The Cause and Evolution of Urban Street Vitality under the Time Dimension: Nine Cases of Streets in Nanjing City, China

Xiaodong Xu, Xinhan Xu, Peng Guan, Yu Ren, Wei Wang, Ning XuSustainability 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a novel framework to assess urban street vitality by incorporating the crucial dimension of time, moving beyond static analyses. By examining nine streets in Nanjing across different development eras, the research reveals that older, more established streets often exhibit higher vitality due to a better balance of form, business, and accessibility, suggesting that time and evolution play a significant role in shaping vibrant urban spaces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban street vitality is a key indicator of a comfortable, human-centered public environment and contributes to urban sustainability. While existing research often focuses on single or multiple factors influencing vitality, it largely overlooks the impact of time and the evolutionary process of urban development. This is a significant gap, as cities are dynamic entities, and their streetscapes change over decades. The paper aims to address this by investigating how street vitality differs across streets built in distinct historical periods (old, main, and new urban areas) and how this temporal dimension interacts with various influencing factors. Understanding this temporal evolution is crucial for effective urban planning and the creation of sustainable, vibrant urban spaces.

Methods

The study proposes a comprehensive framework for assessing street vitality that considers three main factors: street form, street business type, and street accessibility. Each of these factors is further broken down into several subfactors:

  • Street Form:
    • Street density (building area vs. allocated area)
    • Street continuity (building-to-line ratio)
    • Street height-width ratio
  • Street Business Type:
    • Street store density (number of stores per 100m)
    • Street function density (number of functions per 100m)
    • Permeation rate of frontage businesses (transparent wall length vs. total wall length)
  • Street Accessibility:
    • Street location (distance to residential areas/business facilities)
    • Number of entrances/exits
    • Public transportation availability (metro stations, bus stops, vehicle frequency)
    • Walkability (assessed through various environmental factors)

Data for these subfactors were collected through field measurements, Google Street View, traffic apps, and urban planning data. A quantitative analysis was performed for each subfactor, and a ranking method was employed to compare the impact of each factor on street vitality and to visualize the combined impact of multiple factors. This ranking method assigns a numerical rank (1-9) to each street for each subfactor, allowing for a comparative assessment.

Datasets

The study utilizes a dataset of nine streets in Nanjing City, China, categorized into three groups based on their construction period:

  • Old Urban Area: Streets built around 1990.
  • Main Urban Area: Streets built around 2000.
  • New Urban Area: Streets built around 2010 (Hexi area).

The data collected for these streets included:

  • Field measurements of street characteristics.
  • Google Street View imagery.
  • Traffic application data for transportation information.
  • Urban planning administration data.
  • Official transportation app data for Nanjing.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing data sources were leveraged for analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Time is a critical, often overlooked, factor in street vitality: The study strongly suggests that street vitality is not static but evolves over time. Older streets, despite potentially having worn-out infrastructure, often possess a more established and vibrant character due to their longer evolutionary process.
  • Balance is key: High street vitality is achieved through a synergistic combination of factors, rather than excelling in just one. Even with modern infrastructure, new urban areas can lack vitality if other elements are not well-integrated.
  • Street form matters, especially enclosure: Streets with a suitable height-to-width ratio (promoting enclosure) and good continuity tend to foster higher vitality. Wide streets in new urban areas, while modern, can lead to a weak sense of enclosure and reduced street activity.
  • Accessibility drives engagement: Proximity to residential areas, good public transportation, and a walkable environment are crucial for attracting people and promoting street life.
  • New urban areas face a "vitality paradox": Despite modern construction and amenities, new urban areas in the study exhibited lower street vitality, likely due to a lack of established street culture, weaker enclosure, and less integrated human-scale design.

Key Results

  • Highest Vitality Streets: Pipa Street and Wufu Street (main urban area) and Hongmiao Street (old urban area) demonstrated the highest street vitality.
  • Temporal Trend: Street vitality in new urban areas was consistently lower compared to old and main urban areas.
  • Street Form Impact:
    • Building density and continuity were generally higher in old and main urban areas, correlating with higher vitality.
  • The street height-to-width ratio was found to be more conducive to vitality when it approached or exceeded 1, promoting a sense of enclosure. Pipa Street, with the lowest height-to-width ratio (0.64), ranked highest in vitality, suggesting that a reduction in this ratio can be beneficial.
  • Business Type Impact: Store density was higher in old and main urban areas. Permeation rates showed less significant differences across urban areas.
  • Accessibility Impact: Old and main urban areas generally had better public transportation accessibility and a higher number of entrances/exits. While new urban areas had good walkability environments, their overall vitality was lower.
  • Songhuajiang Street (new urban area) had the lowest vitality, exhibiting low rankings across most subfactors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lingering Time: The study acknowledges that street vitality is influenced not only by the number of active people but also by the duration they spend on the street. However, comprehensively measuring and recording lingering time was difficult, and the study primarily relied on the number of people as an indicator.
  • Data Insufficiency for Time Span: The investigation period of 30 years meant that some street environment factors might have had insufficient historical data for a complete analysis. More cases and a longer time span would be beneficial for comparative analysis.
  • Representativeness of Cases: The representativeness of the selected nine streets for a broader urban context warrants further discussion.
  • Impact of Virtual Environments: The rise of online consumption and e-commerce has reduced physical shopping time. Future research should consider the impact of virtual environments on street vitality.
  • Future Work Suggestions:
    • Enhance street vitality in new urban areas by optimizing influencing factors, such as increasing street density, continuity, store density, and the frequency of public transportation.
  • Conduct more statistical characterizations and analyze larger datasets from time-varied urban areas to establish more accurate quantitative correlations between influencing factors, time, and street vitality.
  • Provide more precise insights for urban planning, street vitality construction, and guidelines for sustainable urban development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Street vitality is associated with a comfortable human-based public environment and urban sustainability. In most current studies, street vitality is assessed considering single or multi factors; however, the impact of time dimension is ignored. This study selects nine different year-built streets in old, main, and new urban areas, in Nanjing, China, proposes a framework to assess street vitality considering the different time dimensions and selects the following factors: street form, including building density, continuity, and height-width; street business type, including store density, function density, and permeation rate; and street accessibility, including location, the number of entrances/exits, transportation, and walkability. After calculating the values of the subfactors, a ranking method was applied to assign the ranking of impact of all factors for a comprehensive analysis. The results showed that Pipa Street, Wufu Street in a main urban area, and Hongmiao Street had the highest street vitality and the highest rankings of almost all the factors. Street vitality in different periods demonstrated that street vitality in new urban areas is lower compared with old and main urban areas.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2018cause,
  author = {Xiaodong Xu and Xinhan Xu and Peng Guan and Yu Ren and Wei Wang and Ning Xu and Wei Wang and Ning Xu},
  title = {{The Cause and Evolution of Urban Street Vitality under the Time Dimension: Nine Cases of Streets in Nanjing City, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/su10082797},
}
Figure