The Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse: Origins and Goals
Abstract
The Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse (http://clearinghouse.net) solves a significant information deficit related to civil rights litigation by posting information about thousands of ongoing and closed large-scale civil rights cases. Documents are OCR’d and searchable; cases are searchable by metadata tags as well as full-text searching. Each case has a litigation summary by a law student. We live in a civil rights era—a time when people are using the courts, among other strategies, to fight for civil rights. The Clearinghouse posts the records of those fights, the stories of civil rights cases—across topics, across regions, across organizations—and makes them searchable, usable, and available to everybody.
Introduction: Addressing the Information Deficit
In the American legal system, a profound gap exists between the law as written in statutes and the law as implemented in practice. While landmark judicial opinions are widely available through commercial databases, the vast majority of large-scale civil rights litigation—addressing critical issues such as school desegregation, prison reform, and police misconduct—does not culminate in a definitive, published opinion. Instead, these cases often result in negotiated settlements or consent decrees that are "so ordered" by a court but remain buried in local dockets.
Historically, accessing these records required specific knowledge of case names, jurisdictions, and docket numbers, creating a significant barrier to systemic legal research. This "information deficit" prevented researchers, advocates, and the public from understanding how institutions were actually being ordered to change. The Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse was established to bridge this gap, providing a transparent, centralized repository for the "on-the-ground" records of civil rights enforcement.
Methodology and Infrastructure
Founded by Professor Margo Schlanger, the Clearinghouse operates as a specialized digital archive and search engine. The project’s methodology relies on a multi-stage process of data curation:
- Sourcing: The team gathers documents from diverse sources, including the personal files of retired attorneys, the ACLU National Prison Project, and the Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division.
- Digitization: Paper archives are scanned and processed using Optical Character Recognition (OCR), ensuring that historical documents are fully searchable.
- Human Curation: A critical component of the project is the involvement of hundreds of law students. These students code documents, apply metadata tags, and author concise litigation summaries for each case.
- Public Access: The resulting data is hosted on a public-facing portal (clearinghouse.net), allowing users to navigate the archive by topic, region, organization, or specific metadata.
The Dataset: A Living Archive
At the time of its primary documentation, the Clearinghouse repository featured over 56,000 documents representing more than 8,000 cases. This includes a diverse range of document types, such as complaints, judicial orders, settlement agreements, and docket sheets. The project maintains a commitment to ongoing growth, with hundreds of new cases continuously being processed and added to the database.
Key Insights: Implementation vs. Opinion
The Clearinghouse project highlights several vital insights for legal scholarship and advocacy:
- Transparency as a Tool for Justice: By centralizing fragmented records, the project empowers advocates to amplify their voices and strengthen their bargaining positions through a better understanding of legal precedents and successful settlement structures.
- Focus on Implementation: The archive shifts the focus from what a court says (opinions) to what an institution does (implementation). It captures the actual "stories" of legal struggles that are often lost in traditional legal databases.
- The Power of Metadata: Raw documents are transformed into a structured research tool through rigorous tagging. Metadata such as "immigration class actions" or "fair lending" allows for cross-case analysis that was previously impossible.
- Academic Crowdsourcing: The project serves as a model for leveraging student labor to build public-interest infrastructure that commercial entities like Westlaw or LexisNexis have overlooked.
Results and Impact
The Clearinghouse has successfully evolved from a personal research collection into a vital piece of national information infrastructure. Its primary impacts include democratized access to documents that once required physical travel to courthouses, and the enablement of systemic understanding by aggregating records across diverse topics and regions. OCR technology ensures that decades of civil rights history are accessible through simple keyword searches.
Limitations and Future Directions
Despite its success, the project faces ongoing challenges. Update latency remains a factor for active litigation, as the archive is updated periodically rather than in real-time. Coverage gaps may still exist for certain regions or eras depending on the availability of source materials. Finally, the long-term sustainability of such a labor-intensive project—relying on continuous student involvement—remains a central concern.
Conclusion
The Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse stands as a testament to the power of digital preservation in the pursuit of justice. By making the records of civil rights fights available to all, it ensures that the history of these struggles is not just preserved, but actively usable for the next generation of advocates and scholars.
Summary updated