This study compares two leading minimally invasive techniques for treating lumbar disc herniation: Unilateral Biportal Endoscopy (UBE) and Percutaneous Endoscopic Lumbar Discectomy (PELD). While both methods yield nearly identical long-term clinical improvements in pain and function, PELD offers a faster recovery and smaller incisions, whereas UBE provides surgeons with a superior field of view and significantly reduces their exposure to intraoperative radiation.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Lumbar disc herniation (LDH)—where the "jelly" inside a spinal disc protrudes and presses on nerves—is a leading cause of back and leg pain. While traditional open surgery is effective, it often involves significant muscle trauma and long recovery times.
Minimally invasive surgery (MIS) has become the gold standard, but the field is currently split between two main endoscopic approaches:
- PELD: A single-channel technique where the camera and tools share one narrow tube.
- UBE: A dual-channel technique (similar to knee or shoulder arthroscopy) where the camera and tools enter through separate ports.
Surgeons often debate which is better. PELD is technically demanding and often requires high doses of X-ray guidance (fluoroscopy), while UBE is newer and requires more soft tissue stripping. This paper seeks to quantify the trade-offs between these two approaches in a real-world clinical setting.
Methods
The researchers conducted a comparative study of 51 patients treated at Zhaoqing First People's Hospital between 2021 and 2023.
- UBE Group (n=23): Performed under general anesthesia. Two incisions are made to create independent viewing and working channels.
- PELD Group (n=28): Performed under either local or general anesthesia. A single working sleeve is used, often utilizing a transforaminal or interlaminar approach depending on the spinal level.
The team tracked several metrics:
- Clinical Outcomes: Pain (VAS score), disability (Oswestry Disability Index), and neurological function (JOA score).
- Surgical Efficiency: Operation time, blood loss, and incision length.
- Safety: Intraoperative radiation (fluoroscopy) frequency and complication rates.
Datasets
The study utilized a clinical cohort dataset of 51 patients.
- Inclusion Criteria: Single-level LDH confirmed by MRI/CT, aged 30–70, and failure of conservative treatment.
- Evaluation Tools: Standardized medical benchmarks including the Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) score, the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI), and the modified Macnab criteria for patient satisfaction.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Radiation Trade-off: One of the most significant findings was that UBE required significantly fewer fluoroscopy (X-ray) shots than PELD. Because UBE uses an interlaminar approach with easier anatomical landmarks, the surgeon doesn't need to "check the map" with X-rays as often, protecting both the patient and the surgical team from cumulative radiation.
- The Learning Curve vs. Efficiency: PELD resulted in shorter operation times and less blood loss. However, the authors attribute this partly to the "learning curve." PELD had been established at their hospital longer than UBE. They suggest that as surgeons gain proficiency with the dual-channel UBE, the time gap may close.
- Anesthesia Flexibility: PELD can be performed under local anesthesia, allowing the surgeon to communicate with the patient. This acts as a "live monitor" to prevent nerve damage. UBE, due to the need for more extensive nerve retraction, generally requires general anesthesia.
- Visibility vs. Invasiveness: UBE offers a "wide-angle" view and more freedom of movement for instruments, making it feel more like traditional surgery but through a "keyhole." PELD is more "minimally invasive" (smaller total incision length) but offers a more restricted, "straw-like" field of view.
Key Results
- Clinical Parity: At the one-year follow-up, there was no statistically significant difference in pain relief or functional recovery between the two groups. Both had "excellent and good" rates around 90%.
- PELD Advantages:
- Shorter operation time (~121 min vs ~165 min).
- Lower blood loss (~8.9 ml vs ~16.9 ml).
- Smaller total incision (~10 mm vs ~22 mm).
- Faster return to walking (~1.2 days vs ~2.8 days).
- UBE Advantages:
- Significantly fewer fluoroscopy shots (~6.5 vs ~10.4), reducing radiation risk.
- Subjectively better visualization for the surgeon.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge two primary limitations:
- Small Sample Size: With only 51 patients, the study may lack the statistical power to detect rare complications.
- Short Follow-up: While one year is standard, it doesn't capture long-term recurrence rates (which can happen years later).
Future Work: The team plans to increase the sample size and extend the follow-up period to determine if the superior visualization of UBE leads to lower long-term recurrence rates compared to the more restricted view of PELD.
Summary updated