TL;DR
This paper investigates the potential impact of a Chinese Yuan (RMB) devaluation on the Hong Kong dollar. Using a computable general equilibrium (CGE) model and a survey of financial market participants, the authors find that while the direct trade effects of an RMB devaluation on Hong Kong's foreign reserves are negligible and even slightly negative, market psychology plays a dominant role, potentially leading to a panic sell-off of Hong Kong assets.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In the late 1990s, many Asian currencies devalued significantly during the Asian financial crisis. China, however, maintained the stability of its currency, the Yuan (RMB), a policy praised internationally. This paper delves into the question of whether this commitment to a stable RMB was truly in China's self-interest, particularly concerning its impact on Hong Kong. Hong Kong's economic stability was, and remains, crucial for Beijing, especially after its reversion to Chinese rule in 1997. The stability of the Hong Kong dollar, pegged to the US dollar, was seen as a symbol of Hong Kong's economic health. Therefore, any potential devaluation of the RMB raised concerns about its implications for the Hong Kong dollar, with some fearing a domino effect of devaluations or a severe run on the Hong Kong dollar. This paper aims to quantify the real economic effects and assess the psychological impact of an RMB devaluation on the Hong Kong dollar.
Methods
The study employs a two-pronged approach:
- Computable General Equilibrium (CGE) Model: A multisectoral, multicountry CGE model is used to simulate the impact of a hypothetical RMB devaluation on Hong Kong's trade balance and, consequently, its foreign exchange reserves. This model captures real trade flows, trade balances, world prices, and real exchange rates. It simulates a 10% RMB devaluation against the US dollar to assess the "trade factor."
- Survey of Financial Market Participants: A small-sample survey of seven financial market participants in Hong Kong (currency traders, securities traders, fund managers, and investment bank economists) was conducted to gauge their perceptions and expectations regarding an RMB devaluation. This survey focuses on the "psychological factor," exploring how market participants would react to such an event.
Datasets
The paper does not introduce new datasets or benchmarks. Instead, it relies on:
- Existing CGE Model Framework: The CGE model is based on established frameworks used for analyzing global trade liberalization and structural adjustment programs.
- Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) Data: Used for comparison with simulation results regarding foreign currency assets.
- Chinese Customs Statistics and GTAP Data: Used for calculating trade shares and markups.
- Feenstra et al. (1998) Data: Used for markup estimates on entrepot trade.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Conflicting Trade Channels: An RMB devaluation creates opposing forces on Hong Kong's foreign reserves. On one hand, it can boost Hong Kong's role as an entrepot for Chinese exports to the rest of the world (positive effect). On the other hand, it can reduce Hong Kong's direct exports to China and increase its direct imports from China (negative effects).
- Dominance of Negative Trade Effects: The CGE model simulations suggest that the negative trade effects (reduced direct exports and increased direct imports) tend to outweigh the positive entrepot effect, leading to a slight decrease in Hong Kong's foreign reserves.
- Negligible Quantitative Impact of Trade Effects: Despite the negative net effect, the simulations show that the impact of an RMB devaluation on Hong Kong's foreign exchange reserves through trade channels is quantitatively very small, often less than the month-to-month fluctuations in Hong Kong's actual foreign currency assets.
- Overwhelming Psychological Impact: The survey results reveal a strong consensus among market participants: regardless of the actual trade balance effects, an RMB devaluation would trigger panic selling of Hong Kong dollars due to a loss of confidence in the currency's peg. This psychological factor is deemed far more significant than the trade factor.
Key Results
- Trade Factor: A 10% RMB devaluation leads to a net decline in Hong Kong's foreign exchange reserves, ranging from US$163 million to US$589 million, depending on the markup estimates. This represents a small increase in Hong Kong's trade deficit (0.8% to 2.8% of the 1997 deficit).
- Psychological Factor: All seven survey respondents agreed that an RMB devaluation would lead to panic selling of the Hong Kong dollar. This suggests that market sentiment, rather than the direct economic impact on trade, is the primary driver of potential instability.
- Small Sample Size Caveat: The survey's small sample size limits the generalizability of its findings, but the unanimous agreement on the psychological effect is striking.
Limitations and Future Work
- Model Limitations: The CGE model does not incorporate financial markets, interest rates, or asset markets, meaning it cannot directly analyze the financial aspects of a currency crisis or the speculative attacks it might trigger. It focuses solely on real trade flows.
- Survey Limitations: The survey's small sample size is a significant limitation, preventing formal statistical testing and raising questions about its representativeness.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that future research could link the real trade model to a macro model that includes asset flows to better understand the interplay between real exchange rates, trade balances, and financial market dynamics. Further investigation into the psychological impact, perhaps with larger and more diverse samples, would also be valuable.
Summary updated