The Collective Strategies of Major Stakeholders in Land Expropriation: A Tripartite Game Analysis of Central Government, Local Governments, and Land-Lost Farmers

Qiuxiang Li, Haijun Bao, Yi Peng, Haowen Wang, Xiaoling ZhangSustainability 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a tripartite evolutionary game model to analyze the complex strategic interactions between China's central government, local governments, and land-lost farmers during land expropriation. By simulating these interactions, the study reveals how information asymmetry and varying incentives can lead to conflicts, offering insights for more effective land management policies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Land expropriation in China, driven by rapid urbanization, frequently leads to rural conflicts and hinders sustainable development. Existing research often simplifies the stakeholder landscape, typically focusing on just two parties (e.g., farmers and local governments). However, the reality involves at least three key players: the central government (responsible for national land management and policy oversight), local governments (implementing policies and often driven by land finance), and land-lost farmers (seeking to protect their interests). This paper addresses the gap in understanding the collective strategies and dynamic interactions among these three distinct stakeholders, aiming to identify factors contributing to conflicts and propose solutions.

Methods

The core methodology is a tripartite evolutionary game model. This approach is built upon evolutionary game theory, which accounts for bounded rationality and dynamic strategy adjustments over time, making it more realistic than static game theory. The model uses a replication dynamics mechanism to simulate how strategy proportions change based on their relative success. To analyze the stability of different outcomes, the authors employ the Jacobian matrix, a standard tool in dynamical systems analysis. The complex differential equations derived from the model are solved numerically using the Runge-Kutta method, specifically implemented via the ode45 function in MATLAB.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data generated by the model and parameter values chosen to reflect real-world conditions and test specific propositions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Dyadic Interactions: The paper highlights the critical need to consider the tripartite nature of land expropriation conflicts, as the central government's role as a moderator significantly influences the dynamics between local governments and farmers.
  • Information Asymmetry is Key: A central finding is that serious asymmetry of information between stakeholders is a major driver of low game efficiency and severe conflicts.
  • Incentive Structures Matter: The model demonstrates how differing incentives—central government's desire for stability, local government's pursuit of land finance, and farmers' need for compensation and rights protection—shape strategic choices.
  • Evolutionary Dynamics Reveal Stability: The evolutionary game approach shows that stable equilibrium states can emerge, but these can range from cooperative outcomes to conflict-ridden ones, depending on parameter values.
  • Supervision Costs and Punishment: The effectiveness of central government supervision and the severity of punishment for illegal local government actions are crucial in steering outcomes towards more legal and less conflict-prone strategies.

Key Results

The study identifies several potential equilibrium states (ESS) for the tripartite game, each corresponding to different strategy combinations:

  • {Accept, Legal, Supervised} (P1): This is presented as an optimal outcome, achieved when central government supervision costs are low, illegal benefits for local governments are limited, and farmers receive fair compensation.
  • {Accept, Legal, Unsupervised} (P2): This equilibrium emerges when central government supervision costs increase, leading them to adopt an unsupervised strategy while local governments remain legal and farmers accept.
  • {Accept, Illegal, Supervised} (P3): This state occurs when illegal benefits for local governments are high, and they operate under central government supervision.
  • {Accept, Illegal, Unsupervised} (P4): This outcome arises when illegal benefits are high, and the central government's supervision costs are also high, leading to an unsupervised and illegal strategy by local governments.

Simulations show that increasing supervision costs for the central government can decrease their "Supervised" strategy ratio. Conversely, increasing the punishment for illegal local government actions can shift them towards legal strategies. Higher benefits from illegal expropriation strongly incentivize local governments to adopt illegal strategies. The cost for farmers to safeguard their rights also plays a significant role; high costs can lead to farmer passivity, while lower costs can encourage resistance to illegal actions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study is limited by preset research objectives and time constraints. They suggest that future research could:

  • Investigate the roles of other stakeholders, such as NGOs and "opinion leaders."
  • Extend the model to analyze scenarios with four or more stakeholders.
  • Explore the impact of different institutional designs and policy interventions on the evolutionary dynamics.
  • Conduct more extensive empirical validation of the model's parameters and predictions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Land expropriation, during the rapid urbanization process in China, results in rural conflicts and presents barriers in sustainable development. Collective strategies of major stakeholders should be clearly understood for finding effective measures to cope with conflicts. However, the existing studies usually assume two types of stakeholders, which overlook the complicated practices as, at least central, government, local governments, and land-lost farmers are three major stakeholders. This research aims to explore the collective strategies of the three major stakeholders and examine how various factors contribute to conflicts with a tripartite evolutionary game model. The tripartite model is established based on the evolutionary game theories and relationships among the central and local governments, and land-lost farmers. A simulation analysis is also conducted on the MATLAB platform, which shows that serious asymmetry of information between stakeholders leads to the low efficiency of the game or serious conflicts. Thorough discussions on the influencing factors have also been conducted. The findings can provide good references for the central and local governments to reduce conflicts during land expropriation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2017collective,
  author = {Qiuxiang Li and Haijun Bao and Yi Peng and Haowen Wang and Xiaoling Zhang},
  title = {{The Collective Strategies of Major Stakeholders in Land Expropriation: A Tripartite Game Analysis of Central Government, Local Governments, and Land-Lost Farmers}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/su9040648},
}
Figure