The circulating lipidome is largely defined by sex descriptors in the GOLDN, GeneBank and the ADNI studies

Dinesh Kumar Barupal, Ying Zhang, Sili Fan, Stanley L. Hazen, W.h. Wilson Tang, Tomáš Čajka, Marguerite R. Irvin, Donna K. Arnett, Tobias Kind, Rima Kaddurah‐Daouk, Oliver FiehnbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that biological sex significantly influences the blood lipidome, with a substantial percentage of lipids differing between men and women across three large cohorts. The findings emphasize the need to analyze lipidomics data separately for males and females to uncover sex-specific metabolic mechanisms and inform personalized health strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Biological sex is a fundamental factor influencing human physiology and health, yet many large-scale studies often overlook or combine data from males and females, potentially masking sex-specific biological mechanisms. This can lead to missed opportunities in developing targeted therapeutic strategies. Specifically, the authors aim to comprehensively investigate the extent to which the blood lipidome, a crucial component of metabolism and health, is shaped by sexual dimorphism across diverse populations. They question whether current approaches of pooling sex data might obscure important sex-specific lipid profiles and their implications for health and disease.

Methods

The researchers employed Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (LC-MS) to analyze a broad spectrum of lipids in blood samples. They utilized a robust data processing pipeline, including MTBE extraction, UPLC-QTOF analysis, and data conversion to mzML format. A key methodological aspect was the use of a random forest-based normalization method (SERRF tool) to minimize technical variance and batch effects across the different cohorts. For statistical analysis, they used the Mann-Whitney U test to identify significant differences in individual lipids between men and women. To analyze lipid classes, they applied the ChemRICH enrichment analysis method, which assesses the statistical significance of differences at the class level without relying on a background database.

Datasets

The study analyzed data from three large, well-established population cohorts:

  • ADNI (Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative): n = 806 participants.
  • GeneBank: n = 1,015 participants.
  • GOLDN (Genetics of Lipid Lowering Drugs and Diet Network): n = 422 participants.

In total, 2,243 subjects were included, providing a comprehensive dataset for investigating sex differences in the lipidome.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sex is a dominant factor in lipid profiles: The sheer number of lipids showing sex differences suggests that lipid metabolism is fundamentally regulated differently between males and females.
  • Sex-specific lipid profiles are consistent across cohorts: The observation that a significant proportion of lipids differ between sexes in all three cohorts, despite potential differences in age and other factors, points to a robust biological basis for these differences.
  • The importance of sex-specific analysis: The study strongly advocates for stratifying lipidomics data by sex in future epidemiological studies, rather than treating sex as a confounding factor, to avoid masking crucial biological insights.
  • Specific lipid classes show distinct sex-based patterns: The identification of particular lipid classes (e.g., phosphatidylcholines, sphingomyelins higher in women; triacylglycerols, lysophosphatidylcholines higher in men) provides concrete targets for further investigation into sex-specific metabolic pathways.
  • Age can modulate sex differences: The study notes that age can influence the direction or presence of sex differences in certain lipid classes, highlighting the complex interplay of factors.

Key Results

  • A total of 355 unique lipids from 15 lipid classes were detected across the three studies.
  • 60% of these lipids showed significant differences between men and women in all three cohorts.
  • Up to 87% of all detected lipids demonstrated sex differences in at least one cohort.
  • Sphingomyelins (SM), particularly SM d32:2, were consistently found at higher levels in women across all cohorts.
  • Phosphatidylcholines (PC) and sphingomyelins (SM) were generally higher in women, while triacylglycerols (TG) and lysophosphatidylcholines (LPC) were higher in men.
  • Acylcarnitines were higher in men in the ADNI cohort, but showed a mixed response in GeneBank.
  • Saturated fatty acids were higher in men, while unsaturated fatty acids were higher in women across all three cohorts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cohort-specific variations: While many lipid differences were consistent, the study acknowledges that factors like participant age, comorbidities, diet, and medication usage can influence lipid profiles and may affect sex differences. Future work should further investigate the impact of these factors.
  • Further investigation of specific lipids: The remarkable p-values for certain sphingomyelins suggest that their sex-specific regulation warrants further validation in other epidemiological cohorts.
  • Mechanistic studies: The authors call for studies to discover the underlying mechanisms driving these sex-specific lipid differences, potentially through animal models and functional genomics, to inform sex-specific disease prevention strategies.
  • Diet and exercise contributions: Future research should aim to disentangle the relative contributions of endogenous lipid remodeling versus diet and exercise to observed sex differences.
  • Sex-specific metabolic networks: The study suggests constructing sex-specific metabolic networks to map regulatory mechanisms and better understand sexual dimorphism in lipid metabolism.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Biological sex is one of the major anthropometric factors which influences physiology, metabolism and health status. We have investigated the effect of sexual dimorphism on the blood lipidome profile in three large population level studies - the Alzheimer’s disease neuroimaging initiative - ADNI (n =806), the GeneBank Functional Cardio-Metabolomics cohort (n= 1015) and the Genetics of Lipid lowering Drugs and Diet Network - GOLDN (n=422). In total, 355 unique lipids from 15 lipid classes were detected across all three studies using LC-MS. Sixty percent of these lipids differed between men and women in all three cohorts, and up to 87% of all lipids demonstrated sex differences in at least one cohort. ChemRICH enrichment statistics on lipid classes showed that phosphatidylcholines, phosphatidylethanolamines, phosphatidylinositols, ceramides, sphingomyelins and cholesterol esters were found at higher levels in female subjects while triacylglycerols and lysophosphatidylcholines were found at higher levels in male participants across the three cohorts. This strong sex effect on the blood lipidome suggests that specific regulatory mechanisms may exist that regulate lipid metabolism in a different manner between men and women. Cohort studies involving blood lipidomics should consider separate analyses for male and female participants instead of combined analyses treating sex as a confounding factor.
BibTeX
@misc{barupal2019circulating,
  author = {Dinesh Kumar Barupal and Ying Zhang and Sili Fan and Stanley L. Hazen and W.H. Wilson Tang and Tomáš Čajka and Marguerite R. Irvin and Donna K. Arnett and Tobias Kind and Rima Kaddurah‐Daouk and Oliver Fiehn},
  title = {{The circulating lipidome is largely defined by sex descriptors in the GOLDN, GeneBank and the ADNI studies}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/731448},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure