Abstract
Both the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and the 11-years solar cycle had been identified as important factors that may influence the wintertime southern China precipitation (SCP). However, the interactions between these two factors remain less noticed. In this study, the combined effects of the ENSO and the solar activity on mid-winter (January) SCP are investigated using observational and reanalysis data. Results suggest that both the ENSO and the solar activity are positively correlated with the SCP, although exhibiting distinct spatial patterns. Under different combinations of the ENSO and solar phases, the SCP anomalies show superposition of these two factors to some extent. Generally, the ENSO-related SCP anomalies tend to be enhanced (disturbed) when the ENSO and the solar activity are in-phase (out-of-phase). But this solar modulation effect appears more clear and significant under cold ENSO (cENSO) phase rather than under warm ENSO (wENSO) phase. Further analysis suggests, during the wENSO phase, solar influences on the Northern Hemisphere circulation are generally weak with little significance. In contrast, during the cENSO phase, the solar effect resembles the positive phase of the Arctic Oscillation but with an evident zonal asymmetric component. Its manifestation over the Asia-Pacific domain features by negative geopotential height anomaly over the West Asia and positive geopotential height anomaly over the East Asian coast, a pattern that is favorable for the SCP, thus causing a significant solar modulation on the cENSO-related precipitation anomalies. Further, the potential physical causes of solar effects on circulation are also discussed. Our results highlight the importance of considering solar cycle phase when ENSO is used to predict the East Asian winter climate.
Introduction
Wintertime Southern China Precipitation (SCP) is characterized by high variability, often leading to extreme weather events such as the severe freezing rain and snowstorms of 2008. While the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) has long served as a primary predictor for these anomalies, its relationship with regional climate is not always consistent. Recent research suggests that the 11-year solar cycle—fluctuations in the Sun's radiation output—also plays a significant role. This study addresses the "interaction gap" between these two systems, exploring how solar activity modulates ENSO's impact on mid-winter rainfall in Southern China.
Data and Methodology
The study analyzed climate data spanning 68 years (1948–2016). Key datasets included monthly sunspot numbers (SSN) as a proxy for solar activity, the Nino 3.4 index for ENSO phases, and land surface precipitation data from the University of Delaware. Atmospheric circulation was assessed using NCEP/NCAR reanalysis data.
To isolate the signals of the Sun and the ocean, several statistical techniques were employed:
- Multiple Linear Regression (MLR): Separated contributions from solar activity, ENSO, volcanic eruptions, and anthropogenic trends.
- Lanczos Low-Pass Filtering: Removed long-term trends (>15 years) to focus on interannual-decadal variations.
- Composite and Partial Correlation Analysis: Evaluated the relationship between variables while controlling for confounding factors.
Results: The Asymmetry of Solar Influence
A key finding of this research is the asymmetric nature of solar modulation. The solar cycle's influence is significantly more robust during "cold" ENSO (La Niña) phases compared to "warm" (El Niño) phases. Specifically, under La Niña conditions, the correlation between solar activity and SCP is a significant 0.59, whereas it drops to a negligible 0.11 during El Niño.
When ENSO and the solar cycle are "in-phase" (e.g., El Niño and High Solar activity), their effects can superimpose, leading to positive rainfall anomalies exceeding 30 mm/month in coastal regions. Conversely, when "out-of-phase," the solar cycle can disturb or even cancel out the expected ENSO signal.
Circulation Mechanisms
The study identified a specific circulation pattern termed "West Low East High" (WLEH) that emerges during High Solar/La Niña years. This pattern creates a pressure gradient favorable for transporting warm, moist air from the south into Southern China. This effect is thought to be mediated by a "stratospheric bridge," where solar-induced changes in the stratosphere couple with the troposphere to alter the Arctic Oscillation (AO), effectively "nudging" large-scale polar circulation to influence regional weather.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
The results highlight that the 11-year solar cycle is a critical factor in modulating the East Asian winter climate. Incorporating solar cycle phases into climate models could significantly improve the predictability of SCP. However, limitations remain, including the relatively short historical record covering only six solar cycles. Future work using high-resolution, fully coupled climate models is necessary to further confirm the proposed stratospheric-tropospheric coupling mechanisms and refine predictive applications for meteorologists.
Summary updated