THE CHALLENGE OF BALANCING ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY WITH ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY

Mark Lee, David Stinson, Ma LinaInternational Journal of Strategic Management 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the high-stakes tension between corporate economic survival and the urgent mandate for environmental sustainability in a volatile post-pandemic world. The authors argue that for organizations to survive the transition to a green economy, they must move beyond the ideological standoff between "die-hard capitalists" and "hard-core environmentalists" by adopting comprehensive structural and strategic changes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors tackle the "sustainability gap"—the growing chasm between the practical economic realities of running a business and the increasing pressure from governments, the public, and environmental groups to adopt green practices.

In the current "post-pandemic age," organizations are facing a "polycrisis": recovering from a global pandemic while simultaneously navigating wars, recessions, and high interest rates. Within this high-pressure environment, the authors identify a lack of "middle ground." On one side, environmental mandates are becoming more stringent; on the other, the economic cost of compliance threatens the very existence of many firms. The paper seeks to answer a critical question: How can a company improve its economic performance while simultaneously moving toward environmental sustainability without collapsing under the weight of the transition?

Methods

This is a qualitative management and strategy paper. Rather than using laboratory experiments or computational algorithms, the authors employ a literature review and conceptual framework analysis.

The primary analytical lens used is the Stinson organizational wellness model. This framework is applied to examine how organizational decision-making, restructuring, and change management can be synchronized to meet both fiscal and ecological goals. The paper bridges the gap between theoretical academic literature and the "practical realities" of modern business operations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a conceptual and strategic review, the paper does not rely on a specific empirical dataset (like a survey or a large-scale statistical database). Instead, it draws on contemporary economic trends (e.g., CNBC CEO Roundtable data) and existing management literature to build its argument.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Polycrisis" Context: Sustainability cannot be viewed in a vacuum. The authors highlight that organizations are currently overwhelmed by a volume of issues—inflation, interest rates, and geopolitical instability—that make long-term environmental planning difficult but necessary.
  • The False Dichotomy: A major hurdle identified is the ideological polarization between "hard-core environmentalists" and "die-hard capitalists." The authors argue that this "unwillingness to budge an inch" is a systemic risk that could lead to widespread business failure and job loss during the green transition.
  • Sustainability as Structural Change: The paper posits that environmental sustainability is not a "bolt-on" feature or a PR exercise. It requires deep organizational and structural restructuring.
  • The Role of Organizational Wellness: By using the Stinson model, the authors suggest that a "well" organization is one that can balance these competing external pressures through internal structural agility.

Key Results

While the paper is theoretical rather than quantitative, its primary "results" are strategic conclusions:

  • Compromise is a Survival Trait: The authors conclude that "balance, compromise, and the meeting of minds" are currently in short supply but are the only path forward for economic survival.
  • Transition Risk: The paper warns that without a comprehensive approach to balancing these two types of sustainability, a significant number of companies will not survive the transition, leading to a "corresponding loss of jobs throughout the economy."
  • Strategic Integration: The authors find that economic performance and environmental goals must be addressed as a single, integrated strategic challenge rather than two separate departments or goals.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * High-Level Abstraction: As an introductory exploration, the paper focuses more on identifying the challenges than providing a granular, industry-specific "how-to" guide. * Geographic Scope: While the authors represent institutions in Canada and China, the initial discussion leans heavily on Western economic contexts (e.g., CNBC references).

Future Work: * The authors suggest a need for more comprehensive ways to move companies toward a sustainable future, implying that further research should focus on the specific "organizational and structural issues" that arise during this transition. * Future studies could involve applying the Stinson organizational wellness model to specific case studies of companies that have successfully navigated this balance to provide a roadmap for others.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Balancing environmental sustainability with the economic realities’ businesses face has become a daunting task for both for-profit and not-for-profit organizations world-wide. This paper will explore some of the challenges and opportunities facing these organizations, as well as some of the difficult strategic decisions that are going to need to be made that will have serious repercussions for people, companies, and society as a whole. In examining the literature and the practical realities of sustainability, and the existing pressures most businesses are facing today, the goal of this paper is to seek how we can improve corporate economic performance while at the same time moving toward environmental sustainability. Keywords Environmental sustainability; economic sustainability; strategic choices; restructuring organizations; organizational change; organizational decision-making; Stinson organizational wellness model.
BibTeX
@article{lee2023challenge,
  author = {Mark Lee and David Stinson and Ma Lina},
  title = {{THE CHALLENGE OF BALANCING ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY WITH ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY}},
  journal = {International Journal of Strategic Management},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.18374/ijsm-23-1.7},
}
Figure