The Combined Effects of Hourly Multi-Pollutant on the Risk of Ambulance Emergency Calls: A Seven-Year Time Series Study

Hanxu Shi, Qiang Zhou, Hongjuan Zhang, Shengzhi Sun, Junfeng Zhao, Yasha Wang, Jie Huang, Yinzi Jin, Zhi‐Jie Zheng, Rengyu Wu, Zhenyu ZhangToxics 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that hourly exposure to a mixture of common air pollutants (PM2.5, PM10, Ozone, NO2, and SO2) significantly increases the risk of ambulance emergency calls (AECs) across various health conditions, with no clear thresholds for these effects. The findings underscore the need for comprehensive air quality policies to mitigate these public health burdens.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Air pollution is a major contributor to public health issues, but understanding its immediate impact on health events, especially from the combined effects of multiple pollutants, remains a challenge. While previous studies have looked at individual pollutants or limited combinations, real-world exposure involves a complex mix. Ambulance emergency calls (AECs) are a sensitive indicator for syndromic surveillance, reflecting acute health impacts. However, there's a need for more granular analysis that considers the combined hourly effects of various pollutants on different types of AECs, accounting for specific lag times. This paper aims to fill this gap by investigating the synergistic impact of multiple air pollutants on hourly AECs in Shenzhen, China.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-stage statistical approach.

  1. Distributed Lag Non-linear Model (DLNM): This was used to identify the predominant lag period for each individual air pollutant (PM2.5, PM10, Ozone, NO2, and SO2) and its association with AECs. This step is crucial because the impact of pollution isn't always immediate and can manifest over hours or even days.
  2. Quantile G-computation Model: This novel method was then applied to assess the combined effects of the pollutant mixture. Unlike traditional methods that might look at one pollutant at a time or assume independence, quantile g-computation allows for the simultaneous evaluation of multiple pollutants, assigning weights to each to understand their relative contributions to the overall risk. This approach is particularly useful for understanding synergistic or antagonistic effects in complex mixtures.

The models were adjusted for meteorological factors (temperature, humidity), day of the week, and holidays to isolate the effect of air pollution.

Datasets

  • Ambulance Emergency Dispatch Data: Hourly data from the Shenzhen Ambulance Emergency Center for the period January 1, 2013, to December 31, 2019. This dataset included over 3 million calls, categorized by cause (all-cause, vascular, respiratory, reproductive, and injury).
  • Air Pollutant Data: Hourly average concentrations of PM2.5, PM10, Ozone, NO2, and SO2 from city-level environmental monitoring stations in Shenzhen for the same period.
  • Meteorological Data: Hourly temperature and relative humidity data for Shenzhen from 2013 to 2019.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Effects Matter: The most significant takeaway is that the combination of air pollutants, not just individual ones, poses a substantial risk. This highlights the inadequacy of focusing solely on single pollutants in public health policy.
  • No Safe Threshold: The study found a nearly linear relationship between pollutant concentrations and AECs, with no apparent "safe" threshold below which effects disappear. This implies that any increase in pollution, even to levels previously considered acceptable, can elevate risk.
  • Lagged Effects are Crucial: Identifying specific lag times for each pollutant (e.g., 0-8 hours for PM2.5/PM10, up to 48 hours for Ozone) is vital for accurate modeling and understanding the temporal dynamics of pollution's impact.
  • Vulnerable Populations and Times: The risks were more pronounced in older populations and varied by time of day, suggesting that targeted interventions during specific periods or for specific demographics could be more effective.

Key Results

  • An interquartile range (IQR) increase in the mixture of PM2.5, PM10, Ozone, NO2, and SO2 was associated with a 1.67% increase in the risk of all-cause ambulance emergency calls.
  • Specific increases were observed for:
  • Vascular AECs: 1.81%
    • Reproductive AECs: 1.77%
    • Injury-related AECs: 2.12%
  • The study identified predominant lag periods for each pollutant, with PM2.5 and PM10 showing effects within 0-8 hours, while Ozone, NO2, and SO2 had longer lag periods (up to 48 hours for Ozone).
  • The combined effect was more pronounced in older individuals and during daytime hours.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Proxy for Exposure: The study used city-level average pollutant concentrations as a proxy for individual exposure, which may lead to some exposure misclassification. Future work could explore personal monitoring data.
  • Prehospital Diagnoses: Reliance on prehospital diagnoses, rather than final clinical diagnoses, might introduce some bias, although the use of the Medical Priority Dispatch System (MPDS) helped mitigate this.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest future research could investigate individual behaviors and promote personal air pollution monitoring. They also emphasize the need for local governments to disseminate air pollution information, develop mitigation strategies, and ensure equitable resource allocation for emergency services. The findings also point to the importance of continued research into the specific mechanisms by which pollutant mixtures impact cardiovascular and respiratory health.

Summary updated

Abstract

We found combined effects of pollutant mixtures associated with an increased risk of AECs across various causes. These findings highlight the importance of targeted policies and interventions to reduce air pollution, particularly for PM, Ozone, and NO<sub>2</sub> emissions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shi2023combined,
  author = {Hanxu Shi and Qiang Zhou and Hongjuan Zhang and Shengzhi Sun and Junfeng Zhao and Yasha Wang and Jie Huang and Yinzi Jin and Zhi‐Jie Zheng and Rengyu Wu and Zhenyu Zhang},
  title = {{The Combined Effects of Hourly Multi-Pollutant on the Risk of Ambulance Emergency Calls: A Seven-Year Time Series Study}},
  booktitle = {Toxics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/toxics11110895},
}
Figure