The Change in Body Temperature, Not Acute-Phase Reaction, Predicts anit-Osteoporosis Efficacy after the First Administration of Zoledronic Acid in a self-control study

Yanping Du, Weijia Yu, Haixin Gou, Yiming Lei, Tongkai Zhang, Wenjing Tang, Minmin Chen, Huilin Li, Qun ChengResearch Square 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Acute-phase reactions (APRs) are common side effects following the first administration of Zoledronic Acid (ZOL) for osteoporosis. While these flu-like symptoms are often assumed to indicate drug activity, their relationship with clinical efficacy remains unclear. This study investigated whether objective measures, specifically body temperature changes, could predict bone mineral density (BMD) improvements. In a one-year study of 108 postmenopausal women, researchers found that while the general presence of APRs did not correlate with outcomes, the magnitude of temperature increase within three days of treatment was a significant predictor of BMD gains at 6 and 12 months.

Introduction

Zoledronic Acid (ZOL) is a standard once-yearly intravenous treatment for osteoporosis. However, the first dose frequently triggers an acute-phase reaction (APR)—a cluster of symptoms including fever, chills, and muscle pain. Clinicians have long debated whether a stronger initial reaction signals better long-term efficacy. Because APRs are typically self-reported and subjective, this study aimed to identify an objective biomarker—body temperature—to clarify the link between the initial inflammatory response and long-term bone health.

Methods

The researchers conducted a self-controlled pre-post study involving 108 postmenopausal women (average age 67.4 years) in Shanghai, China. Each participant received a 5mg dose of IV ZOL. The study tracked oral temperatures for the first three days post-infusion and measured Bone Mineral Density (BMD) via DXA scans at baseline, 6 months, and 12 months. Additionally, Bone Turnover Markers (BTMs), including CTX (resorption) and PINP (formation), were monitored alongside blood counts.

Results

The study revealed that the binary presence of an APR (yes/no) was not a reliable predictor of bone density gains. However, the specific degree of temperature change showed a strong positive correlation with Lumbar Spine (LS) BMD gains at both 6 months ($r=0.304$) and 12 months ($r=0.387$).

Table 1: Patient characteristics and clinical markers at baseline and follow-up intervals.

Key findings from the longitudinal data include:

  • Temperature Threshold: ROC curve analysis identified a temperature increase of 1.95°C as the optimal cutoff for predicting clinically significant spine BMD gains, with a sensitivity of 68.2% and specificity of 78.1%.
  • Mediation by CTX: The relationship between fever and BMD was mediated by serum CTX levels. Higher temperature spikes were associated with more effective suppression of bone resorption ($b=0.046$, 95% CI [0.0010-0.0091]).
  • Biological Mechanism: The researchers noted a correlation between temperature spikes and a reduction in monocytes two weeks post-treatment. Since osteoclasts (bone-resorbing cells) differentiate from monocytes, this provides a mechanistic link between the initial inflammatory "storm" and subsequent bone preservation.

Discussion and Conclusion

The findings suggest that the "fever effect" is a tangible indicator of ZOL's impact on the mevalonate pathway. While subjective flu-like symptoms are noisy indicators, a measured temperature rise of $\ge$ 1.95°C serves as a robust predictor of treatment success. This objective measure could help clinicians identify "poor responders" early, allowing for personalized adjustments to treatment plans. While the study is limited by its one-year duration and focus on the first dose, it provides a clear path toward using physiological responses to gauge the efficacy of osteoporosis therapies.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background:</bold> Acute-phase reactions (APRs) are common among people who are treated for the first time with zoledronate (ZOL). The current view is that both the APRs caused by ZOL and its efficacy are related to the mevalonic acid pathway. However, the relationship between APR and ZOL efficacy remains unclear. <bold>Methods:</bold> This study was a self pre - post control study<bold> </bold>involving postmenopausal women with osteoporosis in Shanghai, China, for 1 year. A total of 108 patients withan average age of 67.4±5.8 years were treated with 5 mg intravenous ZOL for the first time. Data on demographic characteristics, APRs , blood counts, bone turnover markers, including CTX and PINP, and bone mineral density (BMD) were collected. <bold>Results:</bold> 1) The results did not show a relationship between the APRs and changes in bone turnover markers and BMD but showed that changes in body temperature (T) within 3 days after administration were positively correlated with changes in BMD of LS at Month 6 and Month 12 (r=0.304 P&lt;0.05, r=0.387 P&lt;0.01). 2) This effect was mainly mediated by changes in serum CTX (b=0.046, 95% CI [0.0010-0.0091]). 3) TheROC curve showed that when T increased by 1.95°C, the sensitivity and specificity of judging the clinically important change in LS BMD after 1 year were the best. <bold>Conclusions:</bold> In this study, we tested the hypothesis that people with elevated body T after initial ZOL treatment had greater BMD improvements and better outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{du2024change,
  author = {Yanping Du and Weijia Yu and Haixin Gou and Yiming Lei and Tongkai Zhang and Wenjing Tang and Minmin Chen and Huilin Li and Qun Cheng},
  title = {{The Change in Body Temperature, Not Acute-Phase Reaction, Predicts anit-Osteoporosis Efficacy after the First Administration of Zoledronic Acid in a self-control study}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-4129472/v1},
}
Figure