The Color Formation Mechanism of the Blue Karst Lakes in Jiuzhaigou Nature Reserve, Sichuan, China

Xiaohui Li, Mengqi Zhang, Weiyang Xiao, Jie Du, Meiqun Sheng, Dalin Zhu, Anđelka Plenković-Moraj, Geng SunWater 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the captivating blue hues of Jiuzhaigou's karst lakes, revealing that travertine deposition and the selective scattering of light by calcium carbonate particles are key to their vibrant colors. By combining hyperspectral data with water chemistry analysis, the researchers developed models linking water quality parameters to lake color, offering a new avenue for water quality assessment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Jiuzhaigou Nature Reserve in China is renowned for its stunningly blue karst lakes, a significant component of its natural beauty. However, the scientific understanding of why these lakes possess such unique and vibrant colors, and how water quality influences this phenomenon, has been insufficient. While it's generally accepted that suspended particles play a role, the specific mechanisms and the interplay of various water quality factors in shaping the distinct blue and green colors of these karst lakes, compared to other freshwater bodies, remained largely unexplored. This paper aims to fill that knowledge gap by detailing the color formation mechanism and identifying the key water quality drivers.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • In Situ Spectral Measurements: They used an ASD FieldSpec HandHeld 2 hyperspectral instrument to collect water-leaving radiance (Lw) and incident irradiance (Ed) data across the visible spectrum (325-1075 nm) at numerous sampling points in Jiuzhaigou's karst lakes and comparable plateau freshwater lakes.
  • Water Quality Analysis: Comprehensive water samples were collected from various depths and analyzed for a wide array of parameters, including physical properties (temperature, turbidity, transparency), chemical indicators (pH, salinity, major ions), and eutrophication indicators (total nitrogen, total phosphorus, CDOM).
  • Colorimetry: The spectral data was converted into tristimulus values (X, Y, Z) and subsequently into RGB color values using established colorimetric methods. This allowed for a quantitative assessment of the lake colors.
  • Statistical Analysis:
    • Redundancy Analysis (RDA): Used to identify the most significant water quality parameters influencing lake color.
  • Pearson Correlation Analysis: Employed to quantify the linear relationships between lake color (R, B values) and various water quality indicators.
  • Stepwise Linear Regression: Developed to establish predictive equations linking water quality parameters to lake color.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): Applied to compare the water quality characteristics of Jiuzhaigou karst lakes with plateau freshwater lakes, highlighting key differentiating factors.
  • One-Way ANOVA and Box Plots: Used to statistically compare specific water quality parameters between the two lake types.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from:

  • Jiuzhaigou Karst Lakes: Including Colorful Lake, Mirror Lake, and Rhinoceros Lake.
  • Plateau Freshwater Lakes: Including Cuoqiong Lake and Xiarucuo Lake.

Spectral data (water-leaving radiance and incident irradiance) and detailed water quality parameters were collected simultaneously during the summer of 2019. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing lakes were sampled for analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Travertine Deposition is Central: The study strongly implicates travertine deposition (calcium carbonate precipitation) as the core process driving the blue color in Jiuzhaigou's karst lakes.
  • Optical Foundation: The selective reflection and scattering of blue and green light by suspended calcium carbonate particles (calc-sinter) is identified as the fundamental optical mechanism.
  • Depth and Transparency Matter: These physical factors directly influence how light penetrates and interacts with the water, significantly impacting perceived color. Deeper, clearer waters tend to appear bluer.
  • Water Quality as an Indirect Driver: While not directly causing the color, water quality parameters influence travertine deposition rates and eutrophication levels, which in turn affect color.
  • Distinction from Freshwater Lakes: The unique water quality of Jiuzhaigou's karst lakes, particularly their low eutrophication and high clarity, leads to a distinct blue hue compared to plateau freshwater lakes, which are more influenced by substrate and turbidity.

Key Results

  • Jiuzhaigou karst lakes are primarily blue and green, with a higher proportion of short-wavelength light in their normalized water-leaving radiance.
  • Travertine deposition was found to be a core link in color formation, with selective scattering by suspended calcium carbonate particles providing the optical basis.
  • Redundancy analysis showed strong correlations between transparency, TDS, and lake colors (p < 0.01), contributing significantly to color variation.
  • Linear regression equations were established, demonstrating a good fit between water quality parameters (like transparency, TDS, K+, SIc, DO, conductivity) and the R, G, B color values of the lakes.
  • PCA revealed clear distinctions in water quality between Jiuzhaigou karst lakes and plateau freshwater lakes, with the former being more influenced by parameters related to travertine deposition.
  • A comparison of colors at similar depths showed Jiuzhaigou karst lakes as predominantly blue/green, while plateau freshwater lakes appeared ivory white or yellow-green, attributed to differences in turbidity and substrate influence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optical Process Clarity: The paper notes that the precise optical process of selective scattering by calcium carbonate suspended matters towards visible light remains unclear and requires further research.
  • Seasonal Variations: The study focused on the summer wet season. The authors suggest that further research is needed on the difference in the formation mechanism of the blue karst lakes in different seasons.
  • Eutrophication Influence: While mentioned as a factor, the direct impact of eutrophication on color formation could be explored more deeply.
  • Broader Application: The findings provide a scientific basis for establishing water quality assessment indicators based on karst lake colors, suggesting potential for wider application in monitoring and management.

Summary updated

Abstract

The karst lakes in Jiuzhaigou Nature Reserve are an integral part of the karst lake landscape, yet research on the formation mechanism for the color of the blue-green lakes in Jiuzhaigou is insufficient. With the help of hyperspectral instruments, coupled with hydro-chemical analysis, this paper elaborates on the unique color characteristics of the Jiuzhaigou karst lakes, delves into the color formation mechanism of the lakes, establishes a regression equation for the color of the lakes as well as the water quality parameters, and sheds light upon the causes for the color distinction between the karst lakes in Jiuzhaigou and the plateau freshwater lakes. The experiment shows that the Jiuzhaigou karst lakes are primarily blue and green, while the proportion of short-wavelength light in the normalized water-leaving radiance and the total incident irradiance of lake water is higher. Based on the redundancy analysis and the correlation analysis, travertine deposition is the core link in the color formation of the blue karst lakes in Jiuzhaigou, while the selective reflection and scattering of the suspended calcium carbonate particulate matters towards visible light represents the optical foundation for the formation. In addition, physical factors such as depth and transparency, changes to the water quality parameters that affect the travertine deposition rate, and the eutrophication process will all exert significant influence over the formation. By building on water-leaving radiance, this paper quantifies the lake color with the tristimulus values (R, G, B) via colorimetrical methods, which features solid goodness of fit with the linear regression equation established based on the water quality parameters. The principal component analysis and colorimetrical analysis show that the color of the karst lakes in Jiuzhaigou varies substantially from that of the plateau freshwater lakes, which mainly results from the difference in the water quality. Research conducted in this paper on the color formation mechanism of the distinct blue karst lakes in Jiuzhaigou illuminates the formation and maintenance mechanism of the plateau karst lakes, which is conducive to better understanding towards the relationship between the water quality and colors of the karst lakes, and provides scientific proof for the establishment of the water quality assessment indicator system based on the colors of the karst lakes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2020color,
  author = {Xiaohui Li and Mengqi Zhang and Weiyang Xiao and Jie Du and Meiqun Sheng and Dalin Zhu and Anđelka Plenković-Moraj and Geng Sun},
  title = {{The Color Formation Mechanism of the Blue Karst Lakes in Jiuzhaigou Nature Reserve, Sichuan, China}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/w12030771},
}
Figure