Abstract
Background: The characteristics of patients who experienced subsequent distal radius fracture (DRF) after initial DRF have not been determined. The purpose of this study was to investigate the characteristics of patients with subsequent DRF and to compare bone fragility parameters of patients with primary and subsequent distal DRF. Methods: We compared demographic characteristics and bone fragility parameters, including bone mineral densities (BMDs), trabecular bone score (TBS), hip geometry parameters, and bicortical thickness (BCT) of the distal radius in 215 patients with initial DRF and 26 patients with subsequent DRF. To reduce bias, patients with subsequent DRF were propensity score-matched in a 1:2 manner with patients affected by initial DRF, and additional comparison was performed. Results: Patients in the subsequent DRF group were older than those in the initial DRF group, but this difference was not significant (p = 0.091). The proportion of patients receiving osteoporosis medications was significantly higher in the subsequent DRF group (41.7% vs. 19.2%, p = 0.011). Bone fragility parameters, including BMD, TBS, hip geometry parameters, and BCT did not differ significantly between the two groups. However, ten-year probability of major osteoporotic fractures was significantly higher in patients with subsequent DRF (p < 0.001). Similar results were observed upon comparing the propensity score-matched initial and subsequent DRF groups. Conclusions: These findings suggest that the occurrence of subsequent DRF after initial DRF can be attributed to multiple factors rather than bone fragility alone. Systematic and multidisciplinary managements would be helpful for preventing the occurrence of subsequent DRF after initial DRF.
Introduction
Distal radius fractures (DRF) are the most common upper extremity fractures in women over 50. A primary fracture is often a harbinger of future skeletal events; clinically, it is well-established that "fracture begets fracture." However, the specific physiological drivers behind subsequent wrist fractures remain unclear. Researchers at the Asan Medical Center sought to determine if these repeat fractures are caused by significantly lower bone mineral density (BMD), degraded bone microarchitecture (trabecular bone), or specific bone geometry. Understanding these factors is vital for improving Fracture Liaison Services (FLS) aimed at preventing secondary, often more severe, breaks.
Methods
This retrospective study analyzed 227 women treated at the Asan Medical Center (Seoul, South Korea) between September 2016 and April 2019 for DRF caused by low-energy trauma. The cohort was divided into an Initial DRF Group (n=203) and a Subsequent DRF Group (n=24). To account for confounding variables, propensity score matching was employed at a 1:2 ratio, matching patients based on age, BMI, and sex.
Key parameters measured included:
- BMD: Bone mineral density via DXA scans.
- TBS (Trabecular Bone Score): An indirect measure of bone microarchitecture.
- Hip Geometry: Parameters such as Hip Axis Length (HAL) and Neck Shaft Angle (NSA).
- BCT (Bicortical Thickness): Measurement of the radius bone's shell thickness via X-ray.
- FRAX®: A clinical tool calculating the 10-year probability of major osteoporotic fractures.
Results
The study revealed a "density paradox": there were no statistically significant differences in BMD, TBS, or bicortical thickness between patients with a single fracture and those with a history of multiple fractures. This suggests that standard bone density scans alone may be insufficient to identify patients at the highest risk for recurrence.
Significant differences were found in clinical risk factors. The subsequent fracture group had a higher prevalence of asthma (16.7% vs. 2.5%, p = 0.009) and a higher rate of prior osteoporosis medication use (41.7% vs. 19.2%, p = 0.011), as shown in the clinical data table.
Crucially, while physical bone measurements were similar, the FRAX scores were significantly higher in the subsequent fracture group (10.8% vs. 7.5%, p < 0.001). This indicates that clinical history and integrated risk assessment tools are more powerful predictors of future fractures than imaging parameters alone.
Discussion and Conclusion
The findings suggest that subsequent DRF is likely driven by a combination of clinical risk factors and potentially extrinsic factors like fall risk, rather than intrinsic bone fragility alone. The higher prevalence of asthma suggests that systemic inflammation or its treatments (e.g., steroids) may play a role. Furthermore, the fact that many patients in the subsequent group were already on medication suggests that pharmacological intervention alone may not be enough for high-risk individuals.
Limitations: The study is limited by its retrospective design, small sample size in the subsequent group, and lack of data on physical performance, balance, or muscle mass (sarcopenia).
Conclusion: Preventing subsequent fractures requires a holistic, multidisciplinary approach. Future Fracture Liaison Services should focus not only on bone density but also on extrinsic factors such as muscle strength, balance training, and environmental fall prevention.
Summary updated