The combination of DNA methylation and positive regulation of anthocyanin biosynthesis by MYB and bHLH transcription factors contributes to the petal blotch formation in Xibei tree peony

Jin Zhu, Yizhou Wang, Qianyu Wang, Bing Li, Xiaohan Wang, Xian Zhou, Hechen Zhang, Wenzhong Xu, Shanshan Li, Liangsheng WangHorticulture 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have decoded the molecular "lock and key" mechanism behind the striking purple blotches on Xibei tree peony petals. The study reveals that petal coloration is governed by a two-layer system: a specific cocktail of transcription factors that activate pigment genes, and an epigenetic "lock" (DNA methylation) that silences these same genes in the non-blotched areas of the petal.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Xibei tree peony (Paeonia rockii) is celebrated as the "king of flowers" in China, largely due to the dramatic red-purple blotches at the base of its petals. For horticultural breeders, these patterns are highly desirable, yet the mechanism behind their formation has remained a mystery.

While we know that anthocyanins are the pigments responsible for the color, the question was: why are they produced only in the blotch area? In many plants, color patterns are a simple matter of where certain "activator" proteins are present. However, in the tree peony, the researchers found a more complex scenario where the genetic machinery for color is present throughout the petal, but is actively suppressed in the white areas through epigenetic silencing.

Methods

The authors employed a comprehensive molecular biology toolkit to dissect this system:

  • Transcriptomics & Metabolomics: They used RNA-seq and HPLC-DAD to identify which genes were active and which pigments were present in blotch vs. non-blotch areas across five developmental stages.
  • Protein Interaction Assays: To see how transcription factors (TFs) work together, they used Yeast Two-Hybrid (Y2H), Bimolecular Fluorescence Complementation (BiFC), and Co-Immunoprecipitation (Co-IP).
  • Functional Validation: They used Dual-Luciferase (Dual-LUC) assays and Electrophoretic Mobility Shift Assays (EMSA) to prove that specific TFs actually bind to and activate the promoters of pigment-producing genes.
  • In Vivo Testing: They validated their findings by overexpressing the identified peony genes in model plants (Nicotiana tabacum and Petunia hybrid).
  • Epigenetic Analysis: To investigate the "lock" mechanism, they used McrBC-PCR and Bisulfite Sequencing PCR (BSP) to map DNA methylation levels on gene promoters.

Datasets

The study relied on:

  • De novo transcriptome assembly: 53 full-length R2R3-MYB and 53 PrbHLH genes were identified from P. rockii 'Shu Sheng Peng Mo'.
  • Comparative RNA-seq data: Samples from blotch and non-blotch areas at stages S1, S3, and S5.
  • Phylogenetic benchmarks: Comparison of peony MYB and bHLH proteins against the well-characterized Arabidopsis thaliana subgroups.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Three Major Culprits: The silencing of three specific structural genes—PrF3H, PrDFR, and PrANS—is what prevents color in the non-blotch areas.
  • The "MM" Complex: Unlike many plants where a single MYB factor handles early steps, the researchers found that PrMYBa1 (an SG7 MYB) must interact with PrMYBa2 (an SG5 MYB) to form an "MM" complex to activate the early biosynthetic gene PrF3H.
  • The Late-Stage Boosters: For the final steps of pigment production, PrMYBa3 (an SG6 MYB) works synergistically with two bHLH partners (PrbHLH1/2) to activate PrDFR and PrANS.
  • The Epigenetic "Lock": This is the "aha" moment. Even when the right transcription factors are present, the promoters of PrF3H and PrANS are hypermethylated in the non-blotch areas. This chemical modification acts like a "Do Not Enter" sign for the cellular machinery, preventing gene expression.
  • Developmental Demethylation: In the blotch area, the PrANS promoter undergoes a demethylation process during early flower development, effectively "unlocking" the gene just in time for the purple pigment to accumulate.

Key Results

  • Pigment Profile: Cyanidin glycosides make up over 91% of the anthocyanins in the blotches.
  • Methylation Gap: The total methylation level in the white (non-blotch) area was roughly 41% higher than in the purple area for the PrF3H promoter.
  • Synergy Matters: In tobacco trials, co-expressing PrMYBa3 with its bHLH partners led to significantly higher anthocyanin accumulation compared to expressing the MYB alone, proving the necessity of the protein complex.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that tree peonies lack a robust, stable transgenic system, forcing them to rely on heterologous expression in tobacco and petunia. While these models are useful, they don't perfectly replicate the peony's internal environment.

A major remaining question is: What triggers the initial spatial pattern of methylation? We now know how the lock works, but we don't know who decides where the locks are placed during the very early stages of petal primordia development. Future research into the "upstream" signals that establish these epigenetic boundaries will be the next frontier in floral patterning.

Summary updated

Abstract

Xibei tree peony is a distinctive cultivar group that features red-purple blotches in petals. Interestingly, the pigmentations of blotches and non-blotches are largely independent of one another. The underlying molecular mechanism had attracted lots of attention from investigators, but was still uncertain. Our present work demonstrates the factors that are closely related to blotch formation in <i>Paeonia rockii</i> 'Shu Sheng Peng Mo'. Non-blotch pigmentation is prevented by the silencing of anthocyanin structural genes, among which <i>PrF3H</i>, <i>PrDFR</i>, and <i>PrANS</i> are the three major genes. We characterized two R2R3-MYBs as the key transcription factors that control the early and late anthocyanin biosynthetic pathways. PrMYBa1, which belongs to MYB subgroup 7 (SG7) was found to activate the early biosynthetic gene (EBG) <i>PrF3H</i> by interacting with SG5 member PrMYBa2 to form an 'MM' complex. The SG6 member PrMYBa3 interacts with two SG5 (IIIf) bHLHs to synergistically activate the late biosynthetic genes (LBGs) <i>PrDFR</i> and <i>PrANS</i>, which is essential for anthocyanin accumulation in petal blotches. The comparison of methylation levels of the <i>PrANS</i> and <i>PrF3H</i> promoters between blotch and non-blotch indicated a correlation between hypermethylation and gene silencing. The methylation dynamics of <i>PrANS</i> promoter during flower development revealed a potential early demethylating reaction, which may have contributed to the particular expression of <i>PrANS</i> solely in the blotch area. We suggest that the formation of petal blotch may be highly associated with the cooperation of transcriptional activation and DNA methylation of structural gene promoters.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2023combination,
  author = {Jin Zhu and Yizhou Wang and Qianyu Wang and Bing Li and Xiaohan Wang and Xian Zhou and Hechen Zhang and Wenzhong Xu and Shanshan Li and Liangsheng Wang},
  title = {{The combination of DNA methylation and positive regulation of anthocyanin biosynthesis by MYB and bHLH transcription factors contributes to the petal blotch formation in Xibei tree peony}},
  booktitle = {Horticulture},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1093/hr/uhad100},
}
Figure