The Classification Impact of Different Types of Environmental Regulation on Chinese Provincial Carbon Emission Efficiency

Feifei Ye, Rongyan You, Haitian Lu, Sirui Han, Long-Hao YangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different types of environmental regulations (formal vs. informal) impact carbon emission efficiency across Chinese provinces. It reveals that formal regulations have a "U-shaped" effect, initially hindering then boosting efficiency, while informal regulations show an "inverted U-shaped" effect, peaking at an optimal level. Formal regulations are found to be more effective overall, especially in economically developed regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China, as the world's largest developing country, faces the dual challenge of achieving ambitious carbon emission reduction targets (peaking by 2030, neutrality by 2060) while maintaining economic growth. Environmental regulation is a key tool for this, but existing research often treats it as a monolithic concept. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how different types of environmental regulations – specifically, government-led formal regulations and socially driven informal regulations – uniquely influence provincial carbon emission efficiency. It also highlights limitations in previous studies regarding objective indicator selection and regional classification, aiming to provide a more nuanced analysis.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-faceted approach:

  • Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) Undesirable Output Model: This is used to calculate carbon emission efficiency, specifically accounting for "undesirable outputs" like carbon emissions alongside "desirable outputs" like GDP. This method is chosen for its ability to handle multiple inputs and outputs without requiring pre-defined weights.
  • Entropy Weight Method: To overcome the subjectivity of traditional indicator selection, this method is used to objectively determine the weights of various input and output indicators for carbon emission efficiency.
  • K-Means Cluster Analysis: This technique is applied to group China's 30 provinces into distinct categories based on factors like economic development, secondary industry value, carbon emissions, and energy consumption. This allows for an examination of how regulatory impacts differ across regions with varying characteristics.
  • Fixed-Effects Regression Model: This statistical model is used to analyze the relationship between formal and informal environmental regulations (and other control variables) and carbon emission efficiency, both overall and within the identified regional clusters.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from 30 Chinese provinces for the period 2009-2019. The data sources include the environmental module-related indicators published by the National Bureau of Statistics of China. Specific indicators used for DEA include: number of industries above designated size, investment in controlling waste gas, natural gas supply, gross domestic product (GDP), and carbon emissions. For the regression analysis, control variables such as technical innovation, foreign investment, GDP, and industrial structure were also included.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Differentiated Impacts: Environmental regulations are not a one-size-fits-all solution. The distinction between formal (government-imposed) and informal (socially driven) regulations is crucial for understanding their varied effects.
  • The "Green Paradox" and "Porter Hypothesis" in Action: The study explores how regulations can sometimes lead to increased emissions in the short term (green paradox) but also stimulate innovation and efficiency in the long run (Porter hypothesis).
  • Regional Heterogeneity Matters: China's vast economic and developmental disparities mean that the effectiveness of environmental regulations varies significantly by region. A blanket approach is unlikely to be optimal.
  • Objective Indicator Selection: Moving beyond expert opinion for indicator selection using entropy weighting adds robustness and objectivity to the efficiency calculations.

Key Results

  • Formal Environmental Regulation: Exhibits a "U-shaped" relationship with carbon emission efficiency. Initially, increased regulation may lead to a temporary decrease in efficiency (retrogression effect) due to rising costs. However, as regulation intensifies, it stimulates technological innovation, leading to improved efficiency.
  • Informal Environmental Regulation: Shows an "inverted U-shaped" relationship with carbon emission efficiency. There's an optimal level of informal regulation where it effectively drives efficiency. Beyond this point, excessive informal pressure might hinder innovation or increase operational costs, leading to a decline in efficiency.
  • Overall Incentive Effect: Formal environmental regulations demonstrate a stronger incentive effect on carbon emission efficiency compared to informal regulations.
  • Regional Classification:
    • Category 1 (Developed Regions): Formal environmental regulation has a significant incentive effect. Informal regulation's effect is not significant.
  • Category 2 (Less Developed Regions): Neither formal nor informal regulations show a significant incentive effect.
  • Category 3 (Industrializing Regions): No significant incentive effect from either type of regulation was found.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Interval Numbers: The study did not incorporate interval numbers for carbon emission efficiency, which could be relevant for indicators like pollutant concentration. Future work could explore modeling with interval values.
  • Broader Decision-Making Factors: The analysis could be expanded to include other crucial factors like urbanization levels, regional resource status, and specific regional policies.
  • Industry-Specific Analysis: The current study focuses on provincial-level analysis. Future research could delve into carbon emission governance across different industries.
  • Policy Recommendations: The paper concludes with policy suggestions, emphasizing the need for differentiated regulations based on regional development, strengthening public awareness of environmental protection, and adopting a diversified mix of policy tools (command-control, economic incentives, public participation).

Summary updated

Abstract

The evaluation of inter-provincial carbon emission efficiency and the analysis of its influencing factors hold great practical significance for reducing carbon emissions and promoting sustainable development in ecological management. To address the shortcomings of existing research in the classification evaluation of carbon emission efficiency and account for the impacts of different environmental regulatory policies on carbon emissions, this paper aims to examine the impact of formal and informal environmental regulations on carbon emission efficiency. This is accomplished by utilizing a combination of the data envelopment analysis (DEA) model, entropy weighting, and k-means cluster analysis methods. The fixed-effects model is also applied to examine the influences of different factors on carbon emission efficiency under different categories. To conduct the case studies, carbon emission management data from 30 provinces in China are collected, and the results show the following: (1) Formal environmental regulations exhibit a “U-shaped” relationship with carbon emission efficiency, whereas informal environmental regulations have an “inverted U-shaped” relationship with carbon emission efficiency. (2) Under the cluster analysis of carbon emission efficiency, formal environmental regulations are found to have a stronger incentive effect on inter-provincial carbon efficiency compared to informal environmental regulations. This study carries significant theoretical and practical implications for China’s timely attainment of its double-carbon target.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ye2023classification,
  author = {Feifei Ye and Rongyan You and Haitian Lu and Sirui Han and Long-Hao Yang},
  title = {{The Classification Impact of Different Types of Environmental Regulation on Chinese Provincial Carbon Emission Efficiency}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151512092},
}
Figure