The Case for an Early Biological Origin of DNA

Anthony M. Poole, Nobuyuki Horinouchi, Ryan Catchpole, Dayong Si, Makoto Hibi, Kōichi Tanaka, Jun OgawaJournal of Molecular Evolution 2014 · DOI

Abstract

All life generates deoxyribonucleotides, the building blocks of DNA, via ribonucleotide reductases (RNRs). The complexity of this reaction suggests it did not evolve until well after the advent of templated protein synthesis, which in turn suggests DNA evolved later than both RNA and templated protein synthesis. However, deoxyribonucleotides may have first been synthesised via an alternative, chemically simpler route—the reversal of the deoxyriboaldolase (DERA) step in deoxyribonucleotide salvage. In light of recent work demonstrating that this reaction can drive synthesis of deoxyribonucleosides, we consider what pressures early adoption of this pathway would have placed on cell metabolism. This in turn provides a rationale for the replacement of DERA-dependent DNA production by RNR-dependent production.

Introduction: Challenging the "RNA-First, DNA-Late" Dogma

The standard "RNA World" hypothesis posits that life began with RNA molecules serving as both genetic repositories and catalysts. In this view, DNA is a latecomer, arriving only after complex protein enzymes—specifically ribonucleotide reductases (RNRs)—evolved to synthesize its building blocks. This "top-down" evolutionary perspective assumes that because modern RNRs are sophisticated and utilize dangerous free-radical chemistry, DNA-based inheritance could not have predated the establishment of templated protein synthesis.

However, this timeline creates a conceptual conflict: if DNA appeared so late, why is the core machinery of all known life so fundamentally centered on it? We propose a "bottom-up" alternative: DNA may have emerged much earlier via a chemically simpler metabolic shortcut, potentially placing DNA-based inheritance alongside the earliest stages of life's evolution.

The RNR Paradox and the DERA Shortcut

Modern deoxyribonucleotide synthesis relies on RNRs, which are incredibly complex enzymes. They require intricate protein structures to manage free radicals that would otherwise destroy fragile RNA molecules. This complexity is the primary reason scientists have historically assumed a late origin for DNA.

We argue that an alternative pathway exists: the reversal of the deoxyriboaldolase (DERA) reaction. While DERA typically functions in the salvage pathway to break down DNA components into acetaldehyde and glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate, its reverse reaction can synthesize deoxyribose-5-phosphate from these simple precursors.

Comparison of the complex RNR mechanism (A) with the chemically simpler DERA-based synthetic route (B).

Crucially, the DERA pathway is chemically simple enough that it could have been catalyzed by early ribozymes (catalytic RNA) or primitive proteins, bypassing the need for the sophisticated radical chemistry of RNRs. This pathway would have allowed early organisms to utilize DNA as a "safe room"—a more stable storage medium for genetic information as genomes grew in size and complexity.

Evolutionary Evidence and the Last Universal Common Ancestor (LUCA)

To support this early-origin hypothesis, we analyzed the distribution of deoxyribonucleotide salvage enzymes across the three domains of life. Bioinformatic searches of the NCBI non-redundant protein database and pHMMER analysis revealed that enzymes for the DERA-dependent pathway are ubiquitous in Bacteria, Archaea, and Eukarya. This suggests that the pathway is ancient and was likely present in the Last Universal Common Ancestor (LUCA).

This early adoption may have been further driven by viral interactions; as suggested by Patrick Forterre, DNA might have originated in viruses as a defense against host RNA-degrading enzymes before being captured by cellular life. The apparent differences in modern DNA replication machinery across domains do not necessarily imply a late, independent origin of DNA. Instead, these differences can be explained by "non-orthologous gene displacement" (NOGD), where ancestral genes are replaced by functional equivalents over time.

Two models for DNA evolution: Model A (standard late origin) vs. Model B (proposed early origin pre-LUCA), incorporating non-orthologous gene displacement (NOGD).

The Transition to RNR

If the DERA pathway was the original route to DNA, why did RNR eventually take over? The DERA pathway is reversible and produces toxic intermediates like acetaldehyde, making it metabolically "messy" for a maturing cell. In contrast, RNR-mediated synthesis is irreversible and highly regulated, allowing for the precise control of deoxyribonucleotide pools necessary for high-fidelity replication in complex organisms.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The DERA-dependent pathway provides a plausible chemical bridge from an RNA world to a DNA world. While this hypothesis challenges long-held assumptions, it is supported by genomic ubiquity and the chemical feasibility of the DERA reaction.

Future research should focus on "synthetic biology" proofs-of-concept. Specifically, can a modern organism like E. coli survive if its RNR genes are replaced by an overexpressed DERA-based pathway? Furthermore, in vitro evolution (SELEX) could be used to search for ribozymes capable of catalyzing the DERA reaction, providing definitive proof that an RNA-based ancestor could have managed the chemistry of DNA synthesis.

Summary updated

Abstract

All life generates deoxyribonucleotides, the building blocks of DNA, via ribonucleotide reductases (RNRs). The complexity of this reaction suggests it did not evolve until well after the advent of templated protein synthesis, which in turn suggests DNA evolved later than both RNA and templated protein synthesis. However, deoxyribonucleotides may have first been synthesised via an alternative, chemically simpler route--the reversal of the deoxyriboaldolase (DERA) step in deoxyribonucleotide salvage. In light of recent work demonstrating that this reaction can drive synthesis of deoxyribonucleosides, we consider what pressures early adoption of this pathway would have placed on cell metabolism. This in turn provides a rationale for the replacement of DERA-dependent DNA production by RNR-dependent production.
BibTeX
@article{poole2014case,
  author = {Anthony M. Poole and Nobuyuki Horinouchi and Ryan Catchpole and Dayong Si and Makoto Hibi and Kōichi Tanaka and Jun Ogawa},
  title = {{The Case for an Early Biological Origin of DNA}},
  journal = {Journal of Molecular Evolution},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1007/s00239-014-9656-6},
}
Figure