The Challenges of Implementing Healthcare Technology and Innovation Across Europe and Beyond

Heli Laarmann, Clayton Hamilton, A Bosman, Rodolphe Thiébaut, Umair A. Shah, Caroline Wood, Patty Kostkova2019 · DOI

Abstract

Public Health in the European Union is mainly a formal competence of the Member States. EU Treaties and Regulations have given EU gradually more mandate in past decades on issues of surveillance, epidemic intelligence, early warning and cross-border response coordination. In this context, sharing timely information on public health threats (fast and slow) to inform interventions at national and EU level, remains of great added value for all Member States. This depends on common standards, compatibility and interoperability of information systems. In this session, panellists will share their experience and recent digital health developments from the perspective of regional, national and international public health and discuss this in the light of developments in digital technology.

Introduction: The Fragmentation of Public Health Data

The integration of healthcare technology across Europe faces significant systemic hurdles. Historically, public health has been the "formal competence" of individual Member States, leading to a fragmented landscape where each country developed independent systems for surveillance and healthcare delivery.

As health threats—both "fast" (sudden outbreaks) and "slow" (chronic disease trends)—increasingly transcend national borders, the necessity for a unified response has become paramount. While EU treaties have gradually expanded the mandate of central bodies for epidemic intelligence and early warning systems, the underlying technical infrastructure remains siloed. A critical gap exists: while the mandate to coordinate is present, the technical interoperability and common standards required for real-time, life-saving data exchange are largely absent.

Methodology: A Multi-Perspective Synthesis

To address these challenges, the 2019 Digital Public Health (DPH) conference convened a plenary session featuring a diverse group of experts. The methodology centered on a 360-degree panel discussion designed to synthesize varied experiences and identify universal roadblocks in digital health development.

Panelists and affiliations representing diverse perspectives in digital public health.

The panel included representatives from various sectors to provide a comprehensive view:

  • National Government: The Ministry of Social Affairs of Estonia, providing insights from a global leader in e-government.
  • International Organizations: WHO Europe, offering a supra-national perspective on health coordination.
  • Academia and Research: Experts from the University of Bordeaux and the UCL IRDR Centre for Digital Public Health in Emergencies.
  • Field Practice: Input from Transmissable (Netherlands) and Harris County Public Health (USA) to provide comparative insights into how these challenges manifest both within and outside the European Union.

Key Insights: From Silos to Integration

The session identified several key shifts and requirements for the future of digital public health:

1. The Shift Toward Centralized Mandates

There is a clear historical trajectory of the EU assuming greater responsibility for surveillance and cross-border response. This evolution necessitates a transition from isolated national technology stacks toward a more integrated European health data space.

2. Interoperability as a Fundamental Requirement

Interoperability is not merely a technical preference but a public health necessity. Without the ability for different systems to exchange and accurately interpret data, the potential "added value" of shared information is lost to delays and incompatibility.

3. The "Fast and Slow" Threat Model

Digital health systems must be resilient enough to manage both "fast" threats, such as acute epidemics requiring immediate action, and "slow" threats, such as long-term public health trends. This requires systems that are both agile and capable of maintaining longitudinal data integrity.

4. Global Benchmarking

The inclusion of perspectives from outside the EU, such as Harris County, Texas, underscores that the challenges of implementing healthcare technology are universal. Finding scalable solutions requires a global dialogue that extends beyond European borders.

Results: The Three Pillars of Digital Public Health

The primary outcome of the session was a consensus on the three essential pillars required for modern digital public health infrastructure:

  1. Common Standards: Unified agreements on data formatting and categorization.
  2. Compatibility: The physical and logical connectivity between different software and hardware systems.
  3. Interoperability: The highest level of integration, enabling systems to not only exchange data but also interpret it for clinical or policy action.

While the technology for digital health is currently available, the socio-technical and political frameworks required for cross-border implementation are still being established.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The effectiveness of modern public health interventions is currently constrained by the lack of fully realized technical standards. Future efforts must focus on:

  • Developing robust protocols for cross-border response coordination.
  • Advancing "epidemic intelligence" tools that can operate across diverse national jurisdictions.
  • Maintaining an active dialogue between regional, national, and international bodies to ensure technology development aligns with practical public health needs.

Ultimately, the session serves as a call to action for researchers and engineers to prioritize the "connective tissue" of healthcare technology—the standards and protocols—over the development of isolated tools.

Summary updated

Abstract

Public Health in the European Union is mainly a formal competence of the Member States. EU Treaties and Regulations have given EU gradually more mandate in past decades on issues of surveillance, epidemic intelligence, early warning and cross-border response coordination. In this context, sharing timely information on public health threats (fast and slow) to inform interventions at national and EU level, remains of great added value for all Member States. This depends on common standards, compatibility and interoperability of information systems. In this session, panellists will share their experience and recent digital health developments from the perspective of regional, national and international public health and discuss this in the light of developments in digital technology.
BibTeX
@misc{laarmann2019challenges,
  author = {Heli Laarmann and Clayton Hamilton and A Bosman and Rodolphe Thiébaut and Umair A. Shah and Caroline Wood and Patty Kostkova},
  title = {{The Challenges of Implementing Healthcare Technology and Innovation Across Europe and Beyond}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1145/3357729.3365106},
}
Figure