The Changes of Standard of Fairness

Wenying Bai, Yue Gao, Yin QiAdvances 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Fairness is not a static moral constant; it is a "moving target" shaped by economic incentives, social hierarchy, cultural background, and cognitive maturity. This review synthesizes interdisciplinary research to show how humans transition from rigid, equal-split "fairness" in childhood to a complex, intention-based framework in adulthood.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While fairness is a cornerstone of social cooperation, it is notoriously difficult to define. Most research focuses on a single dimension—such as how children share toys or how different cultures trade goods. However, these "siloed" views fail to explain why the same person might have different standards of fairness depending on their bank account balance, their cultural upbringing, or their age.

The authors address this gap by providing a comprehensive literature review that integrates four major pillars: behavioral economics, social status, cultural differences, and human development. Their goal is to move toward a broader, more holistic concept of fairness that accounts for the "unstable" nature of human perception.

Methods

This paper is a literature review and synthesis. Rather than conducting a new empirical experiment, the authors aggregate and analyze existing findings from psychology, sociology, and behavioral economics. They categorize these findings into a four-part framework to demonstrate how various external and internal factors "calibrate" an individual's sense of justice.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. (As a literature review, it references various experimental datasets from cited works—such as "trust games" in Mozambique and Germany or "dictator games" in different cultures—but does not introduce a new dataset).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Intentionality Shift: One of the most significant "aha moments" is the transition from outcome-based to intention-based fairness. While infants prefer "good" outcomes (treating everyone well), adults are much more flexible. An adult might view an "unfair" distribution as acceptable if the intention was prosocial (e.g., helping a poor person live a better life).
  • Status-Based Fairness: Social hierarchy creates a "selfish bias." High-status individuals often view fairness through the lens of their own rights and control, while low-status individuals, facing "double disadvantages" in health and education, are more likely to perceive the entire system as inherently unfair.
  • Autonomy vs. Reciprocity: Culture dictates the "flavor" of fairness. Western/individualistic cultures tend to value autonomy (the freedom to act independently), whereas Eastern/collectivist cultures (notably in the Chinese concept of guanxi) view fairness as a service chain of reciprocity—a long-term network of favors and counter-favors.
  • The Meritocratic Evolution: We aren't born believing that "hard work pays off." Children under 10 are typically strict egalitarians (everyone gets an equal share). It is only through cognitive maturation and social experience (around the 13th grade/late adolescence) that humans begin to accept unequal rewards as "fair" if they reflect differences in personal effort and achievement.

Key Results

The paper summarizes several quantitative and qualitative findings from the field:

  • Developmental Milestones: 5th-grade students tend to distribute rewards equally regardless of input, whereas 13th-grade students accept unequal results when provided with evidence of unequal effort.
  • Cross-Cultural Trust: In trust game experiments, participants from middle-income countries (like Brazil) expect more reciprocity from those in high-income countries (like Germany) than they do from those in lower-income countries (like Mozambique).
  • Digital Universals: Interestingly, some fairness norms may transcend culture in digital spaces. Research on World of Warcraft and League of Legends suggests that gaming communities often develop a shared "norm of fairness" that players respect regardless of their real-world cultural background.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the data on collectivist vs. individualist cultures is sometimes contradictory. For example, some "dictator game" experiments showed that individuals from individualistic cultures actually reciprocated more significantly than those from collectivist cultures when punishing norm violators.

The paper suggests that future research should look deeper into these contradictions, particularly within online gaming communities, to see if digital environments are creating a new, globalized standard of fairness that bypasses traditional cultural boundaries.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper demonstrates the relevance of fairness and social phenomena and provides four major aspects which affect the chances of the standards of fairness: behavioural economic development, social status hierarchy, cultural differences, and human development process as the main basis for supporting the general point. These propositions show the potential value and significance of human beings in the social fairness phenomenon. These main points are focused on the tendency of collectivist culture and individualism culture to autonomous and reciprocity. Preferences expressed in emotions and states play an important role in fair trading.; the difference in the group to which individual belongs and how fairness is evaluated. The influence of social information and individual maturity on tolerance of unfairness.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bai2022changes,
  author = {Wenying Bai and Yue Gao and Yin Qi},
  title = {{The Changes of Standard of Fairness}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2991/assehr.k.220504.335},
}
Figure