.
  • Augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) Test: This standard unit root test was used to assess the stationarity of the time series data for both export values and GDP.
  • OLS Regression on First-Differenced Data: Since co-integration analysis revealed no long-term equilibrium, the study shifted to analyzing the short-term dynamics by regressing the first-differenced (growth rates) of exports and GDP. This helps understand how changes in exports affect changes in GDP.
  • Direct Pull Degree and Economic Growth Contribution Rate: Novel estimators were developed to quantify the direct impact of chicken product exports on national income (GDP). The "direct pull degree" measures the immediate impact of export increases on GDP, while the "economic growth contribution rate" quantifies the share of this direct impact in the overall economic growth rate.

Datasets

The study utilized annual time series data from 1980 to 2016 for China, the United States, and Brazil.

  • Chicken Product Export Value: Data sourced from the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) website (faostat.org).
  • Gross Domestic Product (GDP): Data obtained from the World Bank's World Development Indicators database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No Long-Term Equilibrium: A surprising finding is the absence of a stable, long-term equilibrium relationship between chicken product exports and economic growth in any of the three countries. This suggests that while exports might influence growth, they don't anchor it in a predictable, sustained way over decades.
  • Short-Term Dynamics Matter: Despite the lack of long-term co-integration, the study found significant short-term impacts, particularly for the United States. This highlights the importance of analyzing the immediate effects of export fluctuations.
  • Country-Specific Impacts: The contribution of chicken exports to economic growth is not uniform. The US shows a clear positive and significant short-term relationship, while Brazil's impact is more volatile but substantial, and China's appears to be the least pronounced among the three.
  • Direct vs. Indirect Effects: The paper distinguishes between the direct impact of exports on GDP (direct pull degree) and their overall contribution to growth rates. This allows for a more nuanced understanding of how exports translate into economic gains.

Key Results

  • United States: The growth rate of chicken product exports significantly promotes the US economic growth rate. A 1% increase in export growth leads to a 0.0861% increase in economic growth. The direct pull degree and contribution rate are small and stable.
  • Brazil: Shows the most volatile direct pull degree and contribution rate. Its direct pull degree is 0.25 times that of China, but its economic contribution to the growth rate is 1.65 times that of China. The impact on economic growth rate is 0.2064, though its significance level (0.1117) is slightly above the conventional thresholds.
  • China: The direct pull degree of China's chicken product exports is 14 times that of the United States, but its contribution to the economic growth rate is only 8 times that of China. The direct pull degree and contribution rate are generally small and less volatile compared to Brazil.
  • Overall: The direct pull degree of chicken product exports for both China and the United States is relatively small and less volatile. Brazil's direct pull degree fluctuates more often.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Period: The authors acknowledge that the 1980-2016 data period might not be long enough to capture all long-term dynamics.
  • Omitted Variables: The study did not consider other variables that could affect both chicken exports and economic growth, which could influence the results.
  • Model and Methodological Limitations: The authors note that the real economic system is complex and nonlinear, and the choice of model and estimation method can significantly impact results. They suggest that more econometric methods should be employed for a more robust determination of export impacts.
  • Generalizability: The findings should not be generalized to all chicken-producing and exporting countries due to the mixed nature of current empirical results.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest expanding the methodological approach to a larger cross-section of countries (e.g., Thailand, Japan) and incorporating additional relevant variables. They also highlight the need for future research to address the limitations of the current study.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a core industry of the national economy, there is no doubt that the agricultural sector has to adapt to the new economic development. In the literature, many researchers have agreed that agricultural export is an important factor affecting economic growth. This paper explores the contribution of chicken products’ export to economic growth and the causal relationship between them. Based on the data from the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) and World Bank between 1980 and 2016, this paper describes and compares the characteristics of chicken products’ export trade of China, the United States, and Brazil. By applying the co-integration analysis, we find that there is no significant long-term equilibrium relationship between chicken products’ export and economic growth rate in China, the United States, or Brazil. However, the growth rate of chicken products’ export significantly promotes the economic growth rate for the United States. Besides, for both China and the United States, the direct pull degree (an estimator quantifying the degree of agricultural products’ exports in stimulating economic growth) of chicken products’ export is relatively small and less volatile. Yet, the direct pull degree of China is 14 times that of the United States, and the contribution to the economic growth rate of the United States is 8 times that of China. Both the direct pull degree and economic growth contribution of chicken products’ export of Brazil fluctuates more often, and its direct pull degree is 0.25 times that of China, and the economic contributions to the growth rate is 1.65 times that of China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wen2019contribution,
  author = {Xiaowei Wen and Lin Li and Sangluo Sun and Qinying He and Fu-Sheng Tsai},
  title = {{The Contribution of Chicken Products’ Export to Economic Growth: Evidence from China, the United States, and Brazil}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11195253},
}
Figure