The Contralateral Ankle Joint Is a Reliable Reference for Testing Syndesmotic Stability Using Bilateral External Torque CT

Anna‐Katharina Calek, E. Ongini, Bettina Hochreiter, Reto Sutter, Stephan Wirth, Silvan BeelerFoot 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that the healthy contralateral ankle can serve as a reliable reference for assessing syndesmotic stability using a novel bilateral external torque CT (BET-CT) method. By comparing the injured ankle to its healthy counterpart under controlled rotational forces, clinicians can identify subtle instabilities that are difficult to detect with current imaging techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diagnosing subtle or chronic syndesmotic instabilities in the ankle is a significant clinical challenge. Traditional imaging methods like standard X-rays and even MRI often fall short in accurately assessing ligamentous function, especially under load. This can lead to delayed or missed diagnoses, resulting in long-term disability such as chronic pain and early osteoarthritis. While external torque CT has shown promise in cadaver studies, its applicability in living subjects hinges on understanding the natural variations between an individual's own ankles. This paper aims to bridge that gap by investigating the comparability of syndesmotic stability measurements between the left and right ankles of healthy individuals using a bilateral external torque CT device.

Methods

The researchers employed a novel "bilateral external torque CT" (BET-CT) device. This apparatus allows for the simultaneous application of controlled external rotation torques to both ankles of a subject while undergoing CT scanning. Ten healthy participants without any history of ankle injury or surgery were recruited. Four CT scans were performed on each participant: one in a neutral position (0 Nm torque) and three with increasing external rotation torques (2.5 Nm, 5 Nm, and 7.5 Nm).

Five radiographic parameters were measured from the CT scans to assess syndesmotic stability:

  • Anterior Distance (AD): Measures the anterior gap between the tibia and fibula.
  • Tibiofibular Clear Space (TCS): Assesses the space between the tibia and fibula at the tibial notch.
  • Posterior Distance (PD): Evaluates the posterior gap between the tibia and fibula.
  • External Rotation (ER): Quantifies the rotational alignment of the fibula relative to the tibia.
  • Beta Angle (β): A measure similar to ER but taken at the talar dome level.

The core of the methodology involved comparing these measurements between the left and right ankles of each participant under identical torque conditions. Statistical analysis, including Wilcoxon signed-rank tests and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs), was used to determine the significance of side differences and the reliability of the measurements.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from 10 healthy human subjects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Healthy Contralateral Ankle as a Gold Standard: The most significant insight is the validation of using the contralateral, uninjured ankle as a reliable internal control for assessing syndesmotic stability. This bypasses the need for population-based normative data, which can be highly variable.
  • Minimal Intraindividual Differences: Despite considerable interindividual variability in ankle anatomy, the study found that the differences in syndesmotic measurements between a healthy individual's left and right ankles were remarkably small, especially for key parameters like AD.
  • AD as a Promising Metric: The Anterior Distance (AD) emerged as the most reliable parameter for side-to-side comparison, exhibiting the smallest maximum difference (0.5 mm) between contralateral ankles. This suggests it's a robust indicator of subtle changes.
  • Torque Level Impact: While increasing torque generally led to slight increases in AD, ER, and β angle, and decreases in TCS and PD, these changes did not significantly impact the differences between the left and right ankles. This implies that even lower torque levels might be sufficient for comparative analysis.

Key Results

  • Negligible Side Differences: For the Anterior Distance (AD), the maximum difference between the left and right ankles across all tested torques was only 0.5 mm. Other parameters also showed minimal differences (TCS: 2.2 mm, PD: 1 mm, ER: 3.1 degrees, β angle: 8.7 degrees).
  • Excellent Agreement: Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) indicated excellent agreement between the left and right ankles for AD (0.962), PD (0.983), and ER (0.983). TCS and β angle showed moderate agreement.
  • Proposed Cutoff Values: Based on the 95% limits of the data, the authors suggest that a side difference greater than 0.5 mm for AD and greater than 0.9 mm for PD could be considered abnormal and indicative of syndesmotic instability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Healthy Subjects Only: This study was conducted on healthy individuals. The behavior of these parameters in patients with actual syndesmotic instability, especially under higher torques that might induce pain, needs further investigation.
  • Arbitrary Torque Levels: The chosen torque levels (0-7.5 Nm) were based on feasibility in healthy subjects but may not be directly translatable to patients who might experience pain or muscle guarding.
  • Potential for Intra-articular Infiltration: The possibility of using local anesthetics to manage pain in future studies with patients was mentioned, which could influence results.
  • Future Directions: The authors emphasize the critical need for future studies to define definitive cutoff values for side differences in both acute and chronic syndesmotic instability. This will be crucial for guiding clinical treatment decisions. Further research is also needed to confirm the utility of this method in patient populations and to explore the impact of torque levels in those with syndesmotic insufficiency.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using the healthy contralateral ankle joint is appropriate for assessing syndesmotic stability based on minimal intraindividual side differences using the external torque device. Side differences >0.5 mm in AD and >0.9 mm in PD may be considered abnormal and may indicate significant instability of the syndesmosis. However, future studies are needed to define definitive cutoff values for relevant side differences in acute and chronic syndesmotic instability to guide clinicians in their treatment decisions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{calek2024contralateral,
  author = {Anna‐Katharina Calek and E. Ongini and Bettina Hochreiter and Reto Sutter and Stephan Wirth and Silvan Beeler},
  title = {{The Contralateral Ankle Joint Is a Reliable Reference for Testing Syndesmotic Stability Using Bilateral External Torque CT}},
  booktitle = {Foot},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1177/10711007241262771},
}
Figure