The Contents of Environmental Education in Current Elementary Social Studies Textbooks in China

Zhao Wei-ju, Ling Liu, Di WangInternational Journal of Humanities Social Sciences and Education 2017 · DOI

Abstract

The textbooks, step by step, unfold from the "small" environment to "big" environment, from concrete to abstract and from the things around us to the earth we live in. The contents are gradually expanded in an orderly way. Evidently, there are a few defects which claim our attention. The environmental education is incoherent as the contents of environmental education almost appear in the second semester.

Introduction

As environmental protection became a core state policy in China following the 18th CPC National Congress, the burden of fostering "environmental awareness" fell heavily on the education system. This study analyzes how environmental education (EE) is integrated into China's primary school "Moral Education" textbooks, specifically the "Morality and Life" (Grades 1-2) and "Morality and Society" (Grades 3-6) series published by the People’s Education Press. The researchers seek to determine if the content aligns with children's cognitive development and if the thematic progression is coherent enough to build lasting habits.

The "Small-to-Big" Pedagogical Spiral

The curriculum is designed to expand with the child’s world, following a "small-to-big" pedagogical spiral. It begins with "concrete" experiences in the lower grades, focusing on the immediate surroundings. For instance, Grade 1 students are introduced to the arrival of spring, encouraging them to use their senses—seeing, hearing, and smelling—to connect with nature.

Figure 5: Grade 1 students exploring nature through sensory experiences like observing tadpoles in spring, illustrating the "concrete" start of the pedagogical spiral.

This thematic unit, "Walking into nature," aims to build emotional resonance by helping children feel the beauty and vitality of the natural world. By personifying nature in these early stages, the textbooks narrow the psychological distance between children and the environment.

Pedagogical Evolution: From Emotion to Agency

As students age, there is a clear shift in instructional strategy. While lower grades emphasize emotional connection, higher grades scale up to abstract global issues and emphasize agency and investigation. By Grade 5 and 6, the focus shifts to "The earth we live in" and "The home of human beings," introducing macro-level concepts such as natural disasters and global stewardship.

Figure 6: Higher-grade textbooks introduce abstract macro-level issues like natural disasters (typhoons, landslides, volcanoes, and droughts) to broaden the scope of environmental awareness.

This transition from micro-level practical habits to macro-level global challenges represents the peak of the curriculum's application. However, the authors suggest that these macro-level topics might benefit from more consistent "micro-level" practical links to maintain student engagement and ensure that global issues feel personally relevant.

Identifying Curriculum Defects

Despite the logical progression, the study identifies significant gaps in continuity. A primary concern is the "Second Semester Syndrome," where EE content is almost exclusively relegated to the second semester of the school year. This suggests that environmental awareness is treated as a seasonal topic rather than a year-round foundational principle.

Furthermore, there is a total absence of environmental education content in the third grade. This "black hole" in the curriculum creates a fragmented learning experience, undermining the development of environmental stewardship as a continuous moral thread. Environmental protection is a habit-based discipline that requires constant reinforcement, which the current "stop-and-start" schedule may undermine.

Conclusion

While the Chinese "Moral Education" textbooks successfully employ a developmental approach to environmental education, structural incoherence remains a challenge. To ensure that environmental awareness becomes a lasting habit, curriculum reformers should consider redistributing EE content more evenly across all grades and semesters to provide a continuous thread in a student's moral development.

Summary updated

Abstract

The textbooks, step by step, unfold from the "small" environment to "big" environment, from concrete to abstract and from the things around us to the earth we live in. The contents are gradually expanded in an orderly way. Evidently, there are a few defects which claim our attention. The environmental education is incoherent as the contents of environmental education almost appear in the second semester.
BibTeX
@article{weiju2017contents,
  author = {Zhao Wei-ju and Ling Liu and Di Wang},
  title = {{The Contents of Environmental Education in Current Elementary Social Studies Textbooks in China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Humanities Social Sciences and Education},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.20431/2349-0381.0406001},
}
Figure